[EP3 SPOILERS] Chloe's Character Trajectory

Discussion

Chloe underwent a great deal of character development right at the end of Ep3 that I think a lot of people are overlooking due to the shock factor behind the wheelchair. This is significant because it changes Chloe's trajectory from a one-dimensional dead end into something that I believe can be changed for the better. (Let's be honest - like her or not, she's quite objectively destroying her life with all her stunts.) What I'm talking about specifically starts while driving Max back to school after storming out of Frank's RV.

Up until that point, she'd honestly been a fairly one-dimensional character: punk rebel girl. She's been incessantly selfish in her disrespect for authority and even in her friendship with Max. While it was sort of factually assumed that this was due to a series of abandonments (William, Max, and Rachel), she always shielded the real issues behind her tangible problems with David, Nathan, and Frank (and who knows how many others before them). This is the essence of the Chloe we had interacted with through all the preceding events.

However, in the truck on the way back to school, her facade finally breaks down. She admits that she refuses to accept that everything is her fault, and she blames William because she feels he abandoned her. He hasn't been there so she's been blaming everyone else in her life, but underneath it all, she feels that he is to blame. All of a sudden, Chloe the punk rebel becomes Chloe the little girl who is scared and alone because her daddy is never coming home. Suddenly, Chloe isn't a punk - she's broken.

As if that wasn't enough, you almost immediately get to see the real Chloe. You go back in time and get to meet daddy's little girl making pancakes, all happy and cheerful with a bright future. The player had only ever seen punk Chloe until now, so it was impossible to know just how much she had changed from when she was a girl. It would have been reasonable to assume that she was always something of a brat, but this scene puts that to rest. Blue-Chloe, the character we've been interacting with throughout the game, has undergone a radical behavioral shift from how she used to be.

In the span of maybe 10 minutes, you get the full perspective on what has really happened in Chloe's life and what kind of impact it has had on her. The final shot of alt-Chloe smiling in the wheelchair is so shocking because she has become a near-perfect foil for herself. Despite being physically handicapped and locked to a chair, alt-Chloe expresses the one thing blue-Chloe has been unable to find in all her boy-toys, drugs, and adventures: genuine happiness. Meanwhile, blue-Chloe has all the physical freedom in the world, but she's emotionally handicapped and effectively trapped by her past.

I believe that the ultimate purpose of the alternate timeline is to find a way to "save" blue-Chloe, at least emotionally. (Maybe she still has to die, but that's another topic.) We know that all of her troubles ultimately stem from William's death, so it is quite convenient that this alternate timeline has him living at her expense. Now, there are numerous ways this could play out, but I believe that it will be at least possible to help heal blue-Chloe based on actions taken and information gathered in the alternate timeline.

Max tried to use her power to go back in time and save her friend by rewriting history, but that's not how time works. The mistakes of our past define who we are, and changing history effectively destroyed blue-Chloe. The only way to truly help her is to heal her wounds, not erase them.

Posted May 22, 2015, 2:09 AM UTC

9741
broughsuppy•

You're very right, and kudos for the in-depth analysis. I remember thinking "oh man, we've GOT to talk about this" after Chloe and Max's talk in the truck on the way back, but completely forgot about that after, well.....you-know-what.

Chloe revealed that she actually has a hefty amount of self-awareness regarding the fact that she seems to blame everyone but herself for her problems. It makes the ending to the ep even more heartbreaking, in my opinion, because as hard as it is to see Chloe's heartache and deep emotional agony underneath her freewheeling punk facade, I felt like we were finally actually getting somewhere with her after the talk in the van. After she had cooled down, Max and her could've had a serious talk. Obviously her problems aren't anything that could be solved in a day, week, or month -- it'd likely take years -- but you can already see Chloe starting to slowly heal with Max around, imo, especially over the course of ep3. Well-fucking-done to the devs, because that just made the ending FIFTY THOUSAND TIMES MORE HEARTBREAKING OH GOD WHY

39
AeroXero•

Well said, when we skipped to the alternate timeline I was heartbroken because I felt like I was making headway with Chloe and everything was for naught.

19
IotaDraconis•

I guess the heartbreaking comes from the fact that this is not the Chloe we're used to. This blonde girl is not broken, she seems friendly and happy (well, at least within the limits she has).

I can't stress the quote of Jocye often enough: "William's gift were the memories". Those are what define blue-haired Chloe and those are missing at the blonde girl. We would have never had am "double dare" with her, never broken in to the pool and the friendship to Rachel would have been totally different.

