I keep breaking free hubs

So I broke my MTB free hub. It survived all 235 lbs of me for about 250 miles. It was under warranty still, so I shipped it off for repair. In the meantime, I picked up a road bike from Craigslist. It came with a Mavic rear wheel and free hub, and on my first ride out I broke that free hub too. Being used, I don't know the history of the bike or wheel; I just hoped it was bad luck or coincidence. I bought a brand new wheel, this time with a 105 hub, and promptly broke that one on the first ride.

At this point, I think I either have the worst luck, or I'm doing something wrong. Any suggestions? Is there any way I could be pedaling wrong?

Posted Jun 10, 2015, 4:09 PM UTC

26
MetaphoricalsimileOregon, USA 1979 Fuji America•

How big are your quads?

3
morbetterOP•

Most of my weight is not muscle. I don't think you're serious, so I'm not going to measure them, but I'm definitely not any stronger than your average recreational rider.

It's only happening to me when I'm climbing steeper hills. I'm not shifting when it happens. I'm just applying power to get up the hill.

This last hub died when I was in 34/19 climbing a very short but steep hill. I came in with some momentum from coming down a hill, but lost the momentum quickly coming up. I stayed in the saddle and mashed the pedals down to climb the remainder of the hill and then crunch.

3
MetaphoricalsimileOregon, USA 1979 Fuji America•

No, I was asking relatively seriously, thinking that at 235 you could easily be a weight-lifter getting into cycling, but regardless a 105 freehub is designed for some serious torque. Are you installing the cassettes yourself?

I guess that unless you are the 1-in-a-billion case for receiving parts with manufacturing defects, all signs point to you doing something wrong, but I have no clue what you could be doing wrong. Maybe try spinning up hills instead of mashing

3
morbetterOP•

The wheel and cassette were installed by the LBS.

2
dummeyMissouri, USA•

Hmm, what kind of breaks are they? It may be a combination of low spoke count, poor spoke tensioning/balance, high power that is causing your hubs to self destruct.

If this keeps happen, you may need to just go into a shop and get a more sturdy wheelset built for you. You probably aren't do anything wrong. Racers are hammering on their gear all the time and equipment doesn't break every other ride.

1
morbetterOP•

It's not spokes breaking or issues with hub body. It's the pawls slipping or breaking inside.

1