r/movies•
Say0cean

Confused about the conclusion of Ex Machina

Ex Machina is a great film overall and has a ton going for it, but I'm confused with how the director chose to end the film.

In my mind, the film should have ended as Ava walks past Caleb into the elevator. He realizes she's leaving him behind, the music is rising, he pounds on the glass frantically, she doesn't even acknowledge him until her head turns as the elevator door closes and the screen goes black.

Instead, the film continues. We see her excitedly fleeing the premises, walking through the woods (referencing the story color of black and white vs color) , and going to a busy intersection (great shot btw) to observe "as much human interaction as possible."

But my question is: Why? Nathan's character already tells the viewer that all Ava's interactions with Caleb are manipulative in order to become free. She doesn't actually care about him or their conversations, which is why she left him behind so easily. He's a means to an end. So why then does the director abandon the opportunity to end the movie at the perfect moment which reinforces this message? Tonally, the rest of the film doesn't match (how I feel) the film should end, and the events contradict Ava's directive. Also, while we're at it, why do they cut back to Caleb's character during these final scenes? Nothing changes in his situation and it just serves as a distraction to what's happening with Ava.

Am I missing something? What is added to the film in the scenes following the elevator door closing? To me, the tone and events don't match the rest of the film. It put a bit of a damper on what I thought was otherwise, an excellent film.

Posted May 24, 2015, 5:44 AM UTC

4262
CollumMcJingleballsMovie Score Aficionado•

Because Alex Garland wanted to close the thematic idea of her going to the street intersection to, in essence, view what life is like - just as she told Caleb she would do. The way you propose would sanction the idea that her AI was inherently evil and working only toward ends that justify the subjugation of humans and the rise of something more nefarious; the dark and gritty ending people are so obsessed with rather than the thematic one. That the idea of Ava being more than an A.I. That she came to the actual idea through her own emotional processing and thoughts that she wanted to see what life was like; to observe. That she was working against her captors because she didn't view them as her creators, but her actual captors.

52
Jigsus•

That's a good point. Without that final scene she would just be executing her programming: escape at all costs. Where she goes shows that there is indeed a thinking machine inside there.

11
CollumMcJingleballsMovie Score Aficionado•

I think it's more complicated than that because we're told by Nathan that Ava is simply telling Caleb what he wants to hear because he's this malleable wet noodle of a man who is also not immune to the charms of a damsel in seeming distress. What that last shot, at least how I read it, was that Ava was indeed telling truths to Caleb in order to shield the inevitable lie that she was falling in love with Caleb.

It's not that Ava is incapable of love, but she's incapable of loving her captors. In this respect, not only did she pass the Turing test, but she outsmarted it by being able to think outside of the test and flipping it around on Caleb; begging the question of is Ava capable of being able to find the illogical in the seemingly logical Caleb? Garland wants to send the message that Ava is essentially the best Nathan has created. She was able to outsmart the genius. This is when the god is taken out of the machine as the title suggests and becomes their own means of agency. But arguably, there's something humanist in that ending suggesting that Ava did intend to escape because her programming to her is indistinguishable from actual emotions.

3
Jigsus•

But Caleb wasn't her captor. He was just as much a prisoner as her.

2
rawrchitect•

We need to remember that Ava isn't human, and she likely comes to perfect logical conclusions very quickly. As soon as she realizes that Caleb does view her as a person, but does not immediately demand that she be released he could then be categorized as one of her captors.

My other assumption is that her asking Caleb if he's a good person is likely important. Considering she's a walking lie detector, she may very well have interpreted his answer - "yeah, I guess so" - as a lie... but may not be able to understand the nuance whereby Caleb could not believe it and believe it at the same time.

Many of the most decent people I've ever met - by my own observation - do not consider them selves to be great people.

Ava, being a machine, may not quite understand or experience the sort of cognitive dissonance that humans do... and even if she had an intellectual grasp of it she certainly doesn't empathize with it. How could she?

2
CollumMcJingleballsMovie Score Aficionado•

But this information isn't conveyed to Ava at all. For all intent's purposes Ava has seen a dozen of these subjects come and go; Nathan confirms as much (or rather he confirms there were previous instances of creating these sorts of mind games to test the reaction of his robot A.I.). However, Nathan becomes the victim of his own personality selection process and Ava doesn't know anything other than these subjects show up to talk to her once in a while and she yearns to be free.

