[deleted]•

"Silver has been reasonably stable in buying power over the centuries"

Then links to a source that shows almost a tenfold price variance occurring within ten years.

Edit: To carry that math to the logical conclusion, if Dardi was being paid in April 2011 silver he would have earned an equivalent of around $2,331. He would have only been paid $208 in 2001.

5
BVKrustevOPPan-European•

Yep, this should be adressed...

3
grauenwolfSan Diego, CA•

Yea, I remember that crazy spike around 2011. My teacher was quite distressed, as she gained half of her revenue from the production of gold and silver jewelry.

Setting aside that and the even higher spike in 1980, we're looking at an average inflation adjusted pricer closer to 9 USD.

http://www.aboutinflation.com/silver-vs-inflation

0
[deleted]•

Do you have a source for that which deals with anything approaching antiquity? I know practically nothing about silver markets, modern or historical, but a quick google search turned up the following chart which goes back to 1792.

The CPI Inflation calculator provided by the Bureau of Labor and Statistics only goes back to 1913 (when CPI was established), but plugging in the 1913 value from my source ($0.58/oz) gives us an adjusted price of $13.93 - it has been mostly downhill from there, minus the two booms (although I will agree that it has hovered around $9.00 until 1980). I realize inflation inflation is highly variable between decades, but it seems a fairly safe conclusion that the price in 1792 (which appears to be over a dollar by eye) was probably worth substantially more than in 1913.

This is without getting into just how amazingly different the economic structure of our times and Dardi's would have been. Or hell, how amazingly different the economics of silver in Dardi's 15th century Bologna and Henry IV's 15th century England might have been.

I'm sorry to nitpick, but I've heard it said before by some of my history professors that finding equivalence between the cost of goods in largely different times and places is very, very difficult. It makes me immediately skeptical.

3
grauenwolfSan Diego, CA•

It's a very gross estimate. It's probably in within an order of magnitude, based on what I've been told, but no more accurate than that.

One of the problems is that the cost of goods also changes. We can't take, say a loaf of bread, as a baseline because the effort to create load of bread has dropped so much.

0