Marketing ploy

[To be tagged]

Posted Jun 21, 2015, 9:26 PM UTC · edited

097
AnubArackDiana (Ethereal/Kuunavang)•

This will be downvoted to oblivion. You are 3-4 days too late to the party, I'm afraid.

11
Millillion•

minimal content

Proof?

Even if we get double what we already seen its still not worth the price tag.

By who's metric?

We are being charged at least $10 extra to re-purchase the core game.

Proof?

8†
EcmeltTyu•

I'll show ya proof! 1v1 me!

Honestly, people already crying about content is beyond me too. I qq a bit to my friends cause i want them to REVEAL MORE of the content.. but thats about it.

1
GW2subredditaccount•

Minimal content. Such as... a minimum of content... as in they have shown us what will be in it so far, and unless they really want to piss people off and REMOVE items they have already released, then what they have shown is the minimum of what HoT will have.

By anyone's. We can look at the amount of content revealed and compare that to what we've gotten for buying GW2 the core game. We can compare the amount of content we get for each campaign in GW1 to each other campaign, and then compare to the expansion: Eye of the North, and then in a comparison by proportion, we can compare HoT to GW2. And that's apples to apples with Anet. We can then compare other games and what their base game and expansions offered up. And compare price points. There are tons of data points where you can find averages and compare that to HoT vs. GW2.

As to your last point: http://buy.guildwars2.com/store/gw2/en_US/html/pbPage.heartofthorns

Guild Wars 2: Heart of Thorns expansion(includes Guild Wars 2 core game)

And the core game has, at the very minimum, gone on sale for $10. So, if you're intending to buy the expansion, which ONLY, EVER, AT ALL, must include the core game in your purchase as the vendor gives you no other choice, then you ARE re-purchasing the core game, and it will cost a minimum of $10, and if you have the core game, then it does not actually include any benefit for you as Anet is not giving any comparable benefit to players who already own the base game.

There. Now, I'm going to go to work now. Yay for finally being gainfully employed.

1
Millillion•

OP stated the first point as if we knew how much we were getting and that wasn't enough, but I agree that what we've actually seen isn't enough to justify the price to most people.

A for the second point, it's still a personal opinion as to whether what we've seen or what we end up getting is worth it. We could get all of one map, and it would probably be worth it to someone, and we could see a hundred maps and it still wouldn't be worth it to someone else.

And the third point: How do you know that the price of the base game is factored into that $50? The expansion itself very well could have been intended to be priced at $50, and then the base game was thrown on top of it for free.

0
GW2subredditaccount•

Apparently you read it differently than I.

To the second point, whether someone chooses to buy the game, and whether it is actually worth buying the game are separate things. You can compare the value and worth to a number of other instances of expansions, and of content, and you can see clearly that HoT is overpriced.

Well, then that's simple. If the base game is thrown on top for free, people who own the base game then deserve that free copy to gift to a friend, or to use as an alt account. But Anet is not doing that. And HoT, at $40 is overpriced, so if the actual price is $50, it is more outlandish.

1
Lord_of_the_OJ•

And your proof he's not correct?

If HoT is bundled with content why they show us so little and speak always so vaguely.

About the metrics - GW2 vanilla costed $50. This can be used if you want to measure whether or not the price tag is far. And there's no way HoT's content to be even 1/4 of core game. Not only the content but an d the production cost. But then you know you will have much less potential buyers than in 2012, so you might as well pump up the price and try to cash out.

-3
EcmeltTyu•

Prove that i am wrong, without first offering any kind of proof yourself is the stupidest thing to say.

Ifs dont matter. There is only 1 fact which is that they did NOT show much about the expansion which everyone can agree on.

And comparing a game with an expansion is stupid. Creating a world and adding to the world are 2 seperate things. A world that has just been created will almost always have more content. Content that is basicly useless to 90% playerbase after a short period of time.

2
PressTehButton•

The expansion would cost 50$ even if the core game was removed.

If you don't like it don't buy it. That is all.

6
GW2subredditaccount•

But it isn't. It isn't that simple. That isn't 'all.' It may not be that price if the core game was removed, or, if that was the price and they left the core game as part of it, then they should allow people who already have the game to do something with that core game addition, such as gift it to a friend, or use it as an alt account, or trade it for gems or character slots to use on their main account, etc.

This "Don't like it, don't buy it" is, one, a bad argument, and two, simply an attempt to shut down conversation and discussion. You don't want to discuss or debate this? Don't take part in the conversation. Unless what you really want is to quash dissenting opinions to your own. In which case, why even take part in a forum at all?

0
PressTehButton•

There has been a big ruckus already, 2 mega-threads and a an insane amount of threads and comments posted both here and on the forums, most of them ranting about the same things over and over again. We are currently waiting for a statement from arena.net, no need for more complaining.

I'm all in for a good discussion, I already posted plenty of lengthy comments, but in this scenario i think the complaint doesn't make much sense. He is saying the expansion isn't worth the money, i find that nonsensical, firstly because we don't even know the full extent of the expansion and secondly because that is a very subjective opinion. It's a pre-purchase, a lot people were asking for it and they delivered. You can at least wait till they release all the information before saying that it's not worth it.

