r/soccernerd•
twoch

Writing an economics paper. Any help greatly appreciated.

I'm in midst of nailing down a topic for a paper for my international economic relations class. I've been thinking about the impact of United's/Chelsea's/City's (Big teams) jersey sales on china's economy.

Or the relationship between NYCFC and City.

I'm in the very early stages (still determining a topic..) and would love any input or if anyone knows of somewhere reliable to look for sources.

Thanks in advance.

Posted Mar 31, 2015, 10:37 PM UTC

67
bzmbolekwa•

Interesting topic! I took an international economics course once upon a time and we read an interesting book about the life of cotton(which eventually becomes a tshirt) and how it passes through various economies and industries. One of the interesting sections was once T-shirts became "second hand" and were shipped off to Africa. Local merchants have created an entire market of their own off of the used T-Shirts from the West. Might be something cool to look into with respect to your Chinese economy idea.

further on the NYCFC/CITY idea (I am a City fan) you could look at the current market City are trying to break into by creating the expansion team. City also have affiliations with a team in Australia, Melbourne City FC. You could look at the effects of expanding a brand, the City brand, into various markets and their respective success or failure?

Good luck

4
twochOP•

The cotton idea is really good. My professor is being very picky on ideas and I think he'll enjoy that one.

I'm partial towards the transfer market, youth development so I'm very interested in cross-country club relations, but I feel that'll be harder to formulate a paper on the topic.

1
bigrich1776•

Check out "Soccernomics" is a great look a soccer from an economic perspective a la Freakanomics. They have a fair amount of work on soccer club revenues compared to other major companies. And Real Madrid ($675m) and Barcelona ($627m) don't come close to the top 1000 firms in terms of revenue (generally around $1b). So I don't know how much of an effect shirt sales will have on an economy as large as China's compared to oil, agriculture, manufacturing, etc.

The question on cross league associations is interesting but there are only a handful of cases. Although, Man City is interesting because they span across three continents.

If you want my opinion, I would look at TV revenues for each league, especially with networks outside of their home country. The Premier Leagues revenues have exploded over the last few decades and could provide an interesting comparison with the other major leagues. Regardless, you are going to want a far amount of variation in your dependent variable (whether it be differences of shirt sales between clubs, or varying structures of interleague club relationships, or TV revenues of different leagues). Once you find that you can move on to determining the causes of that variation and that's where your argument is going to lie.

Sorry if this is obvious or rambling, but I'm in the midst of my undergrad thesis and I considered writing it on a topic related to soccer. I just wanted to share my experience with others. Best of luck!

4
twochOP•

I just started reading soccernomics! Great so far, but only a couple chapters in...

How far along are you with your thesis? I'm interested to hear more about it.

1
bigrich1776•

Well it ended up not being about soccer. I'm explaining why certain states have passed recreational or medical marijuana measures and why others haven't. Basically there's a strong correlation with per capita last month use of marijuana and passage of legal marijuana measures, especially in states with referenda and initiatives and/or Democratic leanings.

The relationship between societal norms (in this case usage rates) and laws (legal marijuana) is sort of tricky and not definitively explained. But my data points to laws reflecting use among the population rather than influencing it.

It's a pretty basic analysis and not breaking any ground but it's pulling together a few theories on legal marijuana.

If I was to do one on soccer I would examine disparity between in top level teams within the borders of the former East and West Germany. Or the effect of differences in TV revenue distribution on league parity. Or the relationship between revenue, wage spending and debt on league performance.

2
MickyJoHarte•

I'm living in China at the moment, and I have to tell you, I've hardly seen any football jerseys whatsoever. Yeah football is big over here, but you don't really see it in people wearing kits. I don't know a single place you can buy a kit in my whole city. Although you can obviously buy everything off Taobao. The real way you see football over here is in advertising. Messi, Tevez etc. all feature Gatorade, crisp packets, instant noodles, the works. But from a purely subjective and anecdotal point of view, I can't see shirt sales having much of an impact on the Chinese economy. However, big teams are certainly influencing China's sponsorship market at the minute, that much is unquestionable.

The relationship between NYCFC and City is an interesting one, I'd look forward to reading that if you were to post it here. I'd be very interested to see how far outside the regular Parent-Feeder club paradigm they are.

2
Growlbot_•

All the sites under the 'finance' section on the sidebar are good links if you haven't already explored them. Swiss Ramble, Inside World Football, FFP, Economist, Forbes.

Man United would be a good case study on the relationship to market share in China I'd imagine, because they have benefitted over the last fifteen years from targeting that area.

1