To sum it up: Chloe is what she is because of all the things that happened to her. She has a right to feel all the pain to grow into the powerful person we know.

11
superblysituated•

I actually don't think her self-awareness is only revealed in the scene with the truck either. It's kind of peppered throughout this episode, like when she tells Max she doesn't really want to "burn Arcadia bay to the shore" but says things like that because she's been missing Max and all the other people who disappeared from her life along the way. She's finally being vulnerable with Max again, the way she might have before Max left. But I agree, seeing her open up and then having her totally taken away/transformed into another person was certainly devastating.

5
haXona•

Exactly how I felt. After the car scene I was set to help Chloe out because you kinda realised that Chloe is finally seeing things clearly again and that she wants to chane for the better. All that would never have happened if Max had not been in her world again.

The scene at home when the fight between Chloe and Max vs David is another scene that shows clearly that Chloe has become more confident and she now has support - in the form of Max - behind her that will fight for her.

This is exactly why that ending just overshadowed everything for me and everyone else, for a brief moment everyone and everything we had thought about up until the end just froze.

3
UnlimitedFlour•

The only way to truly help her is to heal her wounds, not erase them.

I get the feeling that alt-Chloe's accident would have happened whilst Max was at Seattle and during a holiday. Indeed, it's hinted that the family were unable to make enough money without William to go on that holiday. If this is the case then Max will be unable to stop alt-Chloe going on that holiday and getting into the accident. Even if it wasn't on holiday, Max wasn't in Arcadia Bay after William died.

But yes, a person can change a lot over only a few years, especially at a young age. Pictures of Chloe and Max as children always showed that there was a fairly big divide between the personality of her older and younger self. I'm interested to see if we have any agency in changing that or if previous choices will be taken into account.

EDIT: Also, thanks for breaking up the post into paragraphs and not just putting it into a wall of text!

19
RandomGuy928OP•

I think the prevailing theory is that she got into a car accident. In the scene right after saving William when time is fast forwarding and you see pictures of Chloe's past getting rewritten, the last picture changes to Chloe getting the keys to a truck as a present.

But yes, I don't think Max will be able to change the accident directly since it almost definitely occurred while she was in Seattle.

9
UnlimitedFlour•

Yes, that would make sense. Either way, I think with Max leaving soon after the accident the entire continuum hinges on that one choice. When Max talked to Joyce for the first time in the game I got the impression that she might not have even stayed for the funeral as she only just gave her condolences.

4
AsianGuy1137•

Kind of off-topic, have we gotten any hints on what exactly William does for a living?

2
LilianH•

No idea, but in the past there was a note about him getting a promotion recently, so he's obviously not self employed.

3
Unforgettable_•

Awesome assessment, all good valid points. It is/was quite sad to see Chloe in her wheelchair, but she was smiling! You can just see how much of an impact William had in her life; she was a completely different person when she was younger, a total daddy's girl. And when he passed away, it all went downhill from there. All credit goes to Dontnod and their writers for creating good character development and I can't wait to see how the rest of Chloe's character develops.

7

Much depends how you interpret her circumstances. I'm not sure we are supposed to make a value judgement about the consequences of her condition in it's totality. If you break it down, you can see that either her body is injured, or her mind. That Her Father either protects her physically, or mentally.

In that respect, we changed the detail of the outcome but not the outcome itself. As if Chloe being damaged was somehow predestined. William too performs his role in either case, just in different a different way.

We haven't seen Joyce yet, and her circumstances may change the equation, but is it a coincidence that "William" is derived from Wilhelm and that Wilhelm literally means Will + Helmet or will to protect? (according to some random name website that I checked anyway) And "Price".. well, yeah.

Chloe's name may share a significance with those on the red binders.

<weasel words>

The problem with names is that everyone has to have one and so it's no surprise when they do. It could mean something or nothing. While I think that many (if not all) of the names were chosen carefully (perhaps accounting for why the incidental characters have no names), I'm not sure whether the intent was to inform or deceive given that a scrupulously honest mystery writer is also likely to be a bad one.

<weasel words/>
7
Elaine_Benes_•

Chloe definitely has to pay a "Price" in many, many senses.

3
upper-echelon•

I almost feel like Chloe's purpose in this game is to make the point that just gong through your life inevitably damages you in some way, and that you can't magically erase these damages that are a part of the human condition.

1
upper-echelon•

I agree that episode 3 (and not just the end of it) was extremely important in terms of character development for Chloe. However I just don't buy the argument that the state in which we first meet her is "one-dimensional." I think some people see her that way because they are reluctant to see anything but her rebellious tendencies. I think Chloe has been a complex character since the beginning. The Chloe we know is still the "real" Chloe. There are plenty of things that can make you aware of that at any point she appears in the game.

