r/ffxiv•
Tharcide

Guildwork - Shout injection

[Discussion]

I'm asking this on reddit because it's the only place I've seen where we can post freely that talks about it.

Anyway. Guildwork. It's obviously a very useful tool for hunting, duty finder, and spam destruction.

But I really like the Shout injection and found it very useful. My question is about how reliable it is. Does it really give you ALL the shouts? I started to really rely on it but recently been having some doubts on whether I actually get all of them. It's not a problem with my regex for filtering, spent a lot of time ruling that out.

Do you really get all the shouts? Or just the shouts from zones where a guildwork user is?

Posted May 1, 2015, 11:43 PM UTC

17
worldofneilScott Pilgrim on Sargatanas•

It'll only be zones where a guildwork user is (since it's essentially just agregating data from clients).

4
TharcideOP•

This is what I'm starting to think is happening. It makes sense

1
PhettyXPhetty Xiv on Balmung•

The way it works is by broadcasting shouts other guild work users see. If there's nobody using guild work in the area it doesn't broadcast the shout to others. So it is possible to miss shouts. It's unlikely you'll miss any important shouts though since they'll be from high populated areas like Mor Dhona.

2
TharcideOP•

Yeah it's the main reason why I was fooled about seeing all shouts. It's usually never an issue.

It's just a bummer that some hunt groups with no guildwork users and lazy with linkshell shoutouts or just not in very many will kill a hunt and majority of hunters miss out. Not a huge deal but I wish I could see all shouts :C

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
SirHubertTYRONE BIGGUMS on ODIN•

i havent used gw in a while so this might have changed but from my experince you only see shouts of other gw users

1
TharcideOP•

For those who may misunderstand .. I understand where you are coming from but ...
The reason why I would love to see all the shouts is so I can actively relay hunts from locations I'm not currently @. It means I can help everyone go from location to location without anyone missing any.

A ranks aren't a huge deal but hey people are very appreciative of the calls.

I run around more than anyone else and then I relay it to linkshells. While we are waiting for people to arrive... suddenly a shout pops up over in Central Thanalan. "A rank! Central Thanalan(17,18) pullin soon".

That allows me to tell everyone in my current zone to not attack this Girtab scorpion and instead head over to Central thanalan. It's a lot of work to coordinate this stuff sometimes. It's usually not a big deal but I certainly put a lot of effort into it.

:)

1
ramos619•

I don't use GW, but dammed if this doesn't sound like me watching shouts on ffxiah for anything lol.

1