IRA vs 401k and deduction limits

Retirement

If your income is over the deduction limit, is it still better to contribute to an IRA before your 401k?

The wiki recommends contributing to an IRA before topping off your 401k with an exception if your 401k gives you access to better funds. As far as I can tell, people earning more than a certain amount are able to contribute to their Traditional IRAs, but don't contribute using pretax dollars, so if you contribute $5500 to your Traditional IRA, it costs you ~$7333-7639 (at 25%-28% tax) of salary. If you contributed $5500 to your 401k, you would be paying in pretax dollars, so it would only cost you only $5500 in salary to end up with the same amount in your retirement fund. Comparing the two options, it seems like you'd end up with ~$2000 more in salary (and ~$1440-1500 in your pocket) contributing to the 401k rather than the IRA.

As a follow up question to involve Roth IRAs, if you pay income tax on putting money into your Traditional IRA (for people earning above certain amounts), I assume you don't pay on taking the money out again. It seems like the Traditional IRA then becomes a Roth IRA without the advantage of being able to withdraw your contributions (unless the penalties are nullified by the fact you've paid taxes on the Traditional IRA money already).

Posted Apr 19, 2015, 5:58 AM UTC · edited

05
AutoModeratorMOD•

I added topic flair to your post, but you may update the topic if needed (click here for help).

You may also be interested in:

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
materialdesigner•

You are correct in your analysis, this is why people suggest direct contribution to roth or the backdoor roth where your non deductible traditional IRA contributions then get converted to roth, paying taxes on any gains (minimal if done close to the contributions) but now gaining the benefits of the Roth wrapper.

1
wijwijwij•

The wiki article is talking about deductible contributions to trad IRAs, though it doesn't clarify that. The value in making nondeductible contributions to trad IRA when your income is too high is as a prelude to the back-door Roth conversion of them.

...if you pay income tax on putting money into your Traditional IRA (for people earning above certain amounts), I assume you don't pay on taking the money out again...

When you make a nondeductible contribution (i.e. put after-tax money into a trad IRA), then when you convert it to Roth, that amount is non-taxable during the conversion. So it won't get taxed twice. (Though any growth between the contribution and the Roth conversion is taxable income in the year of the conversion.) So that's how the back-door Roth approach ends up being essentially equivalent to having made a contribution directly to the Roth in the first place.

But what if you simply leave nondeductible contributions in a traditional IRA? Then what? This boglehead wiki page gives the clue:

The major difference comes from the way earnings are taxed. Earnings are taxed as ordinary income if you withdraw them from a non-deductible traditional IRA. In contrast, earnings are tax free if you withdraw them from a Roth IRA.

http://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Non-deductible_traditional_IRA

The Form 8606 is used to keep track of the nondeductible amount in a trad IRA. So that's how you avoid getting double-taxed. But the fact that earnings are treated differently tips things in the favor of doing the back-door Roth conversion.

1
DeluxeXL•

The fact is, all else being equal, it boils down to whether you expect your tax rate to be higher during retirement or right now.

If tax rate is higher now, do pre-tax contribution (401k, traditional traditional IRA)

If tax rate is higher at retirement, do after-tax contribution (Roth IRA, (mega) backdoor Roth IRA)

If tax rate is the same now or later, it doesn't matter either way.

0
WhoopskaOP•

If tax rate is higher now, do pre-tax contribution (401k, traditional traditional IRA)

In this case, the traditional IRA is not pre-tax.

Are you saying that the Traditional IRA becomes a Roth IRA? Do you know about the withdrawal penalties if the taxes have already been paid (as in this case)?

1