I do agree that helping her heal is the only possible solution. I think Max might be the one person who can help with this, and she won't need her powers to do it.

6
Catharciss•

Love this post! I have to agree with you there. I also feel like the hero(ine) in the story isn't actually Max, but Chloe herself —— she has a lot of internal struggle and the entire game seems to be her personal story of redemption.

Losing her father triggered her to go down a different path in life. Rachel Amber (still questionable as to who she is) is missing—— someone she found peace in, after Max moved away. Chloe has all the freedom but she can't seem to settle down with "something." She could go anywhere she wanted, get money the difficult and dirty way, but she would feel haunted.

Of course, most of the time we play as Max and we go through all sorts of things, but I suppose when you try to look at it from a different angle, Max isn't the "everyday hero"; she just happens to be a girl with a gift and she's still trying to figure out what to do with it. She is our guide; a reflection of us, too, in a way. We're just watchers.

People have internal struggles and difficulties and when they are able to overcome those, they end up as heroes in their own right. :)

But this is just me!

4
SunbatherValley•

That's an interesting take. However, as someone with a similar past and similar problems to Bluehair Chloe, I'll assure you she could overcome that though. Be it through time, maturing, councelling/therapy or whatnot. Maybe she would actually be happy if they happen to solve the Rachel situation and just be happy with her and Max. So in that regard, I would say that modern Chloe is better off since she can still have it all, whereas handicapped Chloe is bound to a wheelchair. :(

4
gpot97•

Therapy/Counselling requires money, a pretty large sum of money if it ends up being long term (several years). It's pretty clear in the game that [in the main timeline] the family doesn't have much money. I have to partially disagree with you on the time part. not trying to discount your own experiences. But as we see in the game, time has not treated Chloe well. After her father's death she went downhill over time because [presumably] she wasn't able to access therapy. She was forced to deal with her own problems, and not long afterwards, her best friend left for another state.

Yes, mental handicaps can be healed, or at least treated to some extent. And yes, we cant make quadriplegic magically walk again (yet).

In the end, is it better to be of sound body or of sound mind?

1
SunbatherValley•

Ah, dang it, I forgot about American healthcare. That's a very good point then. But it wouldn't be out of question to help her get access to it down the road, right?

In any case, we have to see that Chloe has had loss after loss. Her father, then Max. Rachel came along but so did Frank and David, who had a negative impact on her life yet again. Then Rachel disappeared. Yet another loss. Assuming Max stays, that's an improvement that can be build upon. Even if they find out something unfortunate has happened to Rachel, that'd be one more blow and then what? Chloe has showed progress in the care and I genuinely think with Max's help she could get better permanently. So in that regard, I'd say stick it out and have a fulfilled life later on without any problems, not physical nor mental. Afterall she's only 19 or 20, righ? (Can't remember if Max said one or two years older than her, but still - Very young)

3
gpot97•

I think that Chloe could definitely get better with Max there to support her, assuming we didnt just kill off that timeline.... And she might have been able to cope with her loss better if Max had been there for her when she needed it. She went through a series of really unfortunate events that really messed her up.

What I love so much about this game is that the characters arent just superficial. They have stories and personalities and actual problems just like real people. You're able to look past the cartoonish graphics and bad lip syncing and get immersed with what really matters in the game, the story.

3
Elaine_Benes_•

Keep in mind Chloe is still 19...I also was a mess at 19. She's got a lot of time to change and grow. Getting out of Arcadia Bay would definitely help.

3
derpdepp•

mental handicaps

how is chloe "mentally handicapped", again? or even "broken" and needing years of therapy?

Seriously, what's so bad about Chloe? Some people talk like she's a lost cause or something... I know people IRL who had more severe issues, and they made it. Not trying to downplay her problems or anything, but she's far from a "lost cause" imo.

3
-Carlos-•

Well there we go, the purpose of the entire game explain. I 100% agree with this theory.

It reminds me of those movie/shows where the protagonist helps a lost spirit find its peace. I do not know a specific one, but you get what I am saying. We are to focus on trying to keep Chloe alive, when we should be helping her find her peace. Our power is not intended to save the world, but to fulfill a purpose. As sad as that may be, we will eventually have to let Chloe go.

