r/anime•
lambce

What's your favorite Studio Ghibili film (not just Miyazaki one's, but Takahata as well)?

Let me start out first by saying that none of these films are bad - I'd go as far as saying the worst one (whichever one that is for each of us) is still worlds better than all the BS coming out of Hollywood. Anyway, I did a thread earlier this week on series with the highest re-watch value, and it's no surprise Studio Ghibili films came up quite a bit. So I was wondering, r/anime, which Studio Ghibili film is your personal favorite, and why? Also, do you prefer the dubbed or subbed versions (some of the dubs are damn good if you ask me)?

Posted Mar 25, 2015, 2:36 PM UTC

327
Redcrimsonhttp://myanimelist.net/animelist/Redkrimson•

Princess Mononoke isn't just my favorite Ghibli film, it's pretty damn close to my favorite film period. It's a laser-focused conservation movie that still has enough breathing room for ambiguity and nuance. It's brimming with Miyazaki's gorgeous aesthetic work, but still has a sharply-written screenplay as well. It's got likable, iconic characters and a gripping blockbuster story that leaps off the screen. Princess Mononoke is smart, poignant, exciting, and strikingly beautiful. I think it's about as close to perfect as you can get in a 2-hour feature. Spirited Away may have won Miyazaki his Oscar, but there's no doubt in my mind that Princess Mononoke will go down in film history as his true masterpiece once he's gone for good.

10
mannoroth0913http://myanimelist.net/animelist/mannoroth0913•

I love you and everything you just posted. Those are my exact thought on Princess Mononoke and it will always be my favorite film and the one closest to my heart.

It was also the first anime I ever saw when I rented it on VHS from a Blockbuster as a child with my mom. While it'll always have a nostalgic factor, it will forever remain in my eyes as a masterpiece.

Edit: do you prefer the Japanese or English dub?

2
Redcrimsonhttp://myanimelist.net/animelist/Redkrimson•

Edit: do you prefer the Japanese or English dub?

I dunno, it's kind of a wash. Though I do love listening to Billy Bob Thornton and Minnie Driver chew the fuck out of the scenery.

2
mannoroth0913http://myanimelist.net/animelist/mannoroth0913•

They really do a great job. Since I can't help but drown in nostalgic love every I rewatch the film, the English dub I can't help but prefer.

2
x87823199xhttp://myanimelist.net/animelist/x87823199x•

all the BS coming out of Hollywood

Do you even movie?

8
ernietinkle•

Halfway to weeb, now he just needs to start talking in Japanese.

2
lambceOPhttp://myanimelist.net/animelist/lambce•

And grow the neckbeard, cause apparently that's a thing.

0
ernietinkle•

A neckbeard isn't a requirement for being a weeb, but for someone like you it would probably be preferable.

3
pittman66http://myanimelist.net/profile/pittman66•

Personally like Urban Dictionary's definition for Weeaboo

1
pittman66http://myanimelist.net/profile/pittman66•

I'd go as far as saying the worst one (whichever one that is for each of us) is still worlds better than all the BS coming out of Hollywood.

You really want to argue Tales of Earthsea is better than (Just naming films I personally like from just last year that I can remember) Birdman, Lego Movie, How to Train Your Dragon 2, The Grand Budapest Hotel, Interstellar? Every studio no matter how amazing their previous works or later works are has their bad moments, they're not invincible. And just cause you get 4 terrible parody films, romantic comedies, etc. from Hollywood doesn't mean there's absolutely nothing good coming out.

Anyway, onto the question, for me it's Spirited Away (With runner up being Naussica (if that counts as it was technically before Ghibli was an official studio)). I really think out of all the Ghibli film, this is easily the most atmospheric, imaginative, beautiful, and just an experience that I haven't seen to many animated films have hit. It's a film that isn't just enjoyable, but become engrossed into the world with the colors, music, and gorgeous backgrounds.

7
Maximal_Disguisedhttp://myanimelist.net/profile/MaxiTaku•

which Studio Ghibili film is your personal favorite

Princess Mononoke

do you prefer the dubbed or subbed version

I do prefer (german) dub on this one.

4
xGuernicahttp://myanimelist.net/profile/xDegausser•

Spirited Away will always be my favorite overall movie from Ghibli.

