r/kurdistan•
Decag

KDP Peshmerga fleeing the battlefield, being mocked by PUK Peshmerga

Posted Mar 29, 2015, 5:45 PM UTC

011
Axa2000Kurdistan•

Where is this battlefield?? Where's the fleeing? It's just some guy mouthing off and trash talking (which weirdly doesn't seem connected to the video) and even a kid runs down to the other vehicles..

Channel is "IraqEnglish" and if you look at their other uploaded videos you see exactly what their agenda is and their intentions are, typical of spreading bullshit against Kurds. So you can't trust this bullshit.

3
ReditskiOther•

OP is an Iranian guy who focusses more on Kurdistan than on Iran's theocracy and hypocrisy.

I can understand the OP somehow. Persians are quite nationalistic, and deep down they love Iranic culture and history. They see that Kurdistan is one of the last Iranic nations that still has an Iranic culture as the dominant culture instead of islamism/mullahism like Iran.

My brothers and sisters from Iran, you don't have to hide that you deep down love Kurdistan and hate mullahism. Just be honest, we will not discriminate you. You can be freely operate your Persian culture inside the KRG, we will not jail you because of listening to western music.

-1
DecagOP•

Honestly, I couldn't care less about Kurdistan for their ethnicity or "Iranic" traits, . I am content with Iran's borders and do not want them to change. I'm not a racist armchair imperialist.

"Iranic culture" IS Iran, a country where most Iranic peoples live together. The KRG was first under Ottoman control and then Arab control. Also Kurdistan is not a nation, but a region in Iraq. It certainly doesn't have Iranic culture as the dominant culture (what you really wanted to say was "pure" which is incredibly racist), it's a mixture of Communism, Turkish, Arabic and Kurdish culture. Which is all fine but if you're going to discuss "Iranic culture" then at least be accurate.

I don't think i'd enjoy the KRG, not only is it insecure and economically deprived, I don't like the racist ethnocentric ideology of the Kurds there. As you have demonstrated, you keep talking about "Iranic culture" whereas I have never once discussed it. I'm happy celebrating my Iranian culture in Iran.

If you want to know what my focus is, it's trying to find out why non-Iranian Kurds don't understand their history well and are so anti-Iranian. Perhaps it is what happens when you're an Ottoman and then Iraqi colony. Also probably because Barzani, who allied with the Turks and Saddam is anti-Iranian due to Iranian support for Talabani.

Still, having said all of that, I like non-Iranian kurds (it's a given I live those in Iran of course) and support them, just surprised at the level of racism and Iranphobia amongst them.

0
ReditskiOther•

Honestly, I couldn't care less about Kurdistan for their ethnicity or "Iranic" traits, . I am content with Iran's borders and do not want them to change. I'm not a racist armchair imperialist.

I also respect Iran's borders, and I think the Kurdish politicians too. You should also have respect for people outside of Iran's borders who want to legitimately execute their right for self-determination. Don't worry about Kurds trying to seceed from Iran, nobody is interested in that except from some fanatics. The KRG politicians see Iran as an ally, not as a rival.

"Iranic culture" IS Iran, a country where most Iranic peoples live together. The KRG was first under Ottoman control and then Arab control. Also Kurdistan is not a nation, but a region in Iraq.

Iranic culture refers to the culture of the Iranic people. Zoroastrianism for example. Shi'ite safavis weren't Iranic but islamist.

Also, Kurdistan is a nation. Just because it hasn't declared full independence, doesn't mean it isn't independent. It is de facto independent, if you have been there once in your life, you would have known. Do you even know that Iraqis can't come in the KRG without a visa?

It certainly doesn't have Iranic culture as the dominant culture (what you really wanted to say was "pure" which is incredibly racist), it's a mixture of Communism, Turkish, Arabic and Kurdish culture.

Communism? Don't project your prejudices on the KRG. PKK and Rojava are leftists, the KRG has nothing to do with communists. Turkish and Arabic culture? Again, are you referring to the KRG or to the PKK? You seem to mix things too much. Only Arabic element inside the KRG is Islam, besides that almost no youth people can speak Arabic. Your country is still ruled by Mullahs who rule their country based on Arabic teachings, the KRG doesn't do that.

