r/conlangs•
CrashWho

Comparatives, The Equative, & Superlatives in Odki! Plus a Couple Questions

Conlang

Okay, work is coming along very quickly on Odki. Below is my full section on Comparatives from my grammar, sans some examples because I'm too lazy to gloss them here. I do have a few questions which I'll ask before I post the grammar. I encourage everyone to look and comment at what I've done. It doesn't mean I will change anything, but it doesn't hurt to learn, and sometimes I like certain ideas.

Please don't bring up nobag vs nopag. Just don't. Every... single... time... Seriously, every time I talk about this stuff, someone brings it up. I'm well aware.

Okay, one of my first questions: In "The chair is not as big as the bed" is that like a negative equative, assuming that you are not indicating that the chair is either larger or smaller based off of context?

Also, I need superlative examples. Anyone feel like giving me some?

Can someone tell me what is happening in the following three sentences and how they should be handled?

"That was the fastest someone ever has run."

"He can run faster."

"He can run the fastest."

####Comparatives

Comparatives are formed through using the following words in Odki: nobag (more) & nopag (less). No verb is required for the comparative in Odki, nor is any word like "than" in English. One of the above words (the marker) precedes the quality being compared, with the standard (the thing something else is being compared to) coming at the end.

The order of the std, qual, & mkr is: mkr + qual + std.

The quality is never declined for gender and the noun being compared to is not declined for anything either. Basically, nothing within the comparative clause takes any sort of inflection.

#####

||||| -|-|-|-| nobag|notabréd|qipi|kotipi| comp|big|mouse|cat| The cat is bigger than the mouse

#####

|||||||| -|-|-|-|-|-|-| nobag|paRrad-ka|tte<weg>pang|tod-ke|edpobpa|tod|po<keg>dodo| comp|free.IV|time<Pl>|3sg-Gen|wife|3sg[Nom]|have<Pfv.Prs>| He has more free time than his wife does

####Equative

Equative comparisons are formed through the suffix -po attached to the quality in the comparison. They have an entirely different structure to the other comparisons. The Subject and the Standard are joined by the conjunction ttitti and treated as a single noun phrase which is the subject of the whole comparative clause. The quality is marked with the suffix -po, unmarked for anything else it might normally take, and comes where it would in a normal sentence.

Many examples of how this functions can be found below. The -po suffix can sort of be thought of as adding ``equally'' to the end of the sentence in English. So in the first two examples, they read more literally as:

``He and his wife are equally loud''

``He and his wife drank the wine equally''

#####

|||||| -|-|-|-|-| tod|ttitti|tod-ke|edpobpa|idto-po| 3sg|and|3sg-Gen|wife|loud-Equ| He is as loud as his wife is

#####

||||||| -|-|-|-|-|-| tod|ttitti|tod-ke|edpobpa|poR<kog>kivdo|igpoR-po| 3sg|and|3sg-Gen|wife|drink<Pfv.Pst>|wine-Equ| He drank as much wine as his wife did

The following happens when the subject of a comparison is a whole clause. In the first two examples the Subject of the comparative clause is also the std. In the third example the Subject of the comparative clause and the std are different.

Note that in Odki, when ttitti is used between two adjectives, it makes them entirely equal and of the same importance. See the section on adjectives for further details. Thus, the first two examples mean the same thing in Odki and either would be valid. However, the first is the form most likely to be found in casual speech, whereas the second is most likely to be found in written texts and considered "proper."

#####

||||| -|-|-|-| tod|kápto|ttitti|vatkom| 3sg|interesting|and|strange| He is as interesting as he is strange

#####

||||| -|-|-|-| tod|kápto|ttitti|vatkom-po| 3sg|interesting|and|strange-Equ| He is as interesting as he is strange

#####

|||||| -|-|-|-|-| tod|yipyib|ttitti|tod|kinekdo-po| 3sg|hungry|and|3sg|full-Equ| She is as hungry as he is full

####Superlatives

Superlatives in Odki are essentially adjectives. The superlative adjective, nobnobag (most/best) or nopnopag (worst/least), is placed before the word it affects. The superlative is then inflected to agree with the noun's Group B gender.

Note that adjectives and adverbs are essentially the same in Odki. Adjectives take the Group B gender of their noun, while Adverbs don't because verbs don't have gender. In this case, the superlative, even if affecting an adjective and acting like what might be called an adverb in other languages, will still receive the Group B gender of the adjective.

#####

|||| -|-|-| tod|nobnobag|ognobpakgo| 3sg|sup|librarian| He is the best librarian

Posted Jun 8, 2015, 7:56 PM UTC · edited

38
TotesMessenger•

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

^(If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads.) ^(Info ^/ ^Contact)

5
justoniumEarthk, toki sona, Mneumonese, Logikalingvo, (th)(m)ish, Conlang•

Is the word order rigid? It feels like a bit of a memory strain to say comparative statements in that order, so it would be cool if there was another order(s) that was also allowed.

2
CrashWhoOP•

Technically yes word order is rigid throughout Odki, though it is possible to have a freer word order.

In the comparatives it is a bit essential though.

1
justoniumEarthk, toki sona, Mneumonese, Logikalingvo, (th)(m)ish, Conlang•

Do the comparatives seem awkward at all to you? Perhaps you think about the language in a manner that allows them to be easier to handle.

2
CrashWhoOP•

Yes, they do seem a bit awkward, and I thought for a long time about them.

The reality is, though Odki is OSV, it follows the patterns of a VO language. The order of a comparative, then, can basically be visualized in the following way: "The dog is bigger than the cat" would be "Bigger than the cat, the dog is." Think Yoda talk and it kind of makes sense.

2
matthiasB•

OK, I don't get the order in your comparatives:

comp [big] (mouse) (cat) => mouse > cat comp [free time] GENITIV (wife) (he) have => he > wife => wife < he

So the genitiv swaps the order? Or das it allways mark the reference but you forgot to mark the cat?

EDIT: I had a brain fart.

1
CrashWhoOP•

You have the first one wrong. Cat > Mouse

There's no swapped order. Both have the same order, with the Standard coming before the subject of the comparison. Basically, "Bigger than the mouse, the cat is" in English.

1
matthiasB•

Yeah, sorry, ignore, what I wrote.

1