Are uke for blocking punches?
Many karateka are taught to do the various basics up and down a hall, solo and with one step and three step "sparring". Almost universally the various "blocks" which you do as part of the kihon and sparring are done against karate punches. The obvious implication is that the blocks are therefore for blocking punches. It's certainly something I believed for a long time.
There is a problem though. They don't in reality work as practised against punches, not real ones anyway. You can prove this to yourself also.
Find a training partner, stand within striking distance, the distance you might be at during an altercation and attempt to stop him slapping your face or body, using any of the uke. uchi uke, age uke, soto uke or gedan barai, while performing the full movement of the uke. My own success rate at this is close to zero.
The simple fact is, a punch takes around 1/4 of a second to hit you, and any of the uke movements take several times that amount of time to complete. The human reaction time for a flinch response with no higher thought involved is also around 1/4 of a second, so against a punch you don't see coming you will barely be able to flinch never mind execute a full uke movement.
Now you can modify the uke movements. Strip out 90% of the unnecessary stuff and simply stick your arm in the way, this is a lot faster and if you see a punch coming you can try it. It's not an uke though, it's just an arm block.
Uke doesn't mean block, it means "receive" and the purpose isn't just to block, but to move you from a disadvantaged position to a better one. If you just stick your arm out, it stops the current attack but he'll just throw another one.
Where do uke come from? They quite simply come from movements in kata. but the usage in kata of the uke movements, don't seem to be related to punching at all as far as I can tell. All movements in kata are simply movements rather than blocks or punches and much of it is related to gripping and being gripped. The names shuto-uke, uchi-uke, soto-uke, age-uke are just convenient ways of referring to the movement.
uch-uke - first seen in pinan shodan/heian nidan. (in to out block). uchi-uke appears to be a defence against someone gripping your arm. The other arm comes across, hooks their elbow and turns them away from you.
age-uke - first seen in pinan nidan/heian shodan. age-uke appears to be a stripping movement of someone who has hold of your wrist, in particular in the kata it is used as part of a hip throw.
gedan barai - means low sweep, rather than uke. First seen in pinan shodan and heian shodan. gedan barai is often the movement guiding or pulling the opponent to the floor as part of a throw or unbalancing, Also used as an arm bar. it's used in a number of places for different things. Very versatile.
soto-uke - first seen in Bassai-Dai/Passai. This is the odd one out of the basic blocks. soto-uke in passai/bassai-dai is another throw, in the kata, you have your opponent's leg hooked.
Shuto-uke - first seen in heian shodan, pinan shodan. It has multiple purposes in various parts of the kata. it's very popular generally in kata.
So, in the pinan/heian katas anyway the uke basics don't seem to be being used against punches. It would make sense then that they don't work very well when you try to use them as such as typically taught.
YMMV. I highly recommend you try them all out yourself against street fight type punches, not karate ones. Interested to hear of other's testing.
Posted Apr 12, 2015, 12:32 AM UTC