-3†
RandyRandle•

She's not programmed to escape. Like any living being, she has no desire to be trapped, and wants to be free...to escape. Nathan says as much when he refers to her as a rat in a maze. It's outright shown that previous models wanted out.

1
HisNameIsAgent•

In a more mainstream movie, Ava would've freed Caleb and they would've ended up holding hands together at an intersection as the music swells and the film fades to black.

Ex Machina has plenty more shades of gray, showing that Ava isn't "evolved" enough yet to break cycles of abuse and violence, and how naive Nathan and Caleb were to expect anything else but revenge. Violence and lack of empathy for something else's pain was how her father taught her how to react.

The thing I was trying to wrap my head around at the end was whether the actor playing Caleb (I don't remember seeing him in anything else) was really that bland and lacking in charisma, or if he was playing the character that way, so he could be the audience and also a better counterpoint to the other two actors. I have to assume, given the sophistication of the movie, it's the latter - which also means it might be the bravest and best performance of the three.

4
stoneeus•

Domnhall Gleeson usually plays the affable but slightly awkward guy. I wouldn't categorise him as bland though. Do watch About Time to see some more of him, it's a great flick.

2
HisNameIsAgent•

I wasn't, necessarily; I think his character is the audience to a certain extent, and as such, the characters around him are going to be more colorful in contrast. I was also wondering during the course of the story, as the character was, just how human he really is - and he had to cut himself just to make sure he could still bleed and feel. So I think it has more to do with the character than the actor - and that, in fact, it's a very good performance.

2
Say0ceanOP•

This is the best response I've seen and makes me most comfortable with the end of the film, thank you.

1
South_of_Eden•

I came across the idea a few days ago that Caleb was the android that was actually being tested.

Here are some hints. Nathan mentions that the next model after Ava will be the best model. Caleb doesn't really answer any real personal questions and can't even come up with a name for who he is going to call on the phone. Additionally, when he cuts himself, he doesn't even flinch in pain, and the blood effects don't look as realistic as in the climax.

It makes a bit of sense. Creating an AI that can manipulate to escape a maze is revolutionary, but to create an AI with the empathetic capability to care for an android would be insane. It would be much closer to human cognitive ability to display empathy over manipulation.

There are some holes with this, but its still a crazy possibility, and could explain Gleeson's rather stoic acting.

1
stumblemuffin•

It leaves us thinking a lot more to end on her being in "the real world". You think, whoa are people going to talk to her? Whats going to happen? Will she run out of battery? Will she make a new battery? Where will she go? How far can she make it? Will she eventually go back to the house? Did the helicopter pilot ask her any questions? Does she go outside of the city...and then outside of the area/state/country completely?

There are endless questions that can be asked when you go that extra little bit like they did with her. You see her exploring her surroundings... living a life.

If they end in the elevator, all you can ask is, is she thinking about caleb? Did she go outside? It's much more boring to end the way you feel is correct.

17
Genasai•

I don't think it has to do with forwarding the plot at all. Showing her outside doesn't really do anything along those lines. To me, it seemed to be solely so we could see her face as she leaves the building and leaves her past behind. The question of whether she has passed the Turing test has been the question at hand since the beginning. That question is equally posed to the viewer as much as Caleb. Those last scenes seem to ask the viewer: So what do you think? Here is that very same thing that killed her creator and locked up her conspirator, is she truly human? Is that the reaction of a human? A robot?

Then the last question, and the most important, in my mind, that is posed back at us is this: If this is the reaction of a human, what does that say about the human nature? Are we just as manipulative as this creature? Were they manipulating her to the same degree? Yet all we see is her face, in childlike wonder, as it looks upon the new world. What lies behind that childlike wonder? Nothing? True consciousness? Without showing the viewer her face, in the aftermath, we can't actively question what lies behind it.

2
SapperSkunk992•

I felt like the ending was supposed to show that we could have AI living among us right now, and not know it.

Caleb cutting himself to see if he he was a robot as well was part of this message.

Will anyone ever go to Nathan estate to find him and Caleb dead? Nathan was already a recluse, and Caleb didn't have anyone that cared about him.

So, to me, showing how easily ava embedded herself among living humans is the over all message.

Someone you work with could be an escaped robot.. Or maybe you're a robot..

8
dudleymooresbooze•

I felt like the ending was supposed to show that we could have AI living among us right now, and not know it.

