r/chrubuntu•
Simoig

[Help] I've reached the limits of ChromeOS and need advice on how to move forward.

In October 13 my Windows laptop died and I got a Samsung ARM Chromebook series 3.

Since then I've always been able to overcome difficulties with the Chromebook's limitations, sometimes even for the better (LateX has been an eye-opener).

Next year I will write my master thesis in the Molecular Biology field and I've been told I will need the Office Suite programs, as well as some light scientific software that is not available for ChromeOS.

Luckily, for each type of program there are Linux alternatives available (SerialCloner and ImageJ).

Which means I am confronted with the dilemma of trying Chrubuntu/Crouton or buying a new laptop with the added disadvantage that I will probably get a professional laptop from the place I will start working at the year after.

This seems like an obvious choice, but I've read that:

  • The ARM processor can't run several Linux programs (Wine).

  • It's a slow system if you choose Chrubuntu instead of Crouton.

I should also mention that I have absolutely no programming knowledge and I don't have time or skills to learn, nor have I ever worked with Linux systems before.

So r/chrubuntu, do you think installing a dual-boot is a good option for a layman like me? If so, should I get Crouton or Chrubuntu?

Posted Apr 21, 2015, 2:28 PM UTC

712
WYkkYD666HP 14 | Mint 17 | 3.19 Stable | John Lewis ROM•

If only for a year and no time to learn, Crouton and ChrUbuntu aren't for you on, especially on an ARM machine.

I would suggest getting Office 365 (free at most universities, like mine) if Google's products aren't powerful enough for you and then just remote desktop into your university's machines for the scientific software you need.

Another option is depending on your university, they might have a Surplus store that sells their used computer equipment on the cheap. So if the software isn't on the university machines you could get a cheap desktop and remote desktop into that just using Chrome Remote Desktop app.

Good luck.

6
SimoigOPSamsung ARM Chromebook Series 3 | Distro | Kernel•

Office365 is the online Office Suite right?

The remote desktop app allows you to use another machine through internet. I am guessing that means the desktop should always be turned on and connected?

Thanks!

1
WYkkYD666HP 14 | Mint 17 | 3.19 Stable | John Lewis ROM•

Yes, Office365 is their online suite. Check with your school if you get access for free.

Ideally you would remote desktop to a machine at the university as they would always be on and hopefully have the software you need.

I really like u/reynhout idea of using Amazon EC2 though.

1
ClairelyClaireHP ChromeBook 14 | Ubuntu 14.10 | 3.17•

You can access Office Online for free. You don't need an Office 365 subscription. Just login with your Microsoft Account at www.office.com - your documents are automatically saved in OneDrive.

1
reynhoutAcer C720 | Lubuntu 15.04 (via chrx) | 3.19 •

Good points raised here.

A couple other ideas:

  • Apple's iWork for iCloud office software has a free tier. More powerful than Google Docs, but not completely compatible with MSOffice, if you need to exchange files frequently.
  • Amazon EC2 has a free tier that lets you run Windows and Remote Desktop in. Maybe you could run the scientific software there?

If you need serial ports connected to lab equipment or a completely local machine for any reason, you might need new hardware. I agree that ChrUbuntu or Crouton on ARM would be an imperfect solution, as some software won't work. It might be worth a try if you had the time to fiddle and poke.

Your minimum cost for new hardware is US$250 or so for a new Chromebook which can run Linux happily, or a bit more for a new low-spec Windows laptop. If you end up getting a computer from work in a year, this laptop could be kept separate for personal use (which is a hugely better idea than mingling personal + work on the same computer).

Beware used laptops. Hard drives and batteries have finite lives, and people generally don't sell their laptop until one or the other is on its way out. A really cheap one (and very good backups) might be worth considering, but the inconvenience of a mid-term hardware failure (or data corruption!) can be significant. Of course that's a possibility with new hardware as well, just less likely. Either way, make sure you have excellent backups!

3
SimoigOPSamsung ARM Chromebook Series 3 | Distro | Kernel•

Thanks for the advice.

  • Never heard about EC2 but it seems interesting. Do you have any experience using it? How does it run? What's the price to rent "an instance"?