^Damn ^this ^is ^going ^to ^be ^as ^sad ^as ^Lee ^from ^the ^Walking ^Dead =/

3
RandomGuy928OP•

That's an interesting thought. I've commented elsewhere that we still don't actually know what the endgame is, but having Chloe's redemption and/or death as the endgame would make a degree of sense. She seems to be the only person actually tied up in everything. She's an enemy of Nathan and the Vortex Club, David is her step-dad, she owes Frank money, she's the only person still trying to find Rachel, she's at the heart of the alternate timeline, and she's the only person other than Max with any connection to the lighthouse. In fact, without Chloe, there wouldn't be much of a plot at all beyond Kate's side story and normal high school drama (Warren's crush, Victoria's bitchiness, Vortex elitism, etc...).

The main problem I see with this, at least from the redemption perspective, is that it's hard to fit the tornado in anywhere. The only theories I've seen that actually explain the tornado involve some sort of cascading spacetime nonsense that require you to undo past actions, but it would defeat the purpose of saving her character if you were to, for example, go back in time and let Nathan kill her (since she would never be "saved" in the final timeline).

I hadn't thought of framing this as the endgame, but it's definitely an interesting lens to view the game through. I'll give it some more thought.

3
TomSparkLabs•

Man, am I going to hate DONTNOD if they kill Chloe.

3
gpot97•

It reminds me of those movie/shows where the protagonist helps a lost spirit find its peace. I do not know a specific one...

Avatar: The Last Airbender? Legend of Korra? Pretty sure there was at least an episode or two.

2
Bumblefuckery•

I just finished episode 3 about 45 seconds ago, and I feel like I just got punched in the gut. Holy shit... whoa. I'm still not totally capable of understanding what just happened. Dontnod, you just outdid yourself. I'm having fun reading what you all are posting, I just have no clue where they will go with this now. The only thing I wasn't so crazy about in this episode is I miss the music. I've been falling asleep to the soundtrack on spotify for the past week or so, and was hoping there would be something to add to it.

3
Grizzlb•

Did you hear any music at all? I played on 360, and there was no music through a glitch. I'm going to reinstall and see if that fixes it.

2
Bumblefuckery•

I did, but usually only in the pause menu. Even then, it was clearly that background pause menu music, not anything substantial. Was there supposed to be music??

1
Grizzlb•

Yeah there were moments in my run-through where there was no sound whatsoever (like on the bus towards the end). There was definitely supposed to be music. Other people commented that they had the same problem.

2
Bumblefuckery•

Ah, I thought that was odd.

1
Elaine_Benes_•

Can we get a shoutout to Ashly Burch as well? Her voice acting is amazing, in my opinion. She brings so much emotional range to Chloe on top of the humor and comedic timing that made her famous. /fangirling

Love the analysis of Chloe as physically vs. emotionally disabled in the different timelines.

3
bleeters•

Huh. TIL that Chloe and Tiny Tina are voiced by the same person. That's kind of magical.

3

+1 She's fantastic. The talent across the board really shines in this game imo. Tbh, I'd love for them to dole out some behind the scenes footage of recording sessions or maybe even gather the cast for a showcase of sorts as they did with The last of us. Record the cast performing some key scenes from the game.

2
Edadinasni•

I like your train of thought.

2
diamondcreeper•

Daaaaaaaamn. Can we get a Nobel up in here?

2
darkitp•

my question , how max got to be popular with the vortex club in the alternative time line ?

how did she get effected with the time change at all ?

this doesn't make sense ..

unless the person who had accident with chole is important person

like the drug dealer frank , or Rachel Amber

that made the vortex club , drug free group - by what we saw from Nathan and Victoria's Behavior -

and does this episode have another ending like the second episode ?

2
RandomGuy928OP•

I suspect that William has been standing up to Mr. Prescott in the alternate timeline and keeping things from getting too far out of hand, but that's pure speculation at this point. Without Mr. Prescott's power trip, Nathan might be a more normal person, and the rest of the Vortex club probably would have followed suit.

It's also very likely that Max was affected by William's death, just nowhere near as much as Chloe.

5
AlvarezMd90•

Man.. I wish we could go back and tell her about her other future. I mean, how would Chloe react? She knows that Max is capable of doing that with her powers.

Heck maybe Max could even show her by holding her hand and going back with her together. I guess she still isn't done grieving about her father.

2
jkhn14•

Its funny Chloe reminds me a lot of how my mom's life was when she was teenager in the fact that they both lost there fathers at a young age and how they responded to that loss with anger and drug use, that being said it will be interesting to see what this alternative route will be like and how you effect it.

1
Razraffion•

I bet it was Chloe who got into a car accident this time. Just assuming on that last picture that burns out.

0