r/Civcraft•
Wugglet

Anyone else find the new xp system ridiculous? 10d to random enchant your tool is insane...

edit: i guess it would be the enchantment system rather then xp

Posted Jun 29, 2015, 8:15 PM UTC · edited

759
stratmatt57•

At first, I'd agree that it's absurd. But if you're running a town where your citizens need e5u3 picks, you could all pool resources and it wouldn't be absurd. But if you're an independent tool producer, it is high-cost. I'm definitely interested as to how it will turn out.

I used to be able to make s5fa2 swords for maybe 28-30d, including both the price to run the sword factory and XP to enchant. It's interesting to see them priced around 120d now.

5
DarkjesusmnArch Mage of Etherium - The Only Gated Comunity on Civcraft•

i made the random enchant factory in etherium,

i made 15 blank picks and enchanted all of them,

every single fucking pick was F3 with nothing else

fuck that factory to hell tell they re balance the settings on what enchats you get

11
stratmatt57•

yeah, submit a request or advice and mention that fortune comes too often.

2
DarkjesusmnArch Mage of Etherium - The Only Gated Comunity on Civcraft•

how would i go about doing that?

2
stratmatt57•

discourse maybe? u/Dr_Jawa may be able to help more.

3
_PizzaShark_Discourse: Soerxpso, IGN: Flyingmeatballs, Citizen of The SPQR•

Make a post on the Discourse forum. All of the developers check it very frequently. You could also submit it as an issue on Github.

1
ProgrammerDan55Developer•

Independent probabilities are a harsh mistress.

I'll be posting the expected probabilities of each enchantment tonight, since it seems people can't read yaml.

I know Matta worked hard to balance the %'s based on 1.7 enchanting, but it's possible there is some problem here or there.

I'd recommend hopping on Civtest and doing a few large batches, just to see your overall probabilities before spending the resources in game.

2
the_gipsyGipsyKing txapu.com•

Maybe it shouldbt mirror 1.7 enchantibg, F is pretty useless in civcraft excepto for hoes maybe

2
ProgrammerDan55Developer•

Not my baby, just the messenger of woe hahah. But yeah, this should probably warrant a revisit on the Discourse.

2
crimeoCombat Librarian•

You get extra crops from fortune on any tool, not just hoes. A F3 pick will give you bonus potatoes and carrots too. Though obviously you don't need 10 of them.

220% is also not that much lower than 300% for mining, especially if silk touch ends up costing 50d each up front.

2
cattuscatMothers of Mount Augusta•

But if you're an independent tool producer, it is high-cost

As it should be. Massive industrial tools like bulldozers aren't made by one man in a shop, but by a company that many people had to come together and pool resources for.

4
Dolan_Draper(Logic_Man)•

massive industrial tools like bulldozers aren't made by one man in a shop, but...

...are made by ro(bots) :V

4
dhingusKhingus of Blackcrowne [In Hibernation], EDEN member•

Welcome to botcraft!

5
brintonChancellor - Arran•

I've known some guys who have built their own bulldozers. Not a project to be taken lightly, however, and we're not exactly talking D9 Caterpillars.

1
paradoxdragon710paraDOXdragon•

Weapons and armor maybe, but why should basic tools cost so much more than before? Not only that but we have to take in to account the repair costs (which are more with this new system) for tools that before were the bread and butter of every civcraft player. I can easily go through an Eff5 pick in 15 minutes

3
ProgrammerDan55Developer•

Not only that but we have to take in to account the repair costs (which are more with this new system) for tools

Not true at all, unless you reset a single tool at a time.

For 1.7, five repairs of a high tier tool would cost over 500 bottles. In 1.8, five repairs of a high tier tool cost about 200 bottles.

The reset factory costs 7 E Blocks (~550 bottles) per run, whether empty or full. If you've got only one pick, your total cost to have an infinitely repairable tool will be about 1.5x that of 1.7.

I'm going to assume you'll reset more than one tool at a time. Let's say 10 tools. Now each tool can be reset for about 55 bottles. So your total cost per 5 repairs for those 10 tools is a shocking like 250 bottles each, or a clean half the cost of 1.7.


TL;DR check your assumption, repairs are dirt cheap now

enchanting is expensive though

4
TwistTheCatAnthropomorphic Cat•

Which means I'm doomed never to get Prot.

I've been trying for two years

2
ProgrammerDan55Developer•

Come mining with me, you'll have prot the next day.

2
Lysika_Lantarielhcf pvp idgaf•

Try to join Mir, in order to avoid peasantry everyone gets a combat loadout and access to the Tool Chest^[1].

[1]Not Sovngardes home.

1
brintonChancellor - Arran•

I actually assumed that the tool enchant costs going through the roof were intended to make up for the new rock-bottom repair costs. It's still means a higher entry cost for newfriends, though, which I thought was a bit counter to ttk's intentions. It's not so hard to loan out a silk touch pick to someone you barely know when they cost 25-30d to make, but when they're 75d to replace it's a different story. All the value is in the tool now, and not so much in the emeralds, but the emeralds are still just as hard, for now, to produce. Maybe the emerald cauldron recipes will streamline things and bring emeralds down in cost to produce.