What irks me the most though is how nonchalantly he is throwing his accusations at arena net. Also he clearly wasn't looking for a discussion, he just venting his frustration and expecting people to join the hate bandwagon.

Considering how bitter he is in his post and how far he goes with stating how worthless the ex-pack is how the devs are deceiving him and basically stealing his money, i think that yes, it is that easy.

0
GW2subredditaccount•

We can compare other expansions and what they're priced at.

We can compare the expansion sold by Anet for the first game in the franchise, as well as compare the pricing and amount of content of the campaigns and to the expansion.

We can compare the value of each item, the minis, the maps, etc. to GW2 and its base price at release and pre-purchase to see if what HoT offers is actually worth the price given it is the same quality as GW2 base game.

We can compare the price, and the content of HoT to a number of other things, and you can see, empirically, that the value and worth is not equal to the price.

Now, if you decide, subjectively, you want to still spend the money on it, that is your prerogative. You simply won't be getting your money's worth. Like paying $5 for a $3 hamburger. That extra $2 does not make the meat better, does not add spices to the burger, it does not make the cook a better chef, etc.... It's simply an overpriced hamburger that you convinced yourself to pay for it, and if you somehow think there is an improvement in quality, it is purely in your mind. Like slapping a 100 year old label on a bottle filled with boxed wine and then charging the price of a 50 year old wine for something that's not "aged" at all. Congratulations. What a deal.

While I may agree that the OP did not state things tactfully or eloquently, I still feel this "complaint" as people want to trivialize it as, is still justified and valid. It is indicative of a strong point. It's not entitlement. It's basic rights and expectations. You expect that you aren't buying a 50 year old wine and getting cheap boxed wine instead. You have the right to question the business practices of a company you have invested your time, money, etc. in.

And as for deception and thievery? Well, the devs have recordedly done both in the past with mass, incorrect bannings and no refunds, and then don't get me started on the whole "MMO Manifesto"...

In short, I think we need a bit more long smoldering embers of anger to mkae the devs walk a bit on hot coals and maybe thing they need to go back a bit and treat players like they used to in GW1... but oh well. I freely admit that is my opinion on how to get the devs to act like they did in better days with better ways, but I think it is fact that the devs need improvement.

So, does OP deserve the snetiments they've gotten? I don't think they deserve the negativity.

I also don't see how "Don't like it, don't buy it" is at all a good way to sum up the topic, or to foster conversation. You say you have tried to discuss it in other posts, but now, you're just trying to shut it all down. Tsk Tsk.

0
PressTehButton•

We can compare...

Go ahead, never said you can't, just make sure to take everything into account, including the stuff you don't know about yet. Like the content that they haven't revealed yet or all the future updates. Yes, truly a great and unbiased comparison.

You simply won't be getting your money's worth.

Again, your opinion. How do you know how much it is actually worth? You are just making assumptions. Don't go mixing hamburgers and wines in to this, comparing them to an MMORPG makes no sense, i shouldn't have to explain that.

incorrect bannings and no refunds

I don't know about every single case, but i do know that they usually try to investigate and resolve issues if the player makes an appeal.

"MMO Manifesto"

Yes, because nothing and that trailer is true and because every other game has realistic and genuine trailers.

Oh I'm not saying that this wasn't a major slip up from arena net nor am i saying that we should forget about this whole ordeal. We should remember this in the future. But we should also not forget the good things that they have done and the fact that they did in fact respond and complied to our requests in the end.

I do think that he deserves the negativity.

Yes indeed, i did try to shut down the thread. There is a proper time and place to discuss this topic and this thread was not it.

0
vengfulr3ap3rDeath comes from the shadows (SF)•

I agree if you don't like it, don't buy it. Though, no one can really make a decision on if they like it or not, because they have no idea what they're getting. But honestly? What i've seen teased and announced and such? If that's all we're getting, or even if we're getting about 15-20% more... it's not worth 50$ by anyones metric.

In my personal opinion, What i've seen leads me to believe the amount of content we're going to be getting with HoT is merely a handful of living world updates bundled together, slapped under the HoT label with a 50$ price tag, and that just isn't worth it.

-1†
PressTehButton•

It really depends how you look at it. There are already a lot of people who preordered the game so your opinion is obviously not shared by everyone in the community.

Here is my point of view: i played this game for 3 years with more than 3500 hours of play time so far and i've only spent 50€ for it. During that time there were also plenty content and feature updates, they also listened to us and implemented a lot of stuff that we wanted and requested. But we are are talking about the expansion here so i know that it is not relevant to you.

We are getting new WvW and PvP maps and mechanics, but so do the people without the expansion, so i guess you would ignore this as well.

What they have confirmed so far is new reward and skill mechanics, new and improved PvE content, new story with more free releases in the future, a new class, specializations and guild halls.

If none of that is interesting to you or if it's not enough, then yes it's not worth it.

