[Misc] Dedicated servers: These are not the solution you're looking for
Since Destiny came out many people have lamented the lack of dedicated servers for the game. Destiny uses P2P (peer-to-peer) technology to create direct connections between players' consoles. The alternative is to individually connect players to dedicated servers (under Bungie's control) which are highly robust and always on. Many people consider this to be a superior system, and in some ways it is. In others it is not.
P2P connections are created whenever players need to see and/or interact with one another. In such cases one console is nominated to the role of host. While all the connected consoles run parallel simulations of the game only the host's version is authoritative. Nothing is considered "real" until the host agrees. This is why sometimes health bars pop back a few notches, or why things teleport. Your local version of the simulation was different to the host's and you've just been synchronised. So if your host's connection suffers, your game suffers, even if your connection to the internet is just fine.
Dedicated servers take some of the uncertainty out of this equation. Commercial servers have better connections to the internet than most individuals, and they seldom crash or disconnect. They're also predictable. Under a P2P system players migrate hosts fairly frequently (if the host's connection degrades to an unacceptable level, they disconnect, or some other condition is met the host changes). In fact, in Destiny you change host once every 160 seconds, on average. This means that your latency can change fairly often with P2P hosts, while it remains pretty steady for dedicated ones. So there are indeed some advantages to dedicated hosts. There are some disadvantages too.
The closest server farm to you is probably in a different city. For many people it will be in a different country. For some, a different continent. The closest person with a console of the same type is probably a few houses away. The average RTT (round trip time - the time it takes for data to travel from you to a server and back again) for dedicated servers is higher for most people than the average RTT for P2P hosts.
The game can make some clever optimisations with dedicated hosts, but you can't beat the physical limitations. The connection to a dedicated server might be more reliable, but it's reliably worse. The sooner your trigger pull reaches the host the better your game feels and a P2P host will get your trigger pull sooner than a dedicated one.
With P2P matchmaking you're more likely to have lower latency, but you'll see greater variation in latency among players in the same game. With a dedicated host you're more likely to have higher latency, but there'll be less variation in latency among players in he same game.
Dedicated servers are also expensive. Destiny is a more complex and ambitious game than many people realise. This complexity makes for a fun game but does not lend itself to massive cloud-based parallelisation. I imagine that a subscription based model could better support such a system, but most people would probably prefer what we have now (which is actually pretty damn cheap).
Finally, it's worth noting that Destiny does actually use dedicated servers in tandem with P2P technology. Bungie created a hybrid system which runs a redundant, lightweight cloud-based host in parallel to the console-based P2P host, allowing for certain optimisations. Essentially, this dedicated host does part-time duty. It doesn't do everything that the P2P host does, but it looks after the really important stuff (like getting Crota to stand up when he should, post-fix). This keeps costs down while still providing some of the benefits of a dedicated host.
TLW: Dedicated hosts are great for some things but they don't reduce latency for the majority of players; on average they increase it. At best they can create a more level playing field by giving players within the same game similar latencies. In practice they're prohibitively expensive for Destiny.
Disclaimer: I am not a networking expert. I have had some formal education in networking, and a little practical experience. I would not be surprised to discover that there are factual and logical errors in this post. I made this post because I believe that the community holds some misconceptions and would benefit from discussing this issue. Hopefully what I've written is interesting to at least one person, and is more right than it is wrong :P With luck y'all can teach me something :D
Acknowledgement: I found a lot of great information in this publicly available talk given by Bungie's Justin Truman. http://www.gdcvault.com/play/1022247/Shared-World-Shooter-Destiny-s
Posted Apr 18, 2015, 10:41 AM UTC · edited