Just how good are your stances?
Stances are horribly dealt with in karate, virtually all styles. They have been categorized and organized and put in boxes as different ways to stand. shito-ryu apparently has 17 stances, shotokan 22 different ways of standing...
I'm sure many of you have stood in stances for hours. I certainly have. Well stances are not about standing at all. Stances are about movement.
When you drop from natural stance into a zenkutsu dachi you have to drive your body forward in a lunge. At the end of the movement, your back leg will be straight and your front will be bent, having stopped you. The important thing about the stance is not the stance itself, it's how you got there. Or put another way. Stances are what you are left with after you have moved, they are the burned out shell of movement.
Of course it matters that you're stable, but the details of the stance, whether feet are at 45 degrees or not, as per shiko dachi vs parallel as per kiba dachi are not going to matter, in a fight you won't notice the details and you will go through dozens of stances in a second.
So when you take a stance in a kata or in basics or whatever. Pay attention to the movement you went through to get there. Western martial arts teachers typically deal with movement directly rather than indirectly as the japanese/okinawan teachers do. i.e. a lunge is a lunge that just happens to leave you in a particular stance. I think it's probably related to teaching using forms/kata.
Within kata, stances are used for specific purposes, they have a reason for being, to move body weight often pushing, pulling, lifting dropping but you can also use the physical positioning of limbs. The deep horse type stances are often used this way to unbalance.
Kata: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y6DfTyJ5wiM&t=1m30s
In use: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jseW5QikD6U
So did you see the kiba dachi... Or was it a shiko dachi? Or did you blink and miss it?
Posted Apr 17, 2015, 10:34 PM UTC
To an extent I agree, but stances are about teaching body mechanics.Stances are not just about movement, because they can support you while stationary and blocking for instance. But what I do agree with is that the position is much less important than people often emphasise. Teaching stances starts off with stand like this, then moves to use tension this way and then eventually just be connected with the ground using appropriate tension at the time you need it.
There are no blocks in karate and you should never be stationary.
The problem I have with stances as taught today is they teach movement indirectly and focus on the stationary kamae rather than teaching the movement directly. Abernethy has the theory that this habit began as class sizes increased when karate went to Japan. They only way to check people were moving correctly was to look at the final stance.
The takedown example I gave in the videos is a technique that exists in virtually every martial art. It's in Judo as obi-otoshi, it's in 14th century European ringen grappling as first twerch. However, in judo and HEMA it might take you an hour to learn and understand (longer to get good at), the way karate is taught using stances, it will take years, if you ever twig as to the use of stance.
(FYI, the HEMA ringen technique: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lvkPLvoH1vI&t=1m12s and the Judo Obi Otoshi: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n_jRGwVt974)
For a start karate is very broad, but there definitely are blocks and they definitely have use. I've used blocks effectively both in the dojo and on the street. Second, I don't agree you should never be stationary. A lot of sport karate bounces around, but traditional doesn't. And that is admittedly less useful for offence, but is more grounded for defence.
When he says never be stationary I dont think hes talking about bouncing around. Don't be stationary means don't just stand their and be still. Move laterally, cut angles, move into range when you want to strike and out of it when you want to avoid being hit. Instead of blocking a strike using foot work or headmovment to get out of the way is usually the better option. Even when you are blocking try using head movement or footwork in order to ensure someone doesn't hit you straight through your block anyway or to reduce the damage you risk taking in blocking.
Its generally not a great idea to stand still and let the other guy hit you.
Sure, generally I'd agree. I have issue mostly with the idea that it's never right to be stationary. Usually it's not, but sometimes it is.
The blocks as used in basics are taken from kata (pinans) and within the kata the movements are just not used as blocks against strikes. Age-uke is a stripping motion and part of an o-goshi throw. uchi-uke is a defence against a wrist/arm grab which rotates your opponent away from you. Soto-uke (not in the pinans) is part of a scoop throw (sukui-nage), shuto-uke is used as an arm trap and strike, gedan barai is used in various places as an arm bar, pulling your opponent down in a throw and in a number of other ways, it is not used as a block... And this applies to any style making use of these uke from the pinan katas or those they are based on. You might argue that shorei based karate does, but while I don't practice goju, i'm fairly confident that the situation within their kata is the same. There is simply no good reason to record sticking your arm out in kata, so the movements there are also for other purposes.
Even if you try to use them as such, they simply don't work as taught. They're too slow by far and only possible way to get them to be useful is to throw 90% of the uke movement away and simply stick your arm out... Well that's just sticking your arm out in response to a blow, and really isn't related to karate, it's something that everyone does instinctively.
On not being stationary, kata teaches to change angles to advantageous ones and to manipulate the opponent into disadvantageous positions. There's no good reason to be stationary and many good reasons not to be.
In conclusion, karate has no blocks, they are all something else. It's likely that they were introduced as basic blocks against punches as class sizes increased and knowledge of the nature of kata was lost, particularly round the 1920s-30s.
Yep, pretty obviously blocks share many movements with throws etc. That's pretty obvious, but to say that's all they are is a logical misstep.
Yes it's instinctive. So is hitting people. What we do though is train to do that better, more effectively - using it to create an opening. We exaggerate the movements, build muscle memory and practice the timing, so when we want to use it it's trained. Just like when you're punching, you don't do the full basic technique - that's just a training tool.
So I've moved, created an opening, he's at a perfect distance for me to hit him - so I really need to move some more before hitting him? Couldn't I just hit him, using the muscles in my legs to get ground connection?
I don't have a trouble with a lot of your ideas, my issue is with your use of absolutes. I do not consider that there is an absolute nature of karate that is progressively being lost. Likely two hundred years ago, there were just as many different ideas on how to do things as there are today.