Stoicism and Entertainment
Hi, I just wanted to get your general thoughts on the relationship between Stoicism and Entertainment. 'Entertainment' I take here to mean everything from watching TV, to playing the piano, to dancing to your favourite music, etc.
Personally I don't watch TV, and watch films fairly sparingly, but I do enjoy music and play the piano. However, even these activities (well, at least dancing around to music) has very little "productive utility" in the grand scheme of things.
I don't think Stoicism, the philosophy, encourages us to be robots, but from what I can tell... if something offers you entertainment, it should at least have some kind of utility or 'point' to it, perhaps something that you can appreciate intellectually (i.e. not moronic TV programs) or something that can inspire you (such as music). Even playing the piano could be said to increase hand-eye coordination and keep the brain active, but then again I guess we have to be careful not to create contrived justifications for idle activities. But where do we draw the line?
This post was inspired by the following quote of Seneca:
And what of those who are engaged in composing, hearing, and learning songs, while they twist the voice, whose best and simplest movement Nature designed to be straightforward, into the meanderings of some indolent tune, who are always snapping their fingers as they beat time to some song they have in their head, who are overheard humming a tune when they have been summoned to serious, often even melancholy, matters? These have not leisure, but idle occupation.
Posted May 24, 2015, 11:17 AM UTC
I believe one of the early stoics is alleged to have died of laughter at a comedy show. Zeno, I distinctly recall, is alleged to have died of a sudden violent suicide after stumbling on his way back from a celebration.
My actions may be prosocial because I contribute to the development of some useful product (work), or because it contributes to social bonds and the enjoyment of others (hanging out with friends) or because it serves in the maintenance of my body and lesser mental faculties (learning, sleeping, eating, solo entertainment). Working a 9-5, and then doing HITs on mechanical Turk, doesn't seem like the optimally just course of action to me.
I think it's even possible for a life of complete 'liesure' to be virtuous. Imagine a person who is very physically weak, very poor at intellectual thought (bad at math, bad at writing, bad in all spheres) but very charming and pleasant. Perhaps the way this person could best contribute to the whole is by just throwing parties. Or consider the food critic, who has other capabilities, but is most excellent at eating delicious food and contemplating the experience of eating delicious food. You must follow your nature.