VeganSnakusAlta Vista•

I'm a little surprised they didn't have the power to do this already. I just assumed that, based on the number of cars I see where you can't even tell if someone is in it, enforcement was selective.

27
elementalist467OP•

The legal standard is currently subjective. Most aftermarket shops will recommend at least 30% light permissibility; however, that isn't codified. They are asking for 70% which is a very light tint. As a motorist with tinted windows, I am against this; however, I will rip off my front tints if they become illegal.

11
TheXenochristSouth Keys•

Takes a lot more work than just ripping then off.

2
Golanthanatos•

this guy is correct, residue left over from the tint's adhesive is enough to cause another fail using the photosensors they use in quebec.

3
jwalton78•

Which tells you something about the accuracy of said photosensors.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
djmorHull•

Remember, when driving in quebec 70% is the darkest you're allowed. They'll fine you and make you rip it off right there, or tow your car. Happened to me. They're assholes. 150$ fine if I recall correctly.

0
greasedonkey•

My friend was fined but they didn't ask him to remove it.

1
djmorHull•

Your buddy's cop was a sure sight nicer than mine. I had to take a razor blade to the car window to remove all that fucking glue.

0
JustHachLowertown•

From what I learned in driver's ed (but this was a while ago), they can cite you if they can't see you clearly through the windows, or if they believe that you could have a hard time seeing out of the vehicle. It's up to you to prove otherwise or pay the fine.

3
ottguy74•

I always thought they did this already. You learn something new every day. But what about night time, how much can you see inside a car as you approach it. I guess I ask because I guess I still question the motive behind this request.

But I don't care, my car has no tint.

2
danaunsRiverside South•

I'm OK with this. From a safety perspective, seeing who is driving, seat belts, etc, is important. It's a weird one though, I am typically a fan of less being more. Less government, less laws, less intervention from 'the man.' In this case, simply ensuring that drivers remain in plain sight is not a lot to ask. ............also, as a father of kids who play on the street, I have taught my kids to make eye contact with drivers. Until you make eye contact, assume that the driver is not aware that you are on the road. Not being able to make eye contact is a bad thing. When I drive even, at a 4 way stop - not being able to see the driver (often through the drivers window) would be a pain in the ass.

14
elementalist467OP•

You realize windshields are already restricted in tinting (you are allowed a band at the top no more than one third down the windshield). Eye contact with pedestrians and other motorists primarily occurs through the front glass. Further most aftermarket tints aren't 5% limo tints. The most common aftermarket tints are 20% and 30% light permissible. Based on my own experience, I have never felt visibility inappropriately compromised at 30% (20% is a bit dark for my tastes). The major advantage for me in window tinting is that the vehicle rejects heat much more effectively. It means the A/C cools it down more quickly and it doesn't heat up as fast when parked.

3
danaunsRiverside South•

Meh. You have your opinion, I have mine. I'm more of a windows open (or roof off) kind of guy myself, my AC is almost never used. Another argument for this, would be to discourage and detect distracted driving ........god damn knuckleheads texting and driving. There are fine and valid reasons on both sides of the issue that I agree with. I think having policy in place to limit the amount of tint makes sense, and far outweighs the alternative.

Arguments against the policy - seem to be rooted in personal, aesthetic, even individual preference.

Arguments for a policy like this - seem rooted in public safety.

6
elementalist467OP•

I haven't seen the public safety arguments backed by evidence. There are lots of jurisdictions to compare with tint bans.

3
SachyrielVanier•

What kind of evidence would be what you're looking for? Number of crashes from distracted drivers with tinted windows?

1
SmarchHare•

So, should sunglasses be outlawed, too?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Paddl3r•

50% would be reasonable. It helps keep your car cooler, providing you have a proper tint, keeps people from quickly trying to peer through your car windows for any sort of valuables as well.

I would rather them crack down on existing laws such as people running red lights, stop signs or the people blasting through the right hand turn lane just to go straight and almost wipe out 2 cars in the process.

10
AlexTheGreat•

Do people really still break into cars? Haven't heard of anyone having that happen in at least 10-15 years...

-11
SmarchHare•

Really? Yes, yes they do.

2
Officer_Copper•

They actually happen a lot but in the majority of cases people have left their doors unlocked.

1
NamesNotRudiger•

I really fail to see the importance of this, seems like the police just want another avenue to start generating some income from ticketing...