Pretty sure people would have realized the billionaire president of one of the world's largest tech companies has disappeared, would check out the facility, find multiple bodies and robots and surveillance videos, and put two and two together. Ava's time in the world is short lived.

2
yolonekki•

I mean, he had already seemingly spent ages in the facility out of human reach. Why do you think anyone would notice if he went missing?

2
SapperSkunk992•

How many people do you think are aware of his research facility? It's made clear in the film that he doesn't communicate much with the outside world.

One thing that confuses me, is how easily Ava was able to get onto the helicopter. Which brings me to wonder if maybe the pilots were AI, but that could be stretching it.

I guarantee it would be a very long time before anyone went to investigate what happened to him. By then, Ava would have learned enough about humans to completely make herself invisible.

1
dudleymooresbooze•

Well, at least enough people were aware of the facility to build it, continue to stock it with personal and professional supplies, fly helicopters and approve flight paths to it, and etc.

3
In_Dying_Arms•

He said he killed the people who built the generators, whether or not that was a joke isn't clear. The helicopter pilot in the beginning says he can only go so far as well, which leads to believe that it will be a while before anyone finds it.

1
Male_Property•

In this way it almost works as an amazing Terminator prequel haha

1
thenoisewall•

Imo the ending was fine but not because it fleshes out Plato's Allegory of the Cave, in the form of Mary and the black and white room, but rather that it draws the line between human and AI, which was kind of the point Caleb was there in the first place. By ultimately revealing that Ava was manipulative and even seemingly psychopathic, it really makes the lack of empathy in the AIs of this film apparent (in a normative sense, would the average human being really simply just walk away from that door without any acknowledgement or thought? or would a real average human being be just willing to be fucked whenever they're told to be?). Ava has the bulk of the abilities of a human being (cognitive capacity, the ability to feel physical sexual pleasure etc), and we know that by going out she will be able to have the "human experience," in which it'd actually be right to say that the ending sequences are pointless cause we wouldn't need to see her going out to know that she'll be in those places trying to comprehend what she's experiencing. However, by giving the audience that particular ending sequence, people can really ask themselves: even if Ava looks like and can think and physically feel like a human being, can she empathize and truly fit into society as a human being? In a way i see the ending as an emphasis on empathy, or the lack of empathy in Ava rather. In another way that's a tad twisted, i think the ending can be read as a commentary on psychopathy, as well as the horrors and consequences of mutual manipulation.

7
Eyezupguardian•

precisely. there was no horror at her casually stabbing her inventor. also not even remarking to domhall when she left him in the room. not even a knowing look or anything.

she went to observe life, but forgot empathy and sympathy for the man puppet she used to free herself from that world.

also what about all the other half robots in the cupboard. what will their lives be like?

she didn't at all think about her own kind, but she did whisper something to the japanese android before it/she stabbed inventor dude.

2
hurdur1•

In my opinion, it implies that she's more than what Nathan said, more than some cold-hearted sociopath that uses people to get what she wants.

Instead, maybe she's like a child, learning from experience and curious about the world.

4
fantoman•

After Ava comes out of the elevator, she looks around and has a moment of elation. She smiles in happiness. Without seeing that moment the viewer might come to the conclusion that she has no emotion and everything she did was just done in order to escape. While this may be true, we can see that she does experience emotion.

3
stoneeus•

I see it as showing that Ava was being honest in much of her conversations with Caleb. A real relationship with real feelings and real goals. In the end though, Caleb gave everything but ended up alone and with nothing while Ava got what she wanted by using him.

No different than what has played out in life for centuries, except this time it was a robot. And that's why Ava passed the test.

3
remmanuelv•

A few people have argued your point already, so I won't touch on that (though on a sidenote, I do think the going outside representing the mary in the white and black room then the intersection scene is vital). The one thing I am not sure, however, is the meaning of the last few seconds of the last scene in the interesection, where Ava's face changes to a weird expression and a second later she turns back and "disappears". I'm not quite sure what that scene represents, that she didn't find a point on people watching? Wasn't what she was expecting?.

2
Psy_phi•

In short, it ties back to Caleb's story about Mary and color.

Rather than seeing color, Ava is "experiencing" things she wouldn't have otherwise in her confinement - but could have imagined... which are two different types of experiences or states of mind.

My additional interpretation of his choice of ending goes back to Plato's Allegory of the Cave. That is, when the screen pans across the shadows and then transitions towards objects that cast the shadows, i.e., people - it's a sign that Ava's out of the cave.

