Concerning moderation and being constructive
Greetings folks. This is the first thread I start here, and I do it only in light of the recent moderator post ( http://www.reddit.com/r/MTGLegacy/comments/2zevfn/mod_post_on_discussion_and_respect_subreddit/ ) for otherwise, I would not have created it.
In it, we get confirmation that constructiveness is expected. I would assume that this means an expectation of being informed and/or wanting to be informed. I asked for clarification regarding that subject, and it apparently means what it means.
But then we get this. http://www.reddit.com/r/MTGLegacy/comments/2zys1k/simple_solution_to_rl_truth_about_chronicles/
A thread completely devoid of logical reasoning, full of false facts, and where the poster simply refuses to see he or she is wrong, and refuses to learn or otherwise verify the facts of his statements. A thread where no one can possibly get anything positive from, a thread where the only thing one can see is misinformation and ignorance.
And yet, here we are. The thread stays visible, and the poster is stubbornly sticking with his point of view using incomplete or flat out wrong concepts and premises, and nothing happens.
Where is the constructiveness? Why is nothing done? Is this not a clear cut case of a place where, AT LEAST, a moderator could jump in and say "this is wrong because of X, this is wrong because of Y", etc? Because at least a moderator might have a bit more credibility in the eyes of the poster than any other random poster here, and might actually help to enlighten someone who absolutely NEEDS to learn and improve.
If we are to be a community intent on actual constructive and positive discussion, how can nothing be done? How is the post and moderator guidelines coherent to nothing being done or said?
How nonconstructive must a post and/or thread be for moderator intervention to occur? Or was the constructive part of the moderator post and warning not really what it looked like?
Long story short, what truly can we expect from moderators here? Am I misunderstanding something? I appreciate any and all honest answer and/or opinion and thank everyone in advance for their time.
Posted Mar 24, 2015, 11:44 AM UTC