  • No need for a completely local machine and wasn't planning on buying a used machine.

If you end up getting a computer from work in a year, this laptop could be kept separate for personal use (which is a hugely better idea than mingling personal + work on the same computer).

  • I agree, the problem is that I have my current Chromebook for this. So buying another one would give me 2 laptops for personal use a year from now. I see my Chromebook model going for 100$ on Ebay, so I might consider selling it to make room for this plan.
1
reynhoutAcer C720 | Lubuntu 15.04 (via chrx) | 3.19 •

I use EC2 for lots of UNIX instances, but haven't tried Windows. The free tier is 750hrs/mo for one year.

After that, it's still only a few cents per hour -- if you need to run Windows software for 10 hrs/week or whatever, you only pay for the hours you use. You'd need to pull the data down after processing (or it goes away) and push it back up next time (if you're operating on the same data sets repeatedly).

See: https://aws.amazon.com/ec2/pricing/

If your data set is very large, that could be onerous, and data transfer fees might apply if it's really big. [EDIT: You can also store your data on Amazon's servers for less cost than keeping the instance running, but the service (S3) isn't designed for consumers and the process feels daunting unless you already know basically what to expect.]

Actually, that's an important consideration for any new or existing local hardware too. Chromebooks have small SSDs (which be upgraded), so depending on what you're working on, you might need to solve that problem. The cheap Windows laptops usually have standard hard drives many times larger than stock Chromebook SSDs.

1
5ilverpeachpit | slackware 14.1 mainline 4.0rc•

Chrubuntu s9ryd with ubuntu 14.04 mostly all works out of the box on an arm chromebook. you can see if the packages you want are available on packages.ubuntu.com, just make sure you are checking for "armhf" binaries. Most people use i386 or amd64, so some packages are not available.

Wine will not work. It emulates windows, not and intel x86 processor. You can probably virtualize an old xp desktop with qemu, but it will not be as quick as native x86 virtualization since more instructions need to be translated.

2
Baeocystin4Gb C720 | Ubuntu •

Dual-booting is not a good option for you.

If you want to try just for fun, that's one thing. But if you don't have time to learn, and don't come from a position of CS knowledge, forget it. These are not turn-key solutions.

A laptop you might possibly get over a year from now should not even enter in to your consideration. Buy a good laptop right now that will run the software you need without having to dick around with workarounds like RDP or partially-supported OSes and save your mental energy for your thesis.

1
reynhoutAcer C720 | Lubuntu 15.04 (via chrx) | 3.19 •

Well, I disagree.

Ubuntu is as turn key of an OS as you can get. Web, email, office apps all work great. Any specialized software will need to be considered for compatibility, of course. But that's just as true with Windows or OSX.

Running Ubuntu as an ordinary user requires zero CS savvy. Installing Ubuntu on an appropriate Chromebook is just a few minutes of unfamiliar effort.

But for anyone that can use Linux and for whom cost is a consideration, I think Chromebook Linux is a great answer. My only reservations would be entirely related to Chromebook specs: SSD, RAM, processor, screen size, etc.

1
Baeocystin4Gb C720 | Ubuntu •

You're preaching to the choir, my friend. But as great as Ubuntu is, it, like all OSes, has its limitations. The OP stated they don't have a technical background, don't have the time to learn, and need to use software that runs best in Windows. As much as I like Linux, I like using the most appropriate tool for the job even more, and in this case, they need a more powerful, windows-based machine to make their lives easier.

1
reynhoutAcer C720 | Lubuntu 15.04 (via chrx) | 3.19 •

Yes, I definitely agree that if the scientific software runs better on Windows, then OP might be disappointed with the Linux equivalent.

I took a look at the linked software: one of them is Java so probably the same on either platform. The other doesn't say, but is also widely multiplatform, so might also be Java. But if these are links to the "Linux options" instead of the "preferred options", then yeah. Important to make sure you understand what you're getting yourself into! :)

And then there are performance and storage needs to consider. I wonder if OP might be able to find someone else in his/her academic department who has more direct experience.

2