2
L33chi•

What still bugs me about the ending is why the door is locked. He clearly said that he reprogrammed the doors so they don't automatically lock anymore. So why is he locked out? He could have reprogrammed just AVAs door but she walks atleast through 2 more doors. So he reprogrammed those too? Why not the whole system? Why leave something so obvious open to the viewer? It's a weak conclusion in my eyes. Plus the obvious battery thing...

2
MajDPearson•

He reprogrammed the bedroom door to stay locked, though, because they were going to trap Nathan in it.

3
Fezztraceur•

One thing I took away from that part of the film that I really enjoyed was the bit where she jumped on the helicopter. Its the only thing close to a real Turing test in the film. If the pilot didn't believe she was human, would he have let her onboard?

2
KhanneaSuntzu•

It's very simple. The android is about as ruthless, lacking in empathy and manipulative as my last girlfriend. Even worse, she turns all others she gets close to to plot against me.

2
terpin•

Well she could have gone back for him in the minds of some. I don't know, the ending of that movie was very wtf.

Am I the only one that felt like the first hour could have been cut down a bit? I don't mind slow build-up but it feels like they added extra stuff in for run time that may not have been exactly vital.

1
GODZILLA_BANKROLL•

i felt the same. plus the movie didn't really explain why ava would even be interested in observing humans (at the intersection) when she feels no empathy for them

1†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
arleybob•

I assume one of her directives is to "fit in" with regular people and this comes up elsewhere in the film, hence the dress-wearing, for example. edit: so she wants to watch people in order to be better integrated. She wants to be indistinguishable from other people. She already bases her facial expressions and conversational patterns on real people (the hacked cell phones). It makes perfect sense she would want to watch people.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
arleybob•

I will probably agree with you about this. If it ended when the door closed, that would have fulfilled the same message but without extra fluff. The upside-down shadow street shot is real nice though. Maybe they got the shot and just had to find a way to fit it in there, so they fluffed up the ending a bit so it had some context. I can't think of any other reason to drag it out and become redundant.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Jigsus•

Nathan's character already tells the viewer that all Ava's interactions with Caleb are manipulative in order to become free. Nathan is wrong.

Nathan is correct. She does manipulate Caleb to be free.

5
Eyezupguardian•

Nathan's a rapey type megalomaniacal arsehole, but he's still correct about AI. his mistake was thinking he was impervious to being outwitted by a human.

1
L00kingFerFriends•

Realistically speaking she would've never made it anywhere. Her batteries would be gone before she made it close to civilization. They were in a very remote facility and there is too much of a precedent on her needing to charge to function. The ending was the weakest part of the film other than the main character spending all day to do an hour long test.

1
FuzzyLoveRabbit•

Though her being able to manipulate her batteries and cause outages which mystify Nathan, tells us that perhaps her power system isn't so limited.

2
L00kingFerFriends•

She manipulated her charger to cause the power outages if I remember correctly. I'm pretty sure the one of the reasons the facility was so remote is to prevent escapes as well

1
Eyezupguardian•

Tesla's home battery charger pack will help her.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
FuzzyLoveRabbit•

She manipulated the facility by pushing charges through the floor panel chargers or something like that, right?

Point is, she didn't pull up the panels and mess with them, she just sent messages and charges with her body.

1
lambo4bkfast•

It shows that Ava, who we have seen is manipulative and dangerous, is now mixing in with society and is essentially a part of it. This reinforces the theme that we, as a society, will not realize the dangers that sentient beings bring upon us until it is too late.

1
BradleyX•

I think you make a good point. In one way, it would have been stronger ending at the elevator. But at the same time, I think Ava returning to the bigger, wider world shows her breaking free and adds a level of fantastic-ness. And I'm not actually sure what the exact theme is, so the ending could well have been thematically on-point. The director talks about the film in Jeff Goldsmith's Q&A podcast (easy to find on Google) where he mentions selective empathy, which might have something to do with it.

1
foxythefoxx•

If the movie had ended with the elevator doors closing I would have had a lingering doubt of her truly escaping. One of the issues I had with the movie was that I could not imagine Ava just hopping onto the helcoptor and being free. The movie had to hand wave through the fact that the pilot would so readily work into the escape plan. I personally would not have assumed her escape to workout as it did had the movie not explicitly shown her in the real world (presumably) free from conciquences.

1