I don't think i'd enjoy the KRG, not only is it insecure and economically deprived, I don't like the racist ethnocentric ideology of the Kurds there.

Economically deprived? Once again, you just show your ignorance. There are more than 10 000 Iranians who travel to the KRG with Nowruz and other holidays, because the Mullah regime restricts too much. The KRG is rich in resources and wealth, it is just that the government is too corrupt to spread it evenly on the people.

Once again, you shouldn't let fanatics on the internet decide your view on Kurds. Go to the KRG and you will meet other Iranians too. There are even Iranian people in exile inside the KRG.

If you want to know what my focus is, it's trying to find out why non-Iranian Kurds don't understand their history well and are so anti-Iranian.

You shouldn't worry about what (some ignorant) Kurds think about Iran.

Perhaps it is what happens when you're an Ottoman and then Iraqi colony.

At least we aren't rulled by Mullahs and can listen to western music without being jailed. And besides that, the Ottomans have always treated us right. The trouble started with the Young Turks and Ataturk, before that there was no big problem.

Also probably because Barzani, who allied with the Turks and Saddam is anti-Iranian due to Iranian support for Talabani.

The Barzani family just thanked Iran recently for the Iranian support to the KRG. You don't know what you're talking about.

Still, having said all of that, I like non-Iranian kurds (it's a given I live those in Iran of course) and support them, just surprised at the level of racism and Iranphobia amongst them.

I do like Iranians too. And your culture(excluding the islamism). And you shouldn't worry too much about what ignorant Kurds think. Iran and the KRG have had good relations and will continue to do so.

Some ignorant Kurds are racist, I can't deny that. But understand that the loud minority doesn't represent the majority. There are thousands of Kurds who go to Iran on holiday, do you really think they hate Iran or Iranians?

And don't worry about pan-Kurdism, no Kurdish politician inside the KRG is interested in Iran's kurdish regions. we are okay with the KRG and don't need to expand one little inch. I would rather see good relations between the KRG and Iran(like now) than to see us fighting. Both of us already got enough hate from Arabic countries, we don't need to hate eachother.

2
DecagOP•

I also respect Iran's borders, and I think the Kurdish politicians too. You should also have respect for people outside of Iran's borders who want to legitimately execute their right for self-determination. Don't worry about Kurds trying to seceed from Iran, nobody is interested in that except from some fanatics. The KRG politicians see Iran as an ally, not as a rival.

I do respect and support Kurds in Iraq, Syria and Turkey.

Iranic culture refers to the culture of the Iranic people. Zoroastrianism for example. Shi'ite safavis weren't Iranic but islamist. Also, Kurdistan is a nation. Just because it hasn't declared full independence, doesn't mean it isn't independent. It is de facto independent, if you have been there once in your life, you would have known. Do you even know that Iraqis can't come in the KRG without a visa?

Iran has been an Islamic nation for 1400 years, just like the kurds have. Does this make us non-Iranian? The Safavids were vehemently Iranian and chose Shi'ism as a defence against the Ottomans who were Sunni.

At least we aren't rulled by Mullahs and can listen to western music without being jailed. And besides that, the Ottomans have always treated us right. The trouble started with the Young Turks and Ataturk, before that there was no big problem.

We can listen to western music, maybe you should read a little more on the social conditions in Iran before making ignorant comments, it's bound to piss people off.

The Barzani family just thanked Iran recently for the Iranian support to the KRG. You don't know what you're talking about.

I know quite well the political situation of the KRG. I posted the link where Barzani thanked Iran. Of course Barzani has to thank Iran if he wants their help - but it doesn't mean he likes Iran. Just read Rudaw to get the sense of the Iranphobia.

I do like Iranians too. And your culture(excluding the islamism). And you shouldn't worry too much about what ignorant Kurds think. Iran and the KRG have had good relations and will continue to do so. Some ignorant Kurds are racist, I can't deny that. But understand that the loud minority doesn't represent the majority. There are thousands of Kurds who go to Iran on holiday, do you really think they hate Iran or Iranians? And don't worry about pan-Kurdism, no Kurdish politician inside the KRG is interested in Iran's kurdish regions. we are okay with the KRG and don't need to expand one little inch. I would rather see good relations between the KRG and Iran(like now) than to see us fighting. Both of us already got enough hate from Arabic countries, we don't need to hate eachother.

