r/redditchi•
Nashafa

New Changes in Reddit Chi

OFFICIAL

Hey clashers! I'm Nashafa, one of your Co-Leaders at Reddit Chi. I've been with the clan for almost two years. A lot has changed since I first joined the clan. Recently we introduced more strict rules along with a strike system in order to manage proper participation during wars. Unfortunately it has come to our attention that more action need to be taken in order for Reddit Chi to perform better in wars. While we hate to make the clan too harsh for members at Chi, we have found it necessary that changes need to be made.

This next season we are going to start giving strikes for poorly planned Clan War attacks. We hope that this will encourage better planning of attacks, resulting in more stars being earned, and therefore a higher percentage of wars being won.

Reddit Chi staff will be analyzing all zero, one star, and 50% attacks. We will then determine if such attacks failed to be properly planned. Poorly planned attacks could include (but are not limited to) the following:

  • A mass dragon attack against a level 9 Town Hall
  • Hail Mary attacks - simply spamming troops
  • GoWiPe attacks against bases with many compartments

We promise that we will not be excessively harsh on giving strikes. If you put effort into executing an attack, we will see that and you will not be punished. We hope to work with all our members on improving their attacks, and as always we are here to provide advice in-game, on the subreddit, and in our GroupMe chat.


If you have any questions or comments about these new changes please leave a comment below or send the mods a message. We are always happy to hear what you have to say.

Cheers,

Nashafa and the Reddit Chi Staff

Posted May 26, 2015, 10:13 PM UTC

513
Unintentional_BonerLil moe•

There are obvious exceptions right? Say its a rushed th9 with lvl 3 air defense.

Im sure i understand you mean an average th9 base for drags and such.

Also sometimes a hog attack can go wrong if a dgb wasnt spotted. So im hoping those 0/1 stars arent strike worthy if that attack looked great until the dgb hit.

But i do agree with these rules.

3
NashafaOPNashafa•

Yes there are obvious exceptions. We understand rushed bases will be approached differently. Sometime attacks can randomly take a turn for the worse and we understand that as well. As long as you start your attack with a proper plan, bring the right troops, etc. your attacks will not receive strikes.

1
UTXKaiUTXKai•

Will this be consistent through all our wars, or will the criteria for a strike change if the war is mandatory/optional and if we win/lose?

Will we also get the option to dispute a strike? I.e. BK/AQ was down.

Overall sounds okay, as long as we receive a PM if we get a strike for a poorly planned attack.

3
NashafaOPNashafa•

This will be consistent through all of our wars at Reddit Chi. Members should be responsible for making good attacks all the time.

You could dispute a strike if you found it necessary. Obviously there are exceptions. If you ever make a "suspicious-looking-attack" let us know why, and if your reasoning is valid there won't be any strikes given.

We will do our best to notify members if they received a strike for a poorly planned attack. The whole purpose of these changes are to help everyone make better attacks so we hope to instruct members on how to improve their war efforts.

1
duffman4evrDuffman•

I think that the general idea of encouraging good planning is definitely worth striving for. However, as a member, I won't know if my attack is 'poorly planned' or not until I actually perform the attack.

What if there was some mechanism to 'approve' a proposed attack plan? For example, I could outline my basic attack in the check-in post, and wait for some leadership/X count of members to 'approve' it? This might be too much of a load on the clan in order to make attacks though. We might reduce the load by having a list of 'pre-approved' attack plans for different TH level (much like how there are a few variations of dragloon based on the base you're looking at).

Also, are we drawing a line between attack planning and attack execution? Bringing the right troops and generally deploying them in a way in accordance to a plan can still go wrong if certain elements of the battle which require finesse aren't executed well.

1
dreamcrusher_dreamcrusher•

If you join the GroupMe and ask advice about the attack you are planning on a target, someone is almost always online to lend a hand. If you do this, the elders will for sure see that you have sought out advice in planning your attack and unless you deliberately do something illogical (like not spreading out a mass drag) you're almost guaranteed to not get a strike.

2
NashafaOPNashafa•

As dreamcrusher said, as long as you put good effort into making your attack, such as asking for advice in planning your attack, you will not get a strike.

We appreciate your idea on "approving attacks" but as you mentioned it is a very large requirement on clan members. We don't mean to be restrictive on our members with attack options. The aim is to simply prevent lazy and poorly thought out attacks. Feel free to use whatever attack strategy you think will work best. Just put effort into it :)

I can see how that line may appear to be a little blurred. We understand that an attack can go terribly because of unexpected traps, etc. - nothing that could have been easily prevented with proper planning. For such occasions we won't be giving strikes. We aren't expecting all attacks to earn 3 stars, but we do hope to lessen the amount of failed and one star attacks.

1
duffman4evrDuffman•

Sounds good!

1
LMM01Liamcal•

I like the new implementation of strikes more strict. I'm getting golems soon and I might be bad at GoWiPe. Can you explain the significance of many compartments in a GoWiPe attack?

1
UTXKaiUTXKai•

Since GoWiPe is more of a core-diving attacks, many compartments create walls and sections that your team has to push through to get to the TH, which reduces the effectiveness of your attack. If you can identify bases that GoWiPe would work well against and funnel your Pekkas, you should be fine.

2
LMM01Liamcal•

Alright, thanks!

1
AnzerouAnzerou•

Get some practice in with GiWiPe =)

1
duffman4evrDuffman•

With a brand new comp, I've always found it necessary to practice outside of war to get a good feel for it. Its usually (but not always) an elixir/DE loss to do so, but its worth doing I think.

1