r/SSBPM•
PlayOnSunday

Mind over Meta 12 - The Supporting Character (Presented by OrangeGluon!)

Hey guys, Sunday here! I'll be writing the normal stuff in a comment below to save space. This weeks article is by u/orangegluon, so I'll let him take it away!


THE SIDE DISHES

We all see this post at least once a week: “Who should I pick as a secondary? I main Falco, Marth, Mewtwo, Pacman, Ryu, Dwayne Johnson, and Dante from Devil May Cry.” This week, we’ll try to give some insight into answering that question. First, we should lay out the ground; what is a secondary? In any fighting game at any level of play, players choose between picking from a subset of the characters, often among more than one character, to use in their next bout against a foe. Typically, a player might choose their “main,” or the character they invest the most time in training. As a result, this character is usually their “best” or most “developed” character. We’ve spent a post talking about mains and what they mean. But most players also have other characters they can feel comfortable using at moment’s notice, characters who the players probably have trained to high levels but are not seen as often or as strongly associated with the player. These are secondaries, characters you play a lot, but aren’t your “main.” They are also sometimes called “pocket” characters, in that you keep them hidden until specific situations, snug in your back pocket till they need to strike.

While you should certainly restrict the breadth of your main and secondary characters to a small handful to reach the highest levels of play (let’s be clear on this!), secondaries are an important aspect of competitive play, and one that can sometimes make all the difference. It’s a part of play that is frequently skipped in meta-analysis because mains tend to take spotlights, so I thought we should spend some time to look at what secondaries are and what they do for players.

(Aside: Much of these examples will be in the context of Melee, but with the increased viability of all 41 PM characters, it probably applies even more in PM, and maybe even 64, Smash4, and others).


NUMBER 2s

So why might a player keep a secondary? The first answer that comes to mind is that more characters are fun (take it from me). Project M, and even Melee, Brawl, Smash4, and 64, all have a common selling point: a huge cast of characters, so it’d be a shame to ignore 95% of a game with a lot of love put in just to only pick Fox on FD. I get a lot of fun out of playing a variety of characters. But we’re focusing on competitive play, so let’s look at some competitive reasons you might pick up secondaries.

In tournaments, is having a secondary in the wings a good idea? In my opinion, almost certainly (once you’re at a stage of play that you’re comfortable with your main, that is). However, this comes at a cost: any time in training you devote to your secondaries is time that could’ve been spent in training your main. In this way, there is big opportunity cost involved in grooming your secondaries, especially if you don’t use them often. In the long run, half-hearted secondaries won’t match your hopes whenever you bust them out, so while they don’t need to be perfect, they do need to be competent, and building that does take time and effort out of a typical training session.

That said, I don’t mean to dissuade you from picking secondaries. I am only cautioning you that there is a trade-off in picking up an extra character, so going overboard with “secondaries” means that while you do have variety, that variety is superficial and underdeveloped, which is counterproductive in the long run. Warnings aside, let’s look at some advantages of having secondaries or pocket characters.


THE SUBSTITUTION

In tourney play, the most apparent reason to have secondary characters is for problematic matchups. Sheik against Ganondorf, for example, is considered to be a problematic matchup for Ganon. While chain grab d-throws and powerful aerials are good advantages for Ganondorf, he gets chaingrabbed even harder, and has a difficult time catching the tricky ninja b*****d, especially when Sheik’s needles make it hard to close the distance across a stage. So Ganondorf is forced to tough out these annoying problems, OR, they can pick a different character with a better shot against Sheik, such as Fox or Falco. Many characters in Melee are demoted to mid- or low-tier largely due to matchups against Sheik, so you’ll often see mid-tier players keep pocket characters like Fox and Falco, or other specific characters to play niche matchups.

