Puppy is Destructive when left alone.

help

My husband and I adopted a 8-12 month old shepherd mix last month. We're working on training her since she doesn't know too much by way of obedience, but she catches on quickly and she's wonderful when we're around, also great with other dogs and people.

What we're having issues with is leaving her alone when my husband leaves for ... anything. I work day shift, M-F. My husband works 24 on 72 off (8-8). She basically gets left alone only for the time when our shifts cross paths (she goes to doggy day care when we're both at work). This alone period at home is around 3 hours at the most. Now she doesn't seem destructive when I leave her and go to work. My husband typically comes home to an empty kong and an otherwise perfect apartment. However, when he leaves her alone to go to class or something else, and I come home, I find the place a mess. Things get chewed, items get pulled off the kitchen counters, etc. We both try to run her into the ground before we leave (go for a run, to the park, tug o war, whatever gets her tired out).

I'm at my wits end, because replacing things is expensive and I love the crap out of her, so I want to work with her on this. In regard to crates, we're working on training her on crates, but we're going slowly because she loathes it (not sure what happened prior to adopting her).

Ideas, tips, whatever would be great for this please!

Posted May 21, 2015, 11:06 PM UTC

87
badlcuk•

The more all this awesome stuff to destroy is left out, the more it reinforces the fun of it. If you're not there to redirect her off of the inappropriate toy and on to the correct--id puppy proof the place (remove your stuff, baby gate her in to a room where your stuff isn't available, etc). She's just getting the entertainment she's looking for. If you're already exercising her enough and working on redirecting her to the correct toys when you're home, you're doing what you can-may take time.

Finding patterns in what she 'destroys' is also good as well. For example, maybe she prefers the texture of something fuzzy, or wooden, and goes for those. If this is the case, you can keep a better eye to remove those objects, or buy a specific dog-replacement better suited for what your dog likes to destroy. My dog always targeted goose down pillows until about age ~2, that was annoying. She also liked leather.

6
alithiaOP•

We're definitely trying! We basically leave her in the living area part of the apartment and close all other rooms off. I try my best to ensure that basically only furniture is left out. Unfortunately, I think I underestimated her willingness to find things to destroy. The sugar jar on the counter (all the way at the back too) found its way to the floor today. As far as I can tell, there isn't a texture target, but I'll be more careful to keep an eye out for that, I hadn't even thought of it, thank you!

1
badlcuk•

Don't worry, it gets better :D

1
alithiaOP•

For sure! My last dog, we had as a puppy, but for some reason I don't remember it being nearly as big as a fight, he just seemed to fit right in. I'm looking forward to getting her out of these habits. We just got through pulling, and she's miles better on the leash now!

1
Jerakor•

There are two main factors that should be looked at first. The time of day she is left alone, and the actions of the person leaving her.

First the time. Is there noise or light or anything else that is different between when you leave and when he leaves? Does her workout schedule not lineup well?

Second the method of exit. Does he make a big deal of leaving and returning? Is his leaving just louder in general, big truck, loud keys? Anything that could be noticeable to her for a long time, something that could rev up her anxiety.

It sounds to me like separation anxiety related to him or general restlessness due to the time of day are the most likely culprits here.

You have two points of data to compare, you and him, so you should try to start looking at all the little details of what is different. I know my pup has seperation anxiety from whomever last spent the most time with her. If my girlfriend stays home sick then when she leaves it is a big deal. If I work from home then when I leave is a big deal.

If you do narrow it down to separation anxiety look for some general tips on this. Lessen the stress of coming and going, consider getting a DAP collar/plugin, change up and freeze the Kong stuffing or get a food puzzle.

3
alithiaOP•

I'm not 100% about how he leaves. I don't make a big deal, I just give her the kong say good bye and leave. When I get home I say hi, and I don't engage in playfulness until she calms down and I get my stuff put down. I'll have a discussion with him tonight about whether or not he's making a big deal. I will say that afternoons seem more problematic than mornings. I try my best to keep a schedule between us because his life as an EMT is unpredictable at best.

6-7: I wake up for work, and her and I go out to play/run/walk/whatever feels good that morning. She'll get fed when I get back. 7-8: I leave. 8-10: Husband gets home at some point between these hours. This is largely unpredictable due to getting a late call or whatever. It has been a long time since something got destroyed during this time period though.

I'm not sure what my husband's schedule is during the day for her. I believe he usually goes for a playtime date with her around 11 and again at 3. I'm thinking afternoons are probably when our schedules vary the most. He's doing another certification, so he leaves around 4:30 to go to class. I get home between 6-7. This isn't every day and I guess that is probably where we are failing in getting her into a routine? I'm not sure how we can combat this?

1
sunriselady_44•

It sounds like the problem might be two fold. The first is that with the varying schedules your dog isn't getting used to routine. Without a routine he doesn't quite know what to expect, so he fills his time in a fun way. The second issue is he has access to "stuff" to keep himself entertained. Both of these are easy fixes. If you have a room that you can gate off and remove things you don't want damaged that can be used but I would suggest crate training your dog. Get a metal dog crate and leave the dog in the crate when you are out. You can leave the dog with a Kong, safe toys, and a comfy non destructible bed. Be sure to really exercise him before putting him in the crate. This is a great book to help your dog look forward to using his crate (http://www.amazon.com/Susan-Garretts-Crate-Self-Control-Motivation/dp/B0013GJJG6) or you can find some of her videos on you tube like this one http://www.amazon.com/Susan-Garretts-Crate-Self-Control-Motivation/dp/B0013GJJG6... ... Good luck,I am sure you are on the right track

3