r/asoiaf•
SimpleManSC

(Spoilers All) What the S5 Finale means for the Iron Throne

ALL

After the Season 5 finale aired there was a fair amount of discontent over Stannis's cliffhanger ending and Brienne's speech about Renly being the "rightful king" of Westeros. I think I know why D&D did what they did and what this means for the future of the show. Let's review:

Robert Baratheon became king after the rebellion because he was the next closest Targaryen heir after the royal family. Throughout the War of the 5 Kings the entire Baratheon family has been eliminated. Robert was goared by a boar, his children are all bastards, Renly was killed by a ghost, Shireen was burned, and now Stannis is seemingly dead at the hands of Brienne. With all these potential heirs dead and the lack of Aegon in the show who is the next closest heir to the Targaryen dynasty?

Daenerys Targaryen

Daenerys is now the rightful legal heir to the Iron Throne by all the laws of gods and men. I know that she already believes this but now the audience will as well. She's a fan favorite and I think D&D want to establish her as more than just a "fire and blood" conqueror. My theory is that Season 6 will open with confirmation of Stannis's death and after word somehow reaches Daenerys there will be some exposition explaining her rock-solid position as Queen, probably by Tyrion.

Posted Jun 21, 2015, 11:10 PM UTC

16
PixarLamp_Dragonfire can't melt stone walls•

Robert Baratheon became king after the rebellion because he was the next closest Targaryen heir after the royal family

I think people put too much into this line that Robert was crowned because of his Targaryen blood. No, he won it with his warhammer, as he says. House Targaryen was exiled and he took King's Landing, he took the crown by right of conquest just as Aegon I did. The Maesters may have put down his Targaryen blood as an after-thought to try and justify it but that's all.

13
ohshitagirlSickest burns in Westeros.•

Agreed, he won it by right of conquest. His lineage had nothing to do with it.

4
SimpleManSCOP•

I'm aware that Robert took the throne by conquest. What I meant with this theory though is that the line of succession has been greatly simplified. In the books it's still quite murky. Stannis is alive, as is his heir Shireen. Aegon is out there who may or may not be legitimate. Then there's Dany. The show has greatly simplified this by making Dany the only possible heir to the throne and I believe this was done to give her more legitimacy to the audience.

1
brashendeavors•

A lot of people think there will be no Iron Throne at the end, meaning it does not matter which people think they have some sort of claim to it.

2
JayPet94The Actual Protectors of the Realm•

Robert also took over the throne by conquest, so the Baratheon name is now the royal line. Dany still is vaguely in the line through the throne (if you go to the top of the Baratheon then trace down the targaryan line) but other people come first, I think. It's very ambiguous though. She has a claim, but like everyone else, it's a weak claim.

Also usually people who are infertile can't rule, and Dany is most likely infertile.

Edit: It's also likely the line just ends, and the small council comes together to elect a new royal family.

1
Zand_Kilch•

Unless r l j is valid and he lives since D is barren.....

1