MOR|Axe is a notable example here, a Melee Pikachu main who has recently placed well in major tournaments. However, a scan through Youtube shows that he also plays a very mean and technical Falco, which he can theoretically use against Sheik (even if his Pikachu play is high enough not to usually need the switch). Axe also can use his precise Young Link to great effect against floaty characters like Jigglypuff or Peach, applying a powerful projectile game that controls the air, despite being a much lower tier character than those flying cotton candies. So, if you pick up secondaries, you should consider the strengths and weaknesses of your main and secondaries, and how they can support each other by patching up disadvantages. For example, in Project M, a Bowser main might learn Falco for a character with a strong neutral game, or a Wolf main could pick up Kirby to live consistently at high percents. These kinds of considerations are important to beat problematic characters or tough opponents.

So, when you choose to pick up secondary characters, it is important to think about what weaknesses and strengths your main and secondaries share, and how they might patch up the others’ disadvantages, such as Falco’s lasers helping a usually-Bowser main to win the neutral, or Kirby’s recovery letting a Wolf main live at high percents consistently. These considerations help greatly in both playing particular against characters and playing particular opponents’ styles.

The flip side of this is that in matchups where your main character will dominate the opponent’s, clever foes might counterpick certain secondary characters against you. What will we do?! We forfeit and hope that loser’s bracket will be free, right…?

NOT. We either slug through the suddenly worse matchup or we can counter their counterpicked character and gain the advantage back! (In some scenarios, this can become a layered mindgame, each player trying to outpredict the other’s choice, making for exciting sets.) Take a look at this Melee set between Hungrybox (famous Puff) and Armada (famous Peach) from Apex 2013.

“Game 1: Armada (Young Link) vs. Hbox (Ness).” “What?! That’s neither Puff nor Peach!” What happened is this: Peach is known to have a traditionally difficult matchup against Jigglypuff. Armada knows this, remembering Genesis grand finals against young Mango’s fabled Puff. Realizing that at the highest levels of play, outplaying Jigglypuff would be dangerous with Peach, Armada opted to use Young Link, whose advantages were summarized a few paragraphs ago. Hungrybox foresaw the switch, knowing that his Puff would struggle hard against a projectile-heavy Young Link, so he switched to Ness, whose forward air, double jump momentum, and strong throws would give him some advantage by neutralizing incoming projectiles, helping weave through attacks, and allowing powerful kill options. As a result, two rarely-played low-tier characters faced off in a highly dynamic match in utmost seriousness. Unfortunately, HBox was not proficient enough to top Armada’s Young Link this time, and he ended up having more success switching back to Puff (as I had mentioned earlier, if your secondaries are not in good enough condition, they will not carry their weight effectively in these crucial matches: perhaps had Hbox known the Puff vs. YLink matchup better, or had a stronger Ness, the set would have turned out differently).


REQUESTING BACKUP

Another reason to have secondaries ready is in case your mains underperform. Spacey mains know this feeling; C9|Mango has stated that the Spacies are like “rock stars,” in that they can perform amazingly on a given day, but often can tank hard if a player’s tech skill is off, or they aren’t “in the zone,” or they mentally break down, or their hands just don’t work. In that case, it’s good to have backup characters who, while less finessed, can be still used comfortably, regardless of matchup.

Surely this strategy can’t be successful, it simply doesn’t make sense to use a suboptimal character when your main is your best one, right? Let’s consult Melee Falco maven Dr.PP from his interview with EG post-Apex 2015, after he bested Armada in Grand Finals with Marth:

“Falco actually gave me LOADS of momentum ... so I was glad the switch [back to Falco] worked out. Armada ended up taking me to Dreamland game 5, and basically, if I stayed Falco I would have to fight his Peach due to the way the counterpick system works. Neither Marth nor Falco are good on Dreamland, so that wasn't really an issue. I lost the Falco vs Peach matchup quite badly when Armada and I played it in Winners Semis. So I made a choice: I decided to go back to Marth and just spend the match learning instead of trying to win. I needed to get a better advantage out of cornering him and he had always avoided corner pressure so well before. If one watches the match, I end up putting all of the information about his game together and end up nearly making a 3 stock comeback! So I think that could have definitely been a good sign of what I was going to do the next set. I essentially used a long-term strategy that ended up helping to cover my character's stage weakness by exploiting my opponent.”

