r/ems•
matoleon

Why do states seem to purposely mislead students on what national registry psychomotor exam will contain?

Backstory:

I've taken and passed the national registry psychomotor - but not because my school helped me prepare.

In 2011, I went to a school in Virginia and they trained me to a standard. I memorized that stupid (VA-specific) medical/trauma sheet upside down and inside out. It had all the steps we know and love, but in the ways that Virginia prescribed. They did their own things in their own ways and it was... whatever. You might think the things that differed were minor, but when it comes to testing, little things end up being all the difference.

The standards were NOT the same. I can't recall exactly, but they did stuff out of order and had different names and lots more that snowballed into huge discrepencies. The sections don't line up and obviously we recalled things and listed things in a completely different manner and the order jumped around and would confuse the hell out of any NREMT tester that hadn't been with our class (skipping ahead to the end, it did and was catastrophic). They called their assessments something completely different than we did and so were unsure when we had moved from one part to another. They (our students) expected interactions and verbal nudging with the testers, the NREMT psychomotor testers however remained stoic and silent and stared at the students when they asked so little as "is the scene safe?" The rest went to hell for our class.

I was one of the only ones that passed because as the class ended, i went to the NREMT website and panicked because i saw that our testing sheets were NOTHING like the NREMT sheets. When i asked, i was told our sheets WERE the national sheets. This was wrong and a lie. Come test day, sure enough the NREMT sheets were in the testers hands and the fact that I had re-memorized the national standard, i passed. Most of my class did not.

Three years later, flash forward to where I live now. Different state, same story. I see it all happening again. We have "testing sheets" that look and feel like NREMT sheets, but they aren't. They're community college specific. The instructors get all pissy and swear they're national registry specific.

They aren't. They're vastly different. Some have steps completely out of order... and on the NREMT sheets these out of order steps are critical failing criteria such as when to apply a c-collar or check CMS. Some of the sheets have completely controversial steps such as binding hands and feet with cravats which can terrify a patient or look like illegal detainment.

Is this endemic? Why do schools insist that they can write their own curriculum and then pretend that the NREMT-standard testers that show up won't be using the national registry sheets come test day? I called to confirm that when we test, we will be using the exact sheets on the website free for download... and yet we're using some random ones that my school made up.

They do this at all the technical schools in my state. Apparently this is everywhere.

Why do states insist on pretending NREMT doesn't exist until the day comes that EMTs need to pass it?

Has anyone else experienced this??

EDIT:

All the responses so far have made me feel pretty weird about this - so I actually went to go back and check. I'll post an update because I'm going through holding the various sheets side by side. I have the tech college sheet, the state sheet, my old state's sheet, and the NREMT sheet. None look alike. I also have from memory what my most recent instructor gave as a lecture on how to quickly memorize how to pass a trauma exam - in other words, an algorithm to quickly rattle through memorization, and thus I want to see based on the sheets how a grader would grade such a performance.

So far, it's not holding up well on ANY of the sheets. I'll show the results in a future post. I feel like I've just had a run of bad schools.

In the meantime, please see: this link, page 31 as a really good example of how a state takes national registry's patient assessment and goes all to hell with it. Note that nowhere in the assessment does a provider ever indicate or does the S&P ever state that the EMS provider should actually transport the patient. There's just three assessment periods for no reason and then done, with no logic behind why.

Posted Apr 21, 2015, 11:27 PM UTC · edited

1219
Bones_MDO2 Wrench Specialist - PA/OH NREMT-B•

PA here. We were taught using the national sheets. Had the registry seal on them and everything.

7
matoleonOP•

then i'm in the wrong state. three times in a row.

because all three states i've been in are reverse registry states (they don't have state licensing before national registry - you pass NREMT first, then get your state license) - yet somehow have different state standards that are vastly different than national testing sheets.

