[Meta] [SocJus] SJW vs. Anti-SJW - very interesting post on Slate Star Codex

META

Hi KIA! I've just read this interesting post on the excellent Slate Star Codex.

It's pretty long, but I feel also relevant to the general theme of this sub. Here's an excerpt from the beginning:

The social justice narrative describes a political-economic elite dominated by white males persecuting anybody who doesn’t fit into their culture, like blacks, women, and gays. The anti-social-justice narrative describes an intellectual-cultural elite dominated by social justice activists persecuting anybody who doesn’t fit into their culture, like men, theists, and conservatives. Both are relatively plausible; Congress and millionaires are 80% – 90% white; journalists and the Ivy League are 80% – 90% leftist.

I'm still thinking about it, but as I've said, I think this is relevant for this sub.

(first time poster here, occasional lurker. If I fucked up anything, let me know)

Posted Jun 15, 2015, 10:17 AM UTC

198
SomeReditor38641•

The social justice narrative describes a political-economic elite dominated by white males
Congress and millionaires are 80% – 90% white

I think it's dishonest to move goalposts within the same paragraph. Same with "social justice activist" vs. "leftist."

5
Mefenes•

Just skimmed it but it seems like a faulty comparison.

Sad puppies are not about prizes being conservative, are about prices NOT CARING about politics, they have themselves nominated liberal authors. When one side wants diversity of opinions and the other wants uniformity of opinions you can't really compare them.

He is also engaging in an oversimplification of the issue. One can think that BOTH the pizza place owners and the conference organizers were wrong.

He is getting the political spectrum wrong. Again. A lot of us that fight these idiots are not conservatives, we are just anti-authoritarian and politically fucking consistent, we don't just give a pass to authoritarian bullies because they do it in the name of teh gays.

4

I read through it fully rather than skimming it - and while I can think of criticisms like you did - I think that the core point is better than some of the examples used, and I would recommend at least reading it fully before coming to conclusions.

2
Mefenes•

But the core message seems to be exactly that, that all reactions are the same. He came close several times to the real problem here, but he did not dwell on it.

Namely: There is people being fired or denied entry to places or silenced for having the wrong ideas. It's not even conservatives, Bill Maher is not a conservative, but he was caught wrongthinking.

This is something that is seen as normal and proper, and anybody who defends it is seen as conservative and an asshole. If I defend Brendan Eich, I am being homophobic and I'll probably should be fired, too.

There is an inquisitorial mindset here that is propagating among the left that is very worrying because WE ARE SUPPOSED TO BE THE GOOD GUYS. My ideology was formed by opposing right-wing authoritarians in my own country and I don't want the left to be defeated by victory and turn into its own monster.

It's the difference between seeing some guy on the news beating up black people and seeing YOUR MOTHER doing it. One is definitely more horrifying.

I would like to hear your own interpretation of the post, though.

4

Where I think you went wrong is when you talk about "the real problem".

I say wrong simply because this post was not supposed to be about who's right or wrong. Rather it was simply examining the mindset of both SJW and anti-SJW and pointing out there were similar patterns there.

For example, I agree that anti-SJW were completely right to defend Brandon Eich, But anti-SJW also demanded that Adria Richards was fired.

I'm sure you can come up with arguments why those two were different. But how similar would the anti-SJW arguments for a pro-Brandon anti-Adria view be to the SJW arguments for an anti-Brandon pro-Adria view? I know my instinctual first thought was "Adria works in PR"; but then I thought an SJW's argument would say a CEO is defacto-PR.

I think the most important thing though, is that this post is not saying SJW and anti-SJW are equally bad. It's saying that they both think in similar ways, namely that both are quick to defend their own side and very sensitive to attacks from the other side. And they both have similar underlying reasons to think in that way.

But that can still be true if one side is right and one side is wrong.

In short, I interpreted is as a call for anti-SJW (not just gamergate; gamergate didn't even exist during donglegate) to perform some self reflection, and to strive even harder to meet our own ideals of free speech. The example of Strange Loop was a bad one - you have to really squint to call disinvting a speaker "speech" - but we the next time there's an Adria Richards we should take care to only attack the arguments and not the person.

Now you could argue against me by saying that if only one side calls for firings they win - I don't know if that's true or not - but that is saying that winning trumps the principle of defending free speech. It's a decision that should be made very carefully if at all.

2
reversememe•

The only consistent message in the Adria Richards case was in feminist media, which was to take her side. I don't think it's fair to paint groups at that time as uniformly anti-SJW, as it was Donglegate that brought awareness of SJWs into tech into the first place for many.

My observation has been that people like Richards manage to rally a defense that other (mostly male) public figures simply do not receive or expect. Way before outsiders even hear of it.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
toiracse•

I think far more related to gamergate is his post months ago on the Toxoplasma of Rage which I thought was a very good read.

I don't think the guy likes being linked on reddit does he? If you're interested in the piece just search the archives for "Toxoplasma of Rage"

1
tones2013•

good read. not relevent here. r/TumblrAtRest

0