The is a fairly good intro to neural networks, but predicting the closing value of an index is meaningless in most cases. Try it - look at the closing value of the DOW or any other index over the last few days and then guess today's close. You'll be very close unless some dramatic news is released today. You can't make money day-trading off of the market doing its normal thing, which is what neural networks are good at predicting. To make money you'd have to predict the outliers - when the market is suddenly going to shift significantly away from the norm.

3
technobiumOP•

Totally agree. The article was intended as an intro to neural networks and the Neuroph framework. Predicting a stock market index seemed to me a pretty interesting use case, but the demo alone is not a reliable decision source. There is also a disclaimer before the Conclusion section.

3
espero•

Whoa. This is seriously insane. Will try this and backtest some stock prices.

......^.^.^what^if^it^works

-3
GoldenKaiser•

Stocks are martingales and therefore any kind of predictive algorithms are purely speculations.

9
superPwnzorMegaMan•

this is probably better than my patented: "oh that one looks interesting", approach.

2
GoldenKaiser•

Actually, because it's a martingale that is not true. You have the exact same probability.

3
superPwnzorMegaMan•

oh, well that safes me a bunch of time figuring out how to use this.

1
monumentshorts•

Neural networks are one of the most basic machine classifiers. Most stock analysis doesn't use this, and if it does uses it in conjunction with ada boost.

In general stocks follow more physics based patterns of randomness and to "predict" them you aren't going to use pure index history values to teach a machine learning algorithm. You'll use sentiment analysis, historical data, randomness theory, etc.

2
pyrodemon131•

I believe that the stock market moves on human psychology. So to predict it we need to watch MTV to become millionaires.

2
[deleted]•

Or just fundamentals...

It is proven by numerous studies that fundamental analysis outperforms any kind of technical methods.

-2