3
Bones_MDO2 Wrench Specialist - PA/OH NREMT-B•

PA is also a registry state that requires registry before state certification. We learned to registry standard and testing sheets

4
SickByNatureTX EMT•

Texas.

Our teacher made us go online to the NREMT website and print out the sheets ourselves. Then we had to bring them to class everyday after that and practice them at least once towards the end of class.

By about the 3rd week, we all knew them inside and out.

Edit: Texas only grants licenses to NREMT's, but doesn't have it's own test other than background checks. If you are NREMT, then you are TX certified.

6
forkandbowlGA medic•

Ga is the same

2
ernest89NH AEMT •

NH here and we're taught to the national standard. NREMT or required prior to getting your state card. My class is very careful and specific with national vs NH information.

3
Anus_Unremarkable•

Yeah, I remember this bullshit. It's been too many years, but what happened was that I was specifically tested in a fashion contradictory to NREMT rules.

And when I called NREMT, they said, "Oh, well, that's up to the states. They can do what they want. We're just a guideline."

So much for being a fucking "national standard."

3
rcordova•

Uh... NREMT is just an organization that lots of states have gotten on board with. They're not a branch of government, they can't force states to follow their guideline.

1
Anus_Unremarkable•

Of course they can. There's no purpose in having a standard if it's à la carte. Nobody would take them seriously if they said "All the states require passing the computer-based test, except Mississippi because they don't want to. But all the other member states have to accept NREMTs who passed Mississippi's test." The whole standard falls apart.

2
rcordova•

I think we're talking about different things since there are states that don't defer to NREMT's guidelines

1
Anus_Unremarkable•

Perhaps so.

1
luckynumberorangemedic-fentanyl repository•

tested in ME, NREMT sheets the whole time. can recited backboard and trauma assessment from memory 2 years later

2
thedoctorshotgreedoEMT-B•

Here in WV we are only doing the WV Psychomotor exam, we are about to take both the WV exam and the NREMT exam and we were told we only have to take the WV psychomotor exam.

2
Tehpillowstar•

"Well, I guess I'll take a quick look at this link...HEY THAT'S MY STATE."

Well I guess I'll take a look at the NREMT website before I take my NREMT exam.

2
DrCheezyGritzFL - First Responder / Fire-Rescue Volunteer•

I guess my school just happened to teach the same at the NREMT / State psychomotor exam. When we passed our "final scenarios" for trauma / medical, that counted for the final class exam, and the school sent the information to NREMT saying that we passed that portion of the test.

1
dramboxf•

CA reporting in.

The EMT-B is taught to the NREMT standard, with NREMT-B forms. At least in my county (Sonoma.) Taught so well, in fact, that when I took the computerized NREMT-B exam, it ended at 60 questions on the dot.

I don't know for sure, but I believe that NREMT-P is also taught the same way in California.

1
RT83isMeNJ NR-EMT•

I trained in Maryland, which was trying out a hybrid state/NREMT certification, which basically meant we had to learn 3 sets of protocols, the textbook for the unit tests and class final, Maryland Protocol for the psychomotor, and National protocol for the written test.

That being said, they were pretty clear from the beginning that each step had slightly different protocols, and told us to split it up, learned the text book until class ended, studied state until the psychomotor was completed, then studied for the NR-EMT test last. I will say if my classmate hadn't taken the NR-EMT test first and warn us to study-up, I probably wouldn't have been prepared.

1
rcordova•

RI

Taught using national sheets, take national tests, receive state license after showing NREMT

1
Tehpillowstar•

I can't really give much of an opinion of how National Registry works out, as I'm just an EMT-B student preparing for that exam, I just want to say that I'm not having this experience. We aren't taught to simply pass that one exam, with a focus of state protocols and what happens in real life, but as National Registry draws closer, all of my instructors are placing greater importance on what goes on in National Registry and what it would be like.

If you are also curious, my patient assessment sheets aren't anything like the S&P you linked. I haven't compared it to the National Registry's, though.

1