The Secret World of Arrietty contains my favorite soundtrack.

Nausicaa and the Valley of the Winds is my favorite of Ghibli's more "artsy" films.

Ponyo is my favorite of Ghibli's more "family" oriented (or just plain adorable) films.

3
aceofjunielhttp://myanimelist.net/animelist/azumula•

Howl's Moving Castle.

2
PixelPenguinshttp://myanimelist.net/profile/PixelPenguin•

My favorite has always been Only Yesterday. Such a simple story, but it's very beautiful. The main character is easy to connect with, and everything's paced perfectly. I think Only Yesterday is the only Ghibli film not to be dubbed, so you sub haters are out of luck unfortunately.

Here's how I'd rank the rest of them.

  1. Only Yesterday
  2. Princess Mononoke
  3. Spirited Away
  4. Grave of the Fireflies
  5. Tale of Princess Kaguya
  6. Kiki's Delivery Service
  7. From Up on Poppy Hill
  8. Pom Poko
  9. Ponyo
  10. My Neighbor Totoro
  11. Secret World of Arrietty
  12. Howl's Moving Castle
  13. When Marnie Was There
  14. Whisper of the Heart
  15. Tales from Earthsea
  16. Porco Rosso
  17. The Wind Rises
  18. Nausicaa
  19. Castle in the Sky
  20. The Cat Returns
  21. My Neighbors the Yamadas
  22. Ocean Waves
2
mannoroth0913http://myanimelist.net/animelist/mannoroth0913•

I started to complain about how you ranked them but they're all such amazing films I don't think I could ever compare them. They all bring something to the table and I love them all so much.

3
watashi-akashi•

I'm not alone! It's my favorite too, but nobody tends to have ever seen it.

Also funny: apart from our top 3/4, our lists are very, very different/ In terms of what I consider best to worst:

  1. Grave of the Fireflies
  2. Princess Mononoke
  3. Only Yesterday
  4. Spirited Away
  5. Porco Rosso
  6. Castle in the Sky
  7. Whisper of the Heart
  8. Nausicaa
  9. My Neighbor Totoro
  10. Kiki's Delivery Service
  11. Ocean Waves
  12. From Up On Poppy Hill
  13. Howl's Moving Castle
  14. My Neighbors the Yamadas
  15. Secret World of Arietty
  16. Ponyo
  17. Cat Returns
  18. Pom Poko
  19. Tales of Earthsea

Still have to watch Princess Kaguya and the Wind Rises though.

3
zeroryoko1974http://www.anime-planet.com/users/zeroryoko1974/anime/watching?i•

Whisper of the Heart is #1 to me, and then Spirited Away and Princess Mononoke.

  1. Whisper of the Heart
  2. Spirited Away
  3. Princess Mononoke
  4. Kiki's Delivery Service
  5. Totoro
  6. Nausicaa
  7. Graveyard of the Fireflies
  8. Ponyo
  9. Porco Rosso
  10. Castle in the Sky
  11. Arietty
  12. Wind Rises
  13. Cat Returns
  14. Pom Poko
  15. From Up on Poppy Hill
  16. Howl's Moving Castle
  17. Ocean Waves
  18. Princess Kaguya (not seen)
  19. Only Yesterday (not seen)
  20. Yamadas (not seen)
  21. Ghibli meseum short (not seen)
  22. Tales from Earthsea
2
PixelPenguinshttp://myanimelist.net/profile/PixelPenguin•

Heh, how are things you haven't seen better than Earthsea?? Taking the hate a bit far.

1
zeroryoko1974http://www.anime-planet.com/users/zeroryoko1974/anime/watching?i•

No, I am sure there are other Ghibli films I haven't seen that I would like better then Earthsea. Earthsea was a complete waste of time

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
AGuyFromRio•

Mononoke hime. Original audio, despite thinking japanese women sound like whiny little bitches sometimes.

In a very close second comes Chihiro no sen no kamikakushi and Grave of the fireflies.

Edit: typo.

-2
x87823199xhttp://myanimelist.net/animelist/x87823199x•

despite thinking japanese women sound like whiny little bitches sometimes

That has more to do with audience expectations than it does the actual cadence of your average Japanese woman.

3
AGuyFromRio•

I never dated an actual japanese girl. Couldn't know :p

1