9
mageganker•

Gotta figure out a way to ticket self-driving cars.

4
Officer_Copper•

Well it's already an offence to have your front windows coated. It is just really hard to get a conviction on it because it is so subjective.

1
rockcanada•

Waste of time. Why don't you instead of looking at dark windows look at all the bad drivers in town first before having a concern with parked cars.

The safety issue is silly and just bullshit. If a bad guy had a gun he could have it on his lap or in his hand next to the door and nobody would know, even with the window down.

5
Smooth_McDouglette•

There might be a better argument in favor of this than mine, but I personally am sick of overtaking some crappy/careless/absent minded driver and not being able to

1 - Get a look at the face of this absolute monster

2 - Give them a good dose of the ol' stinkeye

I'm not concerned about the probably valid road safety concerns that tinted windows bring. I just want to exercise my petty tendencies when I drive, and I don't want a shaded pane of glass to get between me and my goals.

4
elementalist467OP•

There are likely better arguments. The case the officer presented lacked any kind of statistical basis. It amounted to "aftermarkets tints should be banned because they scare me". If he wants to show that the regulation is needed he should be able to cite statistical evidence that tints lead to more accidents or that other jurisdictions with these restrictions have had lower accident rates or fewer roadside police assaults/fatalities. This is an argument to restrict our freedom. We should at least demand it is well founded.

3
Smooth_McDouglette•

I'm not sure why you're telling me this. The only thing that I'm concerned about regarding tinted windows is that I can't easily vent my road rage onto other drivers.

For the record though, being able to make eye contact with another driver absolutely makes driving at least a little bit safer.

4
elementalist467OP•

How much safer? What was the reduction in collisions after bans were introduced in Quebec and Nova Scotia? If it was a 10% drop, that would be pretty compelling. If it was a 1% drop, that would be less compelling.

3
Smooth_McDouglette•
  1. The glass does not break in the manner intended by the manufacturer when a tint has been applied.

  2. Seeing out is not as clear. Deliver pizza for a few days. You'll realize that at night you can't see the numbers clearly enough to read them through even faint tint, but roll down your window and you can read them perfectly. Depending how severe the tint is, it becomes less and less easy to see out at night.

  3. Seeing in is difficult. When you're in the far right lane and someone is slightly ahead of you and in the far left lane, they may shoulder check to the right to see if you're also shoulder checking and intending to move to the center lane. If they can't see you inside, they have no idea what you're thinking of doing. Or if they're a pedestrian wanting to cross the street and they want to know if you see them or not before the walk in front of your car. Or an officer who wants to see your hands on a steering wheel and can't because of your tint. Or an ambulance/paramedic who can't see inside your car after an accident because of tint and then risks their life to save the occupants when you've already gotten out before they arrived.

5
Golanthanatos•

Just another cash grab tacked onto the photo-radar crap.

2
elementalist467OP•

It would be a temporary cash grab as it would effectively shut down tinting shops. I can't imagine the overall ticket revenues would be worth the bother. They could also make cars fail safety with tints which would whittle down the existing install base gradually.

1
Golanthanatos•

at least in quebec, the law applies to front windows, you can paint your rear windows mat black for all they care in quebec, so the tint shops might not be totally screwed, cause they can still tint the rear half of a car.

Reference: panel vans and trucks with no back window at all.

2
robotneedsbeer•

Turn this on it's head, is there any evidence showing tinting has a null effect? Do tinted window cars have the same accident rates (or fewer)? Do cars with tinted windows pose the same or fewer operational difficulties for the cops?

Generally when someone wants to do something new, something that has nothing to do with fundamental freedoms, they have to show that it's not going to cause problems for other people. It's not on the cops to prove tints dangerous or problematic, it's on the tint owners and proponents to show that it's safe. That's the way things are generally approved in Canada: if you want it, you have to prove it. It's not on the government, and more importantly the taxpayers, to do your advocacy for you.

0
elementalist467OP•

It isn't on tint owners to show it's safe. We have the benefit of the status quo. A regulatory change should evidence based. In the absence of good evidence, a plan should be developed to get that evidence.

0
Golanthanatos•

they pop people for bullshit like this in quebec, one of my friends has been repeatedly pulled over for her OEM tint being too dark, that's the one that's integrated into the windows that came with her car from the factory, so 3-4 times/year she has to go to court and fight a ticket over something she CAN'T change.

That's the windows the way they came from the factory, fairly new vehicle sold in canada.