There is no Islamism in Iranian culture, the religion of Iranians is Islam an Iran is an Iranian republic but that doesn't make the culture any less Iranian. If you really want to discuss culture and religion, then it might surprise you to know that Shia Islam is quite similar to Zoroastrianism. The "Good vs Evil" in Zoroastrianism translated quite well into the "Oppressors vs oppressed" dichotomy of Shia Islam.

I want good KRG and Iran relations too, however the KDP has put its eggs in Turkey's basket so it doesn't seem likely that the KRG will become close to Iran anytime soon.

I've met lots of great Kurds. However the ones who speak about politics come across racist and Iranphobic. Again, doesn't change my support for Kurds - but just because I don't parrot Israelis or westerners in admiring Kurds for the BS reasons they do, doesn't mean I don't support them.

I posted the video because I don't like the KDP (for obvious reasons), not because I don't like the KRG.

0
ReditskiOther•

I do respect and support Kurds in Iraq, Syria and Turkey.

To be honest with you, a lot of the Kurds inside Turkey are real assholes. 40% of them votes for AKP.

Iran has been an Islamic nation for 1400 years, just like the kurds have. Does this make us non-Iranian? The Safavids were vehemently Iranian and chose Shi'ism as a defence against the Ottomans who were Sunni.

Shi'ism isn't an Iranic creature brother. You are still Iranic people. And the best poets inside the world comes from the Persian language. I only wish that your country Iran kept going that way instead of installing islamism.

We can listen to western music, maybe you should read a little more on the social conditions in Iran before making ignorant comments, it's bound to piss people off.

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-29272732

I know quite well the political situation of the KRG. I posted the link where Barzani thanked Iran. Of course Barzani has to thank Iran if he wants their help - but it doesn't mean he likes Iran. Just read Rudaw to get the sense of the Iranphobia.

Barzani is a corrupt man, of course he wants everything. But it doesn't make Barzani-followers anti-Iranian. And you are right about Rudaw, it is an anti-Iranian medium. But it also an anti-Kurdish medium since it only focusses on the KDP but denigrates literally every other kurdish faction.

There is no Islamism in Iranian culture, the religion of Iranians is Islam an Iran is an Iranian republic but that doesn't make the culture any less Iranian.

Iran is an islamic republic. The rulers of Iran are islamists. The laws of Iran are based on islamic teachings. You even got the Supreme Leader who rules Iran.

If you really want to discuss culture and religion, then it might surprise you to know that Shia Islam is quite similar to Zoroastrianism. The "Good vs Evil" in Zoroastrianism translated quite well into the "Oppressors vs oppressed" dichotomy of Shia Islam

This can be quiet true. I don't hate shi'ites by the way. I have shi'ites inside my family. And to be honest with you, most shi'ites I've met are way more sincere than sunnis.

I've met lots of great Kurds. However the ones who speak about politics come across racist and Iranphobic. Again, doesn't change my support for Kurds - but just because I don't parrot Israelis or westerners in admiring Kurds for the BS reasons they do, doesn't mean I don't support them.

I also support you guys against ultra-nationalist Kurds, when people try to mention Iran and stuff, I try to school them. Educate them, telling them that it is not that bad as people portray. And that people should realize that Iranians and Kurds have fought alongside eachother against the pan-Arabists.

I love the Iranian people and your culture, but I just hate the islamism of Iran. Not only shi'ite islamism, but also sunni islamism. I hate Kurds who support islamism. And you should not feel threatened if a Kurd loves USA(like I do). Just because we love the USA, doesn't mean that we are automatically anti-Iranians. I wish that we all could work it out and established a USA-Iran-KRG-Israel alliance(although I know that you find this ridicul, I would love to have that). Cause one thing that the USA, KRG, Iran and Israel all have in common is: that ba'athists and sunni islamists hate us.

2