I however do believe that is it's worth my money and i'm fully willing to support arena.net. Of course you and everyone else are free to disagree, i know other people have had different experiences with the game and some have valid reasons to complain. But to me "it's not worth it" is a stupid complaint right now since you haven't even seen all of the content.

I am sure i can't and haven't changed your opinion, so again my advice to you would be to wait till they release all the information and then judge it. If you still don't like it at that point it either don't buy it or just wait for a price drop which will eventually come.

4
Millillion•

I don't think what we've actually seen is worth $50, but I believe what we effectively know we're getting definitely could be, though I'm still withholding my purchase until I see more of it.

3
shirogatsu•

Shoo away!

I'm wondering is it a single person who creates new accounts every day and post same/slightly modified pasta?

5
indigo-alien•

You should have tried sitting in Lion's Arch when this shit hit the fan. I was there late that night simply because my wife and I went dancing. Map chat was howling about the price, the lack of the character slot and combo package of core game and expac.

It's safe to say there are plenty of pissed off people, and more to come because of the casual nature of the players who come and go, and find out what is happening later than most.

These posts will continue for a long time to come.

3
fortebass•

a)you cant say minimal content till, youknow, all the content is shown?

secondly and b) it'd still be 50 regardless, 50 is the norm for an expansion.

3
GW2subredditaccount•

Actually, it isn't.

The norm I have seen for expansions is $30 and less, especially if the base game was $60-$80 at its own release.

In the US, for decades, I see new games, for PC and Consoles, appear in stores at $59.99. Then expansions come, and at their release, they're half that price as often, in total, they are half the amount of content of the base game, or less, and require the base game to play the content. $50 for an expansion is not usual.

And so far, yes, you can say minimal content because we know what they have revealed so we do know the minimum. As u/Onlinerage says, if what is revealed were doubled, then it still would not be worth $50.

Look at what we got with the base game. A total of 30 + open world explorable maps, multiple dungeons, multiple storylines that converge to one point, etc. etc. Look at what HoT will bring. One class. As few as 9 new skills to a single class with still no option to multi-class or somehow really expand upon your build, with a pre-HoT-release trait rework patch that will reduce overall build diversity. One confirmed PvE map, and I would wager that we won't get other PvE maps at HoT's release, but even if we did, the total would not exceed 3. I would wager we WON'T get a full storyline that leads to the attack on Mordremoth at the release of HoT. I would wager we won't get any new dungeons. HoT won't bring with it any new game modes, or game types, etc.

And we can compare apples and apples with how Anet has handled additions to its games in the past. And we can look at the 'bonuses' of the HoT bundle price points and compare in past and present the cost of those. A mini? A skin? A Character slot?

No, Fortebass... You're entirely wrong with your post.

0
fortebass•

30 dollars? it hasn't been 30 dollars for anything in over a decade that's just silly. and finding what is revealed worth or not is entirely subjective, from what was shown and what i have played i could easily get my moneys worth out of it, hence my intent to buy closer to release when i have some money. you say im wrong, but i say you wrong, tis hour arguments work.

0
GW2subredditaccount•

The choice to buy the game is subjective. The value of it and worth, is objective. Anything and everything cane be broken down to its basest costs, and the costs can be determined by a number of factors. Objectively, if you actually have an open mind to look at the facts, HoT, for what is revelaed, or, even at the absolute maximum of 6 + PvE maps, and a full campaign to take down Mordremoth at HoT's release, is over priced. Period.

0
fortebass•

what is the exact price of an elite spec, a rev, and a glider then?

0
Paelmoon•

Ya'll realize that even if they took away the free core game from new players, it would still cost $50 right?

2†
Wulfgarion┬─┬ ノ( ゜-゜ノ), Everything's on the table•

and all your claims are supported by... your degree in economics/marketing/managing or perhaps research/studies/numbers?

yeah, now stop speaking bullcrap, what you think its happening is not what it is happening, you're just assuming stuff out of your head with zero proof and zero arguments to back you up besides fake assumptions, come back once you have those please or learn to troll

0/0 would not allow to live

1†
WulfaenFriends with Merlin Olsen•

Literally everything you said has already been posted. :p Mostly in the most upvoted submission of all time.

1
ofaniel•

We needed yet another of these threads..

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-15
Dwayneak•

I find people usually use the term "white knight" when their argument was shit to begin with and they don't have a proper response for the people who disagree with them. I honestly wouldn't be surprised if the content for HOT ends up not being enough to justify the price, but there is no proof. It's not out yet.

6
OnlinerageOP•

There are too many comments to reply to. Either way it didnt seem like people understood what I was fully getting to. Anet is using this expansion to milk as much cash from us as they can. I did state that the price is too much for what we've seen but that wasnt the only point of this post.

-9
Millillion•

So because there's a lot of comments you can answer any? And as I pointed out, you have no proof that they're trying to milk us. Heck, there was exactly one sentence in your post that was fact, and here you are trying to pass off all this bullshit as fact.

3
Dwayneak•

How do you know Anet just wants our money? Do you have the ability to read minds? Until the expansion comes out you have no evidence that the price is too high. You could be completely right, but until you have evidence it's pointless to insult the people who work at Anet.

1