[EP3 SPOILERS] Chloe's Character Trajectory
Chloe underwent a great deal of character development right at the end of Ep3 that I think a lot of people are overlooking due to the shock factor behind the wheelchair. This is significant because it changes Chloe's trajectory from a one-dimensional dead end into something that I believe can be changed for the better. (Let's be honest - like her or not, she's quite objectively destroying her life with all her stunts.) What I'm talking about specifically starts while driving Max back to school after storming out of Frank's RV.
Up until that point, she'd honestly been a fairly one-dimensional character: punk rebel girl. She's been incessantly selfish in her disrespect for authority and even in her friendship with Max. While it was sort of factually assumed that this was due to a series of abandonments (William, Max, and Rachel), she always shielded the real issues behind her tangible problems with David, Nathan, and Frank (and who knows how many others before them). This is the essence of the Chloe we had interacted with through all the preceding events.
However, in the truck on the way back to school, her facade finally breaks down. She admits that she refuses to accept that everything is her fault, and she blames William because she feels he abandoned her. He hasn't been there so she's been blaming everyone else in her life, but underneath it all, she feels that he is to blame. All of a sudden, Chloe the punk rebel becomes Chloe the little girl who is scared and alone because her daddy is never coming home. Suddenly, Chloe isn't a punk - she's broken.
As if that wasn't enough, you almost immediately get to see the real Chloe. You go back in time and get to meet daddy's little girl making pancakes, all happy and cheerful with a bright future. The player had only ever seen punk Chloe until now, so it was impossible to know just how much she had changed from when she was a girl. It would have been reasonable to assume that she was always something of a brat, but this scene puts that to rest. Blue-Chloe, the character we've been interacting with throughout the game, has undergone a radical behavioral shift from how she used to be.
In the span of maybe 10 minutes, you get the full perspective on what has really happened in Chloe's life and what kind of impact it has had on her. The final shot of alt-Chloe smiling in the wheelchair is so shocking because she has become a near-perfect foil for herself. Despite being physically handicapped and locked to a chair, alt-Chloe expresses the one thing blue-Chloe has been unable to find in all her boy-toys, drugs, and adventures: genuine happiness. Meanwhile, blue-Chloe has all the physical freedom in the world, but she's emotionally handicapped and effectively trapped by her past.
I believe that the ultimate purpose of the alternate timeline is to find a way to "save" blue-Chloe, at least emotionally. (Maybe she still has to die, but that's another topic.) We know that all of her troubles ultimately stem from William's death, so it is quite convenient that this alternate timeline has him living at her expense. Now, there are numerous ways this could play out, but I believe that it will be at least possible to help heal blue-Chloe based on actions taken and information gathered in the alternate timeline.
Max tried to use her power to go back in time and save her friend by rewriting history, but that's not how time works. The mistakes of our past define who we are, and changing history effectively destroyed blue-Chloe. The only way to truly help her is to heal her wounds, not erase them.
Posted May 22, 2015, 2:09 AM UTC
You're very right, and kudos for the in-depth analysis. I remember thinking "oh man, we've GOT to talk about this" after Chloe and Max's talk in the truck on the way back, but completely forgot about that after, well.....you-know-what.
Chloe revealed that she actually has a hefty amount of self-awareness regarding the fact that she seems to blame everyone but herself for her problems. It makes the ending to the ep even more heartbreaking, in my opinion, because as hard as it is to see Chloe's heartache and deep emotional agony underneath her freewheeling punk facade, I felt like we were finally actually getting somewhere with her after the talk in the van. After she had cooled down, Max and her could've had a serious talk. Obviously her problems aren't anything that could be solved in a day, week, or month -- it'd likely take years -- but you can already see Chloe starting to slowly heal with Max around, imo, especially over the course of ep3. Well-fucking-done to the devs, because that just made the ending FIFTY THOUSAND TIMES MORE HEARTBREAKING OH GOD WHY
Well said, when we skipped to the alternate timeline I was heartbroken because I felt like I was making headway with Chloe and everything was for naught.
I guess the heartbreaking comes from the fact that this is not the Chloe we're used to. This blonde girl is not broken, she seems friendly and happy (well, at least within the limits she has).
I can't stress the quote of Jocye often enough: "William's gift were the memories". Those are what define blue-haired Chloe and those are missing at the blonde girl. We would have never had am "double dare" with her, never broken in to the pool and the friendship to Rachel would have been totally different.
To sum it up: Chloe is what she is because of all the things that happened to her. She has a right to feel all the pain to grow into the powerful person we know.
I actually don't think her self-awareness is only revealed in the scene with the truck either. It's kind of peppered throughout this episode, like when she tells Max she doesn't really want to "burn Arcadia bay to the shore" but says things like that because she's been missing Max and all the other people who disappeared from her life along the way. She's finally being vulnerable with Max again, the way she might have before Max left. But I agree, seeing her open up and then having her totally taken away/transformed into another person was certainly devastating.
Exactly how I felt. After the car scene I was set to help Chloe out because you kinda realised that Chloe is finally seeing things clearly again and that she wants to chane for the better. All that would never have happened if Max had not been in her world again.
The scene at home when the fight between Chloe and Max vs David is another scene that shows clearly that Chloe has become more confident and she now has support - in the form of Max - behind her that will fight for her.
This is exactly why that ending just overshadowed everything for me and everyone else, for a brief moment everyone and everything we had thought about up until the end just froze.