"Spoilers" Am I the only one disappointed in Act 3?

Spoilers

Is it just me or the last act (the confrontation with the Wild Hunt) a mess? Little to nothing is ever explained. I was expecting some Letho-esque conversations with Avallach/Ge'els/Eredin discussing the Hunt/Aen Elle/etc., maybe even a visit to the "Spiral" mentioned in the books, but there is virtually no exposition about anything and even Eredin, the main villian, is never developed as a character which is just massively disappointing. The Time and Space quest and the trip to Tir Na Lia was a perfect time for this. I've read all of the books, and I still don't really understand what it was all about.

The Ciri/White Frost bit also felt unfinished. Instead of a pointless cutscene, could we not have a short Ciri segment where something is explained about what the hell she is doing?

I just find it bizarre that a game that is otherwise so well done (seriously, some the best writing in a game ever), could just fall apart so horribly at the very end. Like the pre-EE Witcher 2, the whole final act just feels incomplete, and I really, really hope they can revisit the Hunt and the final act in a DLC or expansion.

Posted May 31, 2015, 5:17 PM UTC

511
nycaless•

I wouldn't say it "fell apart horribly," but I definitely was left wanting more of an explanation at the end.

9
gorionn•

Yes, I didn't find last missions as polished as the whole story. It kinda felt like they rushed to just go to the "boss" fights, then few almost meaningless choices at the Tower and the end... I got the happy ending after all, but to be honest I expected something more. Last hour of gameplay wasn't as amazing as the rest of the game unfortunately.

5
Kardz3825•

Eredin was massively disappointing for me. I felt like TW2 had the right idea with how they set Letho up as a villain of that game.

3
laserszsf•

I was left with plenty of questions. What exactly is the White Frost/Light? A magical curse? a living being? a natural event? Why does it travel from world to world? Why is Ciri the only one that can stop it? How do Geralt's choices to make her feel confident or whatever even matter? All we get it some kind of brief, wordless flashback sequence. It was kind of underwhelming.

3
MeshesAreConfusing•

I had no d, but then again I played all the games and read all the books so maybe they just didn't do a good enough job of explaining it to people who were new to the series.

2
jinz•

You definitely needed to have read the books to have understood the ending better, they should have went into more details of the prophecy and Ciri's time in Aen Elle from the book in the game before the final battle.

2
Balorat•

Is it me or did you wrote the exact same thing in the cdpr forum?

1
stylepoints99•

Witcher 3 Enhanced Edition incoming.

Honestly I'm kind of sick of the Aen Elle though, let me run around Tir Na Lia butchering them like the hunt does to humans and I'll be happy.

1
Skyrar2412•

I agree. The portrayal of the Wild Hunt and Eredin was weak. Hopefully they will address this in a enhanced edition

1
jakemufcfan•

Probably the biggest question I was left with was who was Bea was she just Ciri's friend I feel that Geralt hints at something more

1
Sir_Lith•

Read the books, they do a good job spelling it out for you.

As a sidenote, I guess some things were left purposefully vague.

1