A beautiful example of success with a secondary: PP’s comfort with Marth vs. Armada’s Fox (Armada’s own secondary), rather than Falco vs Peach (both players’ mains), let him mentally sit back and spend an entire game studying and “downloading” his opponent’s style on Dreamland, and then reversing momentum suddenly in the second set, rather than focus and miss key details that could cost him Grand Finals. Marth pulled enormous weight here: he protected PP’s main from getting destroyed by Armada’s Peach again with nothing to show for it, and he brought the fight to a playing field where PP had the psychological advantage, even on a stage which gave Armada’s Fox the advantage -- a bout between secondaries. I would call this a tactical brilliance, much like in chess, where a seemingly dubious move, using a subpar “bishop” rather than “queen” turned out to be ingenious and win the checkmate.

As an additional point, PP spent a large portion of Top 8 at Apex winning with Marth instead of Falco, including important games against Leffen’s Fox (his main), a match which arguably could have been a big struggle for Dr.PP’s Falco, when Dr.PP wasn’t “feeling falco-y.” In both the particular matchup and PP’s own feelings at that moment, Marth was the correct choice.


NEW PUNCHING BAGS

So outside of brackets directly, what good could secondaries do for you? One last possible application of using secondaries that I’d like to mention is training, both for yourself and others.

Firstly, playing multiple characters helps yourself grow to some extent, as learning more techniques with a character makes you more aware of the matchup against that character. It also gives you skills that carry over to your other characters if you can incorporate them as good habits. For example, the importance of spacing with Marth might help you learn Zero Suit Samus, or playing with Fox might help your tech skill fingers with Wolf and Pikachu. This is a topic that I think deserves fair analysis as well, and one which I hope to cover in more detail in a future Mind Over Meta in a more general context (hinting hinterinos).

Secondly, having secondaries helps you understand matchups in more detail. If someone is, say, a Metaknight main and decides to learn Yoshi as a secondary, then Yoshis who come up against him in tournament won’t be as much of a surprise. When is the last time someone beat you in bracket with a character you have almost no experience fighting? Chances are, it wasn’t too long ago. Playing some small variety of characters outside your main will at least give you the experience to know other characters’ threats and weaknesses. Consider another example from Apex 2015’s Melee Top 8: top Fox player Leffen vs. fan favorite Yoshi player aMSa. Leffen, while known for an intense Fox, actually began as a Yoshi player, and therefore was less surprised by aMSa’s nifty Yoshi movement and tricks. This, too, is an aspect of pre-play that I’d like to discuss in future in broader contexts (hintus hintus).

The last thing I’d like to mention is that secondaries are great for training others. Say your friends are having trouble with a particular Roy at tournaments. If you happen to have a pocket Roy, you can use it to teach your friends how to beat that character, while strengthening your Roy at the same time. By wailing on them til they get it right, you improve your friends’ matchup knowledge and insight purely through play. The more powerful and more intricately you understand your secondary Roy, the more that your peers can learn from you. This is especially important in situations like crew battles, where your success is largely dependent on your teammates’ matchup knowledge, especially in more obscure matchups, or against players who are extremely well-versed in particular characters. Every advantage could be worth the effort in crews, and in that sense, if you can play those problem characters as secondaries, partial responsibility falls on you to educate them toward success.


FINAL REMARKS

I feel that secondary characters are an under-examined part of gameplay in both analysis and self-analysis of players. As several examples showed, they add a dynamic part of the metagame surrounding fighting games like Smash (especially one with a cast as large as Project M’s). It can definitively swing battles in one direction or another, even at the highest level of play. While focus should definitely be on mains, careful attention to developing properly polished secondaries and clever decision-making can improve your competitive success by leaps and bounds.

Thanks for reading this article; I hope that my analysis is accurate and makes sense. This is my first large-sized analysis of Project M, and I’m honored to be able to contribute to the community through MoM, so thanks for giving me a chance. Shoutouts to u/locaux (Chroma09) and Applejacks, who offered some insight into this post, and to u/L_Pag for editing+revising. We’ll see you next week with another Mind Over Meta. Take care!

Posted Mar 1, 2015, 9:55 PM UTC · edited

5736
Loading comments…