Interesting take from Untold on the "Martyr of Islington"
untold-arsenal.com/archives/42800Posted Apr 23, 2015, 1:33 PM UTC
Posted Apr 23, 2015, 1:33 PM UTC
very curious what u/itscorley thinks?
I think it's great, basically...like several of the other people who've posted, I'm a big fan of Untold as a blog. Their 'present day' stuff is consistently great and I love the work they do to report and share parts of club history that often go wayyyy deeper than like 'BFTP.' Most of the (admittedly limited) amount I know about the club's deep history comes from chewing through Untold archives on sleepless nights in like 2010.
As far as this particular piece goes, I think I mostly agree with it: as far as I can tell Tony and I both land solidly in the 'Pro-Wenger' camp, particularly with a fascination about how he's been so willing to be pragmatic in pursuit of his 'idealistic' vision of how football ought to be played.One thing that I want to mention is the wrinkle Tony pulls out here (that I didn't get to address so fully in the guardian piece) about Arsene's tactical pragmatism coming out at certain times when he feels like getting results is particularly important. Tony mentions the end of 08/09, I remember personally the end of (I think) 12/13 when we were grinding out 1:0s for the last ten weeks of the season to come fourth. I do think that this on-pitch-pragmatism (that we've seen against City away this season) is an important part of who Arsene is as a manager, and I didn't get too far into that in the piece. Although I might argue that maybe there's a deeper agreement here: the times that Arsenal play more 'pragmatically' are usually the times when there's concerns over the team's trajectory in the league, notably about top four places. So to me this is still basically in tune with the idea that Arsene is pragmatic in the service of ideals, or beauty, or whatever: this pragmatic play is very much intended to insure that in future seasons the club has the financial resources and prestige to play the way it wants to. Maybe that's a little arcane, but: in general I don't find too much to disagree with here. Tony knows MUCH more than I do about the club and its history, and if this piece comes out as a book I'd certainly read it.
The only other thing I'd say, more philosophically/generally, is that in general I feel awesome about the vast majority of the response to the piece, even when it's critical. It's all part of a conversation that I think is healthy for us fans to have: it helps us understand what the club is, and who Wenger is, and on some level who we are. Someone like Wenger is never going to be totally summed up in even a 3000 word webpiece; I think the point of 'Martyr' is less to be the one final take on Wenger than it is to bring a few new terms or ideas into the conversation that people are and will continue to be having about him. The fact is that we as fans are very hungry for Arsenal content; we want to know every day about contracts, transfers, injuries, lineups, bantz, etc. And because we want that the media that comes up around the club, whether it's in big fancy papers like the guardian or on the hundreds of (excellent!) blogs around Arsenal, tends to have a pretty short wavelength. If you have to write 500 words a day about a given soccer team, or a 750 word column six times a season (as a lot of the newspaper guys are doing) it's always going to be easier to dwell on 'what's happening TODAY' or the results at the weekend or whatever. Within that daily/weekly cycle it can be difficult to fit in the sort of macro perspective or synthesis (both about what Wenger's been doing over the last decade, and about how our thoughts and feelings about Arsenal relate to the way the world and football is changing around us) that this piece wants to do. So, that was all a really long-winded way of saying that what my piece wants, more than anything, is for us to see the story of Arsenal/Arsene as something that happens over years and decades as opposed to weeks and months. And so this kind of criticism (and some of the other FAR more critical stuff I've seen) basically makes me really happy. It's possible for reasonable, committed Arsenal fans (a lot of whom, let's be honest, have much stronger connections to the club than I do) to have a much different perspective than I/my piece do about Arsene (are we keeping too much cash on hand? quite possibly!), but I basically see my piece as being part of a real big conversation, and as long as that conversation's not abusive--as long as we don't lose track of the fact that every single one of us wants the club to win, wants her to wear the shit out of that yellow ribbon, etc--then, great, I'm happy to be told I'm wrong.
But this whole business of communication most of the time via journalists is coloured by the incident of 1 October 1996, when a veritable horde of journalists gathered on the steps of Highbury demanding to talk with the manager whose job officially began that day. They were there to shout, “what do you have to say about the rumours Mr Wenger?”
Can someone who remembers that time shed some light on this? What was this about?
Pedophile charges if I remember correctly.
On his first day? wtf!
According to untold there was a rumor then that Wenger had left Japan because he got busted for paedophilia. I don't have any independent sources other than untold.
This is good. Much better than the suffocating purple prose of the "Martyr..." piece.
I've been lurking on r/gunners for about 6 months. I don't see a lot of references to Untold which I think is one of the better researched Arsenal blogs out there. Too bad I guess
Should post up more of their articles, this was a really well done and quality piece.
The Martyr piece seemed less factual and more like the writer wanking himself of rather than writing a factual piece.
I think the point of it was to be overwritten. If you don't like the style of the writing then it's just your opinion. I thought the metaphors were stretcued to their limit but it seemed very nice as an arty type of prose.
There's nothing wrong with arty type of prose, but there is a problem when it falsely depicts the truth though.
Artsy for the sake of it is called being Kitsch where I am from...
Wow, love this piece. So refreshing for an article to have perspective AND accuracy.
Untold are fantastic; worth a daily read; non-reactionary, calm and like you said accurate perspective.
Can't believe I didn't know about this blog. Thanks for the post.