r/karate•
css1971

How to decode karate kata

Karate kata are still very badly understood generally today and that is because the knowledge required to understand them has been kept secret for many years. Kung-fu forms, Tae Kwon Do poomsae/patterns have exactly the same problem, for exactly the same reason and from the same origin.

The problem begins in China centuries ago where martial artists of the time drilled various attacks and defences against the attacks, both with weapons and without. As the numbers of drills increased, dealing with more attacks and defences, remembering them all became a problem. Writing them down was not practical as most people were illiterate. An additional problem was the need for a partner in order to practice the drills, so they came up with a way of putting the defensive sections of the drills together to create the first kung-fu forms.

The martial artists would have continued to drill the individual attacks and defences separately with partners, and the forms were primarily used as memory devices to allow solo practice. i.e. they would have known exactly what was in each form before they practised it.

Today, we don't know for sure but can make some educated guesses. The attack portion of the forms is missing, so the context of all of the techniques to be found within are also missing. However Patrick McCarthy has come up with a theory about they types of attacks which would have been dealt with in the unarmed forms. Habitual Acts of Physical Violence (HAPV), is a simple list of the types of attacks that one unarmed person can typically make against another.

To make forms fit into small training spaces, they created a concept of embusen (line of attack) and the embusen rule, where a kata has to balance. Any steps in one direction have to be matched by an equal number in the opposite direction. Then they arranged the techniques within the form/kata such that turns in the embusen coincided with changes in direction inherent in the techniques. If you do this correctly you end up back at your starting point after performing the form.

For westerners, the important release of information about how kata was constructed came in 2001, when Seikichi Toguchi, one of the Goju-ryu masters published in English part of a set of rules created by (or passed down to) Chōjun Miyagi for decoding kata. These are "Kaisai no genri" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaisai_no_genri).

Kenwa Mabuni has also published information on how kata can be viewed in "Kobo Kenpo Karatedo Nyumon" in 1938 but the book is still only available in Japanese.

The Kaisai rules are simple and split into basic and advanced:

Basic:

  • Don't be deceived by the embusen of the kata. It's purely there to fit the kata into a small space.

  • Advancing implies attack and retreating implies defence.

  • There is only one opponent and he's in front of you. Turning to face a new direction does not mean turning to face a new opponent. This is a direct implication of the concatenation of the training drills into a form.

Advanced/supplementary:

  • Every movement is significant. There are no empty/religious/salutation/exercise movements.

  • A closed pulling hand returning to chamber usually has some part of the opponent in it.

  • Utilize the shortest distance to your opponent.

  • If you control an opponent’s head you control the opponent. Many attacks in kata are against the opponent's head/neck area, even if they appear to be at a different level.

  • There are no blocks. Uke are not blocks, they are "defences", however in kata they may not even represent defences, but simply be the movements of the limbs required to execute a more complex technique. All "uke" are taken from kata, and in kata they are used in a specific context.

  • Pay attention to angles. Angles in kata are very important. The angles turned to in the kata embusen indicate the angle you have to turn to with respect to the opponent to make a technique work.

  • Touching your own body in kata indicates that you are touching part of your opponent. In the absence of a partner to practice with, where the kata touches your own body, you would be touching or holding part of the opponent's body.

  • Contour your body. Attack hard with soft and soft with hard.

  • There is no pause in the application.

Further, Kenwa Mabuni also wrote that the angle taken in kata represented an angle which should be taken against a frontal attack:

http://seinenkai.com/articles/swift/swift-tidbits1.html

Iain Abernethy also has some good information on the significance of stances in kata. They are not random. Stances indicate movement of body weight, they can be used for unbalancing techniques and they can be used to indicate height changes.

There are some additional implications of kata being made up of drill sequences. The most important being that kata ends a fight immediately, at the end of the sequence of movements the opponent has been defeated or otherwise completely incapacitated. The sequences would be short and to the point.

A simple example sequence from Pinan Shodan/Heian Nidan: uchi-uke (inside to outside "block"), kick, gyaku-tzuki punch.

uchi-uke - right arm crosses the body to the left and hooks and bends the opponents right elbow, pulling back to your right. Left hand holds opponent's right wrist or forearm. This turns the opponent 180 degrees away from you.

kick - Kick to the back of the opponent's knee causes him to ground his knee, lowering his head.

punch - The chudan punch is to the back of the opponent's neck.

It's unlikely in this case that the uchi-uke is being used against a punch or anything else as fast as a punch is. It is far more likely it's being used against a right handed grab at approximately stomach level, possibly to the left arm.

These are my words. I highly recommend that you go to the "Kaisai no genri" wikipedia page, and on to the references there to read the original material in the original words.

Posted Apr 7, 2015, 10:06 PM UTC · edited

5629
Loading comments…