1
ProgrammerDan55Developer•

Nah, the reset cost was a "fuck it let's get it online" decision b/c the balance discussion was endless.

You're on the money. It changes the game. I certainly have given away a ton of Eff4 ST picks, and will continue, but it'll actually hurt now whereas before it was more a generous gesture.

ECauldron will help a lot. 30% more efficient output, same types of ingredients as DCauldron, just more of them.

Basically if you set aside your diamond cauldron inputs, compacting them instead, and save up for a single ECauldron run, you'll get 30% more emeralds for your efforts.

1
Evocat0rHow is me freeing Hantzu make me a collaborator???!!!•

Wanna buy a sword? B)

2
TheeloutSpongesuds: King of Balkania; Head of IACP; /r/BalkBrandPots•

So basically Operation Muh Cooperation was a huge success

1
volga-river-culturecheshirelulcat aka russian•

I think it'll do well to increase scarcity. Everything shouldn't be cheap as shit.

Edit: down voting because I think I should be able to build the pyramids of giza for 300d equivalent

5†
Lysika_Lantarielhcf pvp idgaf•

It's probably going to make newfriends more scarce :P

14
Aerothers•

^ wat he said. It's all well and good saying "things shud b hard for errybudy" when you're sat atop your giant toilet made of diamond blocks, but remember that people usually decide whether they're going to carry on playing this server within the first hour at absolute most.

9
ariehkovlerIf you don't see the fnord it can't eat you•

How many people are able to obtain enchanted equipment in their first hour of Civcraft since the map reset?

5
Aerothers•

not my point

7
_PizzaShark_Combats is where make empire•

High enchanting costs is, in my opinion, one of the less limiting factors for newfriends. I've heard a lot of people leave over the tick rate, and a lot leave because they couldn't find any actual people online within walking distance. Enchanting cost is the last time we need to worry about to retain newfriends.

1
Aerothers•

Yeah i'm arguing for not making it harder

1
tipperarytradPericorp | The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance•

Most of us weren't handed our s5f2 in our first hour.

0†
Aerothers•

No but most of us had found a civilisation and gotten a feel for how hard it is to get stuff by then, that's what i meant. If i had joined the server and found out it would require weeks of grinding to get out of stone tools i would have left that very instant.

3
Lysika_Lantarielhcf pvp idgaf•

You should've joined America... Oh wait :-(

1
volga-river-culturecheshirelulcat aka russian•

..i used stone tools exclusively for several months. it's really not that bad. and i'm not even that rich. i'm just saying it would be better if diamond armor was actually rare and expensive, and if magical high efficiency tools were actually rare and expensive. it's where this whole "bigger tech tree" thing comes from because people can, by day 1 of the server, have enough diamonds for a set of prot and some nice picks. if shit was actually expensive we would have far more people using iron and leather, and only the few using prot. as it should be.

0
Lysika_Lantarielhcf pvp idgaf•

You should've joined Iria man... Eff5 and a ST and a diamond vein on my first day. You can literally trace the America invasion back to OfUnknown!

3
Aerothers•

Enchanted diamond armor is rare and expensive. I have seen magnitudes more people not in prot than i have seen people with prot.

If you're looking for diversity, the problem is not that prot is too easy to obtain, it's that there is no point fighting unless you have it, as it is above and beyond better than iron and leather, and hence the only people that fight are those who have prot. If you make prot harder to get, all you will do is reduce the number of people who fight, you wont get more people wearing iron and leather.

3
volga-river-culturecheshirelulcat aka russian•

Stone picks breed character

6
GeneralThomas4CEO of ThomasCorp•

Mining 50000 blocks with stone picks to make a mega farm, and then having that server reset as soon as I finished built my character!

5
_PizzaShark_Discourse: Soerxpso, IGN: Flyingmeatballs, Citizen of The SPQR•

It might, but this is really only a problem for the newfriends who come on and think they're going to start the next biggest nation right off the bat with their two friends from playschool. They usually quit after a month anyway.

1
VisonKaiAMBeaudry529 | Augusta | Anarcho-Neckbeard•

It's not really going to increase scarcity so much as further increase the power of the botlords. I would never even consider doing the new XP recipes without bots. Not that botting is particularly hard to do (I do it on my main account semi-frequently), but IRL I have better things to spend my preciously scarce money on than extra minecraft accounts to bot with.

The tools being more expensive doesn't really do anything because with the server pop so low now (and it is lower, a lot lower) there won't be much demand for them, which can be easily filled (even more easily filled, now that we have deterministic enchantment factories) by people who still make XP, and then they get the diamonds from selling the tools. It's just a cycle.

5
Lysika_Lantarielhcf pvp idgaf•

The nice thing about building is that you can build pretty much any building for 300d.

1
TheHobbyist94Toltecahtl of Yoahtl | Lawyer | UN Diplomat | Eden Brother•

Happy Cakeday!

2
AukFearSteel fuel melt can't jet beams!!!•

You seem to be under the delusion that this was designed to make the game more friendly and fun for the average player or new players when it is actually supposed to make the rich and powerful more rich and powerful.

Silly Goyim.

1