r/dndnext•
alterafro

The Bully-Buster!

I'm a reasonably new player who's looking to add some flavour to his character. I'm thinking of using a stereotypical young Gnome tinkerer, and I thought it would be a cool idea to kit him out with a spring-loaded-boxing-glove set up like Data has in the Goonies. Being new and all, the process of creating unique items like this is completely alien to me, so I was wondering mechanically if this is reasonable? I was thinking myself that it would be something that he could use to attempt to knock opponents down/back? Thanks!

Posted May 14, 2015, 1:34 PM UTC

112
AngryKoboldDmWarlock•

Hit up your DM, (s)he has the final say in whether or not you can do that. It sounds like a reasonable enough request.

2
alterafroOP•

Yeah, I'm gonna discuss it with him, but our group all started at the same time and this is our second game together (The first that this DM is running), so I thought that some more experienced perspectives would be helpful :)

1
EatsTheBlossomsThe Divine Edgar•

The problem is knocking someone down is a mechanical effect which has a lot of power in combat, so you need to be weary of making it too easy. Look into the rules for shoves, and I would probably give you a mechanical boxing glove that lets you make a shove, maybe with a +1 or something. Or maybe the glove has its own modifier overall. But it would be powerful, especially if your character himself has a low strength score.

But I'm also into non magical items for players, such as custom weapons, weird devices, costumes etc. so I'm definitely into the idea. So definitely try and work it out because as long as it's bo overpowered it would be a cool thing for your character to have.

2
alterafroOP•

Yeah, that's what I was worried about. I thought maybe once it's deployed I would need to manually wind it back up (taking an action) and it would give some sort of speed/movement penalty when it's hanging off my chest , halving speed + disadvantage on DEX/Athletics checks possibly. I'm leaning towards setting a fixed DC that the opponent has to beat with their choice of Athletics/Acrobatics, and I like the idea of having it flinging me backwards as well on a failed STR check.

2
EatsTheBlossomsThe Divine Edgar•

Ha! The image of you running around with an extended boxing glove flopping from your chest while you're trying to gather it up and shove it back in to its box but tripping over it is hilarious.

Now we're too far I think in the negative direction. Just let it be a reward. You throw resources (gold) at it and get something valuable in return. It can be as good as say plate mail or any other expensive thing you can buy. Depending on how much you put in. But then again the drawbacks are funny and maybe that's the most important part of a goonies inspired tinkerers item.

Also you using it on an ogre or something else big and just getting shot backwards while he's standing there like "...what?" is also really funny.

If you really want to get into it, most of the other devices just mimic some small part of a cantrip (looking at the book again, looks like specifically presdigitation), so realistically the most balanced would be to let you say take an action to wind and then next then release, getting advantage on your shove check or what have you (true strike) or say letting you hit an enemy with it and they are "winded" or something for a turn, making it so they can't use reactions (shocking grasp) or maybe just you can use it to shove from X distance (mage hand?) but that might be too much and not enough at the same time.

But maybe with a drawback it could be more than that. Again really up to your DM and contingent on how your campaign is going to be.

2
IronforgedAnti-Paladin•

Just reflavor existing items, for example a mace or hammer could be a mechanical boxing glove like device. If you want it to shove targets taking levels in fighter(battlemaster), or a feat like Martial Adept or Shield Master to gain something that will let you attack and shove or shove as a bonus action.

You could always just use your boxing glove mace to shove without doing any damage.

2
alterafroOP•

The way I was imagining it, is that the contraption is fixed to my person on a brace, and it's activated with some sort of button in my hand. But yeah,I'm thinking damage is not really the point of the device, its more just a reaction to a frontal assault so he can more easily flee

1
rockmanz3r0•

Then totally just flavor up your shove attempt. You could see if your DM would allow advantage on the roll, from the surprise aspect, limited to the first time you use it per creature/encounter, as kind of a situational thing. I would just spend some gold+time to craft it, but have it be more of a mundane item, like a crowbar or hunting trap or something; in the end it's ultimately just a shove attempt, right? Don't need to overdo it

2
blahlbinoaPaladin of Torm•

holy shit that's an awesome idea! Talk it over with your DM for sure and like everyone said here, look over rules for what you would like.

Me? I would make it a 1d4 damage with the creature of a medium size having to make a DC check of like 20 on their Con or be knocked out. Lower checks for smaller creatures and anything over medium would just laugh at you.

2
alterafroOP•

Thanks! So far I think I'm looking at it working like this:

*When it is used, the opponent makes a Athletics/Acrobatics check (DC to be determined)and if the check fails, the opponent is pushed back 5ft or prone

*If the check succeeds then the player wearing the device must make a Strength check, and on a failure, the player is thrown back 5ft and prone

*After it has been deployed, an action must be used to re-compress the device

*Whilst the device is deployed, the player has disadvantage on DEX rolls

But that's just before I can run it past my DM. I like the idea of using creature sizes, so I'll probably try it integrate that.

1
blahlbinoaPaladin of Torm•

I would just make it two checks. One to see if you actually hit, and second to see if the person is getting sucker punched. Take your pick on what the opponent rolls, but if the roll is failed, the thing that is getting popped would just get 1d4 non-magical bludgeoning damage. Though reloading takes a round and the disadvantage should be anything that uses your arms until reloaded.

2