4
wilsky25•

Of course they do, and then they have even more bullshit reasons to pull people over and give them tickets. The only type of tint that should be banned is 5% tint, which is commonly called limo tint. The problem with this is, I have 20% on my car, and during a sunny day you can see right into it, but on a rainy night it is literally pitch black. So I would be getting pulled over at night all the time for tint that is perfectly fine during the day.

2
TheXenochristSouth Keys•

I tint all my cars 20% all around. Whenever I get pulled over, I make sure my window is rolled down before the officer gets out of his vehicle.
My buddy had 5% tint on his car, and driving at night was awful. You could barely see out of the rear window.

3
elementalist467OP•

I also do that. Window down and hands at ten and two. Brace for ticketing. "Good day Officer"

1
SmarchHare•

This seems like a good use of police resources

2
Welinder•

I would think a reputable glass/auto dealer would have a good understanding of what is legal.

2
elementalist467OP•

There is not a clear standard currently. The popular wisdom is that the police don't ticket at 30% and higher, but that isn't law.

2
Officer_Copper•

Canadian Tire still sells plastic licence plate covers which are completely illegal. But they will sell them anyway to make a few bucks.

2
Pr0ject_Mayhem•

Window tints are the scourge of our city. About time we cracked down on these criminal window tinting scum. I'd kill them myself if I could. There's probably a connection to texting here somewhere too.

We should divert some resources from the guns and gangs unit to put an end to this madness. I can live with frequent unsolved shootings. But this bedlam created by window tinting has to stop. Think of the children!

2
sanguichHintonburg•

This right here. Shit, even start by ticketing people for running stopsigns & red lights.

2
Gunboat_Willie•

Personally as a bike rider and pedestrian I have to say being able to make eye contact with drivers is important to me. While I can totally understand the police perspective in terms of officer safety.

I'm not a car driver so I can't speak for them but I would think that being able to see the person in the car next to you and whether or not they notice you etc would be beneficial.

2
elementalist467OP•

Generally speaking you interact with pedestrians through the front glass which is illegal to tint (except for a thin band at the top). If a driver is typically watching pedestrians at intersections through your side windows, they should start stopping before the crosswalk instead of on top of it.

2
Gunboat_Willie•

True, but when riding a bike and I am coming up to a vehicle it's nice to see the driver looking over at his mirror. I only mention this because twice I have had cars with totally tinted windows just pull around a car that is ahead of them and stopped (ie turning etc) and they just suddenly pull in front of me. To me it's just not about the driver of the vehicle being able to see, so much as being able to see the driver of the vehicle. Not to mention when they are backing out of parking spaces etc..

1
elementalist467OP•

I am trying to understand the geometry where the front two windows would be your sightline as a cyclist behind a motorist.

2
Gunboat_Willie•

Yeah sorry I was talking about tinted windows all around the vehicle. sorry about that, my bad.

1
ManofManyTalentz•

Yes yes yes. It's a safety thing for sure. Driver and passenger should have zero tint if you ask me. Rear seats whatever. I need to see the person driving.

2
JulesCee•

Not excited for this to happen, but I understand some of the reasoning. I have 20% on my car and if I'm making a turn on an unfamiliar, unlit road I sometimes roll it down to get a clearer view because it's just too dark.

1
NegScenePts•

Tinted windows are irritating. I hate not being able to see.

1
JonnyNostalgia•

Meanwhile they're rocking ghost cars with limo tint. I wonder if they'll give them up if they get their way.

1
elementalist467OP•

Who watches the watchmen?

It would be unlikely. They would argue operational necessity.

2
Officer_Copper•

That can't overwrite the law. Police vehicles still have to follow the rules unless their is a clear exemption. When police vehicles started using the wig-wag headlights they realized it was illegal and had to stop using them for a while until the HTA was amended

1
Officer_Copper•

Regardless of the % that the legislature agrees on, having the appropriate tools available to measure the % should be available and authorized by the law.

1
elementalist467OP•

If a % is legislated then I presumed such equipment would have to be issued to enable enforcement. My hope is that the tint regulated isn't a factory 70%.

1
kevin823•

They should focus on incarcerating muslims.

-4
AsianLocust•

BS!......maybe OPS should focus more on fighting crime. Sounds to me that they are strapped for cash!

-5
Officer_Copper•

Well this is the traffic unit talking about this. So it's really what they should be doing.

1