Karate is really just Kung-Fu
Many karateka think that karate is just a punching and kicking martial art. Even some depressingly senior ones. We punch, we kick and we block and nothing else. Well that's a very meagre view of what karate really is, they have lost a lot of the richness which is present in the karate katas.
It's really the katas which are the strength of karate and as I have posted about several times, the katas are very badly understood. Within them you can find virtually every martial technique which exists. Arm locks, wrist locks, leg locks, throws of many kinds, there are eye gouges, there are chokes and strangles. You name it and there will be one or several instances of it in the katas. Even more than that though, the katas also teach strategy and fighting tactics, with the information coming from the people who used the methods to save their lives centuries ago.
Karate prior to WWII was a strong martial art with a justifiably fearsome reputation. With the loss of knowledge about kata it has since become weak, almost laughable in fact. I'd like that to change.
Karate didn't spring from nothing in Okinawa, the myths about peasants creating the art are just that. Myths. If you look at a map you'll see Okinawa is just off the coast of China and it would be amazing if China didn't have an enormous cultural impact on Okinawa and on Karate.
Well, while Okinawa did have it's own native systems, the majority of karate was imported from China over the centuries. Chinese people, families emigrated, lived and brought Kung fu with them to Okinawa. In particular. Kung-fu forms.
Most recently, the Goju-ryu style of karate is essentially a wholesale import of methods from White Crane kung-fu which is popular in Fujian province in China. Some of the kata are nearly identical, and the methods contained within will be similarly identical.
Going further back, it's rather more difficult to trace the specific DNA from Kung-Fu to Karate, but it's there. The Kusanku kata was created from teachings of a Chinese ambassador to Okinawa. Passai was a Chinese family form.
There is more influence but it can be difficult to understand exactly how some fighting information from China can make it into an Okinawan kata other than by wholesale copying of the form.
Well, tracing individual sequences is particularly difficult even between styles of karate, a kata can look somewhat different. However, there are some techniques which are highly characteristic and immediately visible. The easiest of these to see is Manji-uke.
Manji-uke is a kicking defence. Opponent kicks you, you parry his leg to the side and catch it with your other arm, then lift it up high while pushing him over backwards. In Passai/Bassai, the kata then kicks out the opponent's remaining leg and dumps him to the ground, while you retain your grip on his leg at the knee level. Once he's down, you grab his foot or ankle with your other hand and pull violently apart, dislocating his knee.
Now, I have certainly seen, and I'm sure you have also seen many kung-fu movies where prior to a fight starting, one of the actors enters a stance very like manji-uke, one arm up high to the rear, the other down low to the front... That's because it IS manji-uke. It's technically identical.
In fact here it is in the kung-fu sequence in The Matrix: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V8ZdGmgj0PQ#t=54
Here is a sequence from a kung-fu form which has an identical application to the sequence described above in Passai/Bassai.
...
Kung-fu: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=21vZz4beFv8#t=77
...
Bassai (Shotokan): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tXPZFarJMh0#t=57
...
Parry the incoming kick, catch and raise leg lifting up high, kick opponent's remaining leg out and dump opponent to the ground while retaining hold of his leg. Grab ankle and pull apart violently dislocating the knee. The applications are identical. It's obvious that the karate sequence came from Shaolin kung-fu. They are far too similar for it to be a coincidence and we shouldn't really be too surprised, Shorin is the Okinawan pronunciation of Shaolin.
It's obviously much more difficult to trace less characteristic sequences but basically, Karate is really Kung-Fu. There are certainly Okinawan native techniques in karate, but it's difficult to identify them. One of the obvious ones is similarly characteristic; the Okinawan Sumo (Shima) throw in Kusanku/Kanku-Dai:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vS46TgGja_w&t=1m58s
This is native to Okinawa and isn't really seen in China:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LIi6pQ4WQgQ
Does this make karate any the less? No, certainly not. Martial arts have been taking techniques from each other since humanity learned to fight. It does mean that you will likely find many kung-fu forms and methods very familiar.
Posted Apr 28, 2015, 9:55 PM UTC · edited