I just realized I had $1700 in my 401k (story in comments), which I no longer contribute to. Is it worth switching investments, withdrawing to pay debt, or moving to an IRA?
When I first starting working, I had contributed to my company's Fidelity 401k until I realized that they actually didn't offer any matching. So I changed my contribution to 0% and forgot about it. Several years later I decided to log in on a whim and realized that there was $1700 sitting in my account. I think I have the option to change my investment, but that seems more like playing the stock market, which I am clueless about. I would like to use it to chip away at over $10k in credit debt, but would that be worth taking a penalty fee? My third option, which everyone keeps urging me to do, is to move it into a Vanguard IRA. I'm currently living paycheck to paycheck so I haven't had the luxury to look into savings/retirement. Any insight would be greatly appreciated.
Edit: I am still with the company.
Posted Apr 23, 2015, 1:49 PM UTC · edited
Roll it over to a Vanguard IRA and put it in a Target Date fund. If you withdraw it you wouldn't see much more than half of that money after taxes and penalties and you'd be back to having zero retirement savings.
That probably isn't an option if OP still works at that company.
Good catch... I'd definitely had assumed that this was a prior job, but now that I read more carefully that isn't clear.
Where I work they say this isn't an option till you cease employment. But you can take a distribution with the plan at any time can't you? Can't you just put a distribution into an IRA within 60 days and pay no taxes?
Signed in to say just this.
Just performed this myself with an old 401k and it took less than 10min on the phone with Vanguard to notify them it was coming and then 10min on the phone with Fidelity to say I wanted to rollover my 401k from them to Vanguard.
Do you need anything special, or basically just have an account statement handy so you can reference the account number? I've been a slacker about doing this, but I really need to.
Figure out roughly how much is going to be transferred and call the company you are transferring into first (Vanguard in example). Tell them how much to expect, 401K Roth or standard, and what account(s) you'd like it to go into once transferred. The Roth piece is important cause you want to take from on type and place it into the same type (to avoid fee's). Vanguard will email you a document with information like your account # and most importantly the address to send the rollover checks to.
Then call where your 401K is (Fidelity in the example) and say that you want rollover all of it. I had both Roth and standard so they sent me 2 separate checks.
Generally, your 401k holder will send the checks to your personal address and then you have to turn around and send it to Vanguard (but I've heard some places will send it directly to the other).
Get the check(s) in the mail, maybe write the new account/funds (with Vanguard) they should go into on the check or a sticky note attached to the check, and then turn around and mail them to Vanguard (same envelope is fine and remember, Vanguard already gave you the address to mail it to). I think you have something like 60 days from the time Fidelity mails you the check until the time Vanguard receives it without penalty.
Hope that helps.
Since the money has not yet been taxed, wouldn't it be subject to tax before putting it into a Roth at Vanguard?
I'm in a similar situation and genuinely curious.
Not if you roll it to a traditional IRA, if its a roth I believe there is a tax obligation now because you aren't paying taxes on the amount when you reach retirement age and can withdraw.
My suggestion assumed rolling over into a traditional IRA (which is what a "rollover IRA" when it's termed that way, actually is). If the OP wanted to do a Roth conversion after they did the rollover, then they would owe taxes.
Thanks for the reply, looking at this from a big picture, any downside in putting it into a Roth?
I see no difference taking the money out, having it taxed, and putting it into a Roth vs. getting a pay check, taxed, investing in Roth.
Am I wrong? Thanks again.
I'm not sure I follow. Since you're not the OP can you describe what situation you're actually dealing with?
If you were to "take the money out" rather than doing a rollover, you would get hit with the 10% early withdrawal penalty, so you don't want to do that.
The difference between converting a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA and making a new contribution to a Roth IRA is that one involves saving some of your income and the other is just changing the tax treatment of existing savings.
You might even be eligible for some type of bonus for rolling over an account, right?
Edit: never mind I didn't realize you typically need to roll over $25k + to get any bonus
Why not just keep it in Fidelity? From an administration / paperwork standpoint, that's probably easiest, and OP can still decide to invest in Vanguard funds.
Maybe, it depends on the funds his 401k provides.
True, but if he's rolling it into an IRA, then he can invest in anything he wants.
I guess I'm just not well-versed enough in the differences between Vanguard and Fidelity to know why you'd move your money if you didn't have to.
EDIT: It looks like if you're going to end up investing in Vanguard ETF's anyways, you can do so through Vanguard for $0 in fees, whereas Fidelity would charge you their standard commission, which is $7.95 per trade. Otherwise, if you're going to invest in some other fund, I don't see huge differences between the 2, so I was just recommending leaving it in Fidelity for the sake of convenience.
Good point, I thought you meant keep it in the 401k as opposed to rolling it into an IRA with Fidelity.