r/boardgames•
kyzed

Suggestions needed

Hi guys! I'm about to embark on a monster of a task with a short window of time to do it and I need your help. My sister is about to turn 18, and I decided to give her a board game that is Supernatural-(the tv show)-themed. To my unfortunate luck, there's only 2 of those and neither one is interesting enough to play with. So I decided, rather impulsively, to make one myself. The problem is, I only have about a month to do so. So I think I just have to pattern "my game" into an already existing one. I was thinking of maybe using Arkham horror or eldritch horror rules as my guideline. I saw a post in BGG way back where a guy basically did this. I just don't know if he did finish the whole game. Anyway, what I ask of you is a suggestion on what games should I based it on? Is Arkham horror/eldritch horror good for it or way complicated?

Thanks for the help!

Posted Jun 17, 2015, 9:55 PM UTC

44
dkl415•

It seems like it would require a lot of work, since there are so many components.

For similarly supernatural themed games, I can suggest: Buffy tVS, Last Night on Earth or A Touch of Evil.

3
SirBearsworthBattlecon War Of The Indines•

I think for the amount of time you have, then it may be easier to do a retheme of a smaller quicker game like Love Letter or Lost Legacy. Make the Princess/Lost Legacy card something like the Revolver, Bobby's Flask or an Cas's Soul. You are all chasing this mcguffin in order to further your plans whether you're hunter or demon.

The game is easily rethemed (I mean just look at what AEG did with it) and there are only 16 cards and some token for points.

3
rantspacedotcom•

Arkham Horror is a great game in itself. It's a little long but it's great with a good group of players. I've never watched supernatural so I don't know how to suggest you'd change the game but you can always make new character cards with characters from the show I guess. Maybe change the monsters as well.

1
CityWithoutMenI'm a good cowboy•

Base Eldritch may be your best bet, but that's still a lot of cards and tokens to rewrite. Maybe Elder Sign would be better? It's a pretty competent dice game.

1