Stoicism and Entertainment

Hi, I just wanted to get your general thoughts on the relationship between Stoicism and Entertainment. 'Entertainment' I take here to mean everything from watching TV, to playing the piano, to dancing to your favourite music, etc.

Personally I don't watch TV, and watch films fairly sparingly, but I do enjoy music and play the piano. However, even these activities (well, at least dancing around to music) has very little "productive utility" in the grand scheme of things.

I don't think Stoicism, the philosophy, encourages us to be robots, but from what I can tell... if something offers you entertainment, it should at least have some kind of utility or 'point' to it, perhaps something that you can appreciate intellectually (i.e. not moronic TV programs) or something that can inspire you (such as music). Even playing the piano could be said to increase hand-eye coordination and keep the brain active, but then again I guess we have to be careful not to create contrived justifications for idle activities. But where do we draw the line?

This post was inspired by the following quote of Seneca:

And what of those who are engaged in composing, hearing, and learning songs, while they twist the voice, whose best and simplest movement Nature designed to be straightforward, into the meanderings of some indolent tune, who are always snapping their fingers as they beat time to some song they have in their head, who are overheard humming a tune when they have been summoned to serious, often even melancholy, matters? These have not leisure, but idle occupation.

Posted May 24, 2015, 11:17 AM UTC

86
MinotaurWarrior•

I believe one of the early stoics is alleged to have died of laughter at a comedy show. Zeno, I distinctly recall, is alleged to have died of a sudden violent suicide after stumbling on his way back from a celebration.

My actions may be prosocial because I contribute to the development of some useful product (work), or because it contributes to social bonds and the enjoyment of others (hanging out with friends) or because it serves in the maintenance of my body and lesser mental faculties (learning, sleeping, eating, solo entertainment). Working a 9-5, and then doing HITs on mechanical Turk, doesn't seem like the optimally just course of action to me.

I think it's even possible for a life of complete 'liesure' to be virtuous. Imagine a person who is very physically weak, very poor at intellectual thought (bad at math, bad at writing, bad in all spheres) but very charming and pleasant. Perhaps the way this person could best contribute to the whole is by just throwing parties. Or consider the food critic, who has other capabilities, but is most excellent at eating delicious food and contemplating the experience of eating delicious food. You must follow your nature.

11
Scynne•

I think Seneca was just a tone-deaf buttocks. If music is not one of the most soul-moving human experiences, than a great deal of people - historical and modern - are very profoundly confused on the nature of their own experience. Speaking personally, I have been greatly inspired towards many other Seneca-approved mindsets and actions through the marvel of music.

4
bebestman•

Never forget that the ancient Stoics were humans too and thus also have outlandish beliefs. Aurel said books are a distraction, Seneca doesn't want you to listen to music and Epictet dislikes laughter at dinner parties. The common thread here, I think, is that they condemn a particul preoccupation with their respective actions. Maybe at some point in their lifes they even had some kind of problemativ experience with these things, at least in their eyes. For Aurel books were a distraction because he was busy organising war on the borders of the empire. Epictet maybe was a jokester when he was younger. Maybe Seneca played the lute too much, who knows.

In any case, what I would take from this is: Enjoy these experiences when they present themselves, but don't seek them out for their own sake. There is virtue in reading a book and drinking with your friends to relax or to enhance the friendships, there is no virtue in knowing all books of a fiction series by heart for no other reason than knowing them by heart. I guess for the ancient Stoics art for art's sake doesn't exist but serves a higher purpose, like all things do.

Maybe a last parallel, after which I meditate on your question some more: The Stoic will eat to nourish his body, he won't eat to have eaten. The Stoic will watch Mad Max to relax his mind, he won't watch Mad Max to have watched Mad Max.

3
duffstoic•

I'm not sure what Seneca is getting at in this passage. My possibly wildly wrong interpretation is this: many people continue to work and busy themselves with things in their leisure rather than just chill out. They do the equivalent of organizing their sock drawer instead of relaxing and be at peace -- they don't know how to stop.

The bit about "humming a tune when they have been summoned to serious...matters" I think is about appropriateness: imagine someone humming a pop song at a funeral. A person who does this is distracted, not present with what is at hand. Music isn't bad, it's just about time and place.

Epictetus mentions musicians several times in the Discourses and never says anything negative about music generally. In Discourse 1.1 he talks about the field of music doesn't let us know when to play music, it's rationality which does so. I think Seneca is pointing at something similar -- when it is appropriate to play music.

I think a strong argument could be made for music and the arts to be an essential component of areté, of excellence as a human being. Learning a musical instrument develops discipline through practice. Playing music with others develops social intelligence, and it is our nature as human beings to be social. Great music can uplift our souls. Music can be a great way to transform our mental-emotional state, and thus to interrupt "the passions" and reconnect us with more useful and resourceful states.

It's all about how you go about it.

2
MindfulMonk•

If you stop listening to music and playing the piano that doesn't mean you will become a robot. Stoicism is quite an utilitarian philosophy so the "productive utility" is highly encouraged.

The issue though is the same as "you should exercise, eat healthy etc.". It is easier said than done.

You have to ask yourself, how much time you actually need to "relax" to ensure peak productivity. You also need to be truthful, because as you mention, we are good at contriving justifications, the best person to fool you is you.

Only you know how much downtime you need to perform the best. Don't guilt trip yourself about it. Getting burned out is much worse than watching the occasional Game of Thrones episode while sipping a beer.

2
Aurelen•

I would say entertainment is something desirable, but it should be viewed in its proper place. It's not nearly on the same level as arete. So, if seeking it out and enjoying it gets in the way of arete, it's in your best interest to stop.

It's comparable to eating candy versus a full, nourishing diet. Have some candy now and then; why not? But if your diet is loaded with candy and lacking any real nourishment, your health will start to decline very soon.

1