Challenge: AB sunscreen with little to no alcohol AND no white cast

Question

So I use a lot of actives in my routine, like a lot. I don't think they're messing with my moisture barrier, though. My skin and texture itself is really nice outside of one thing: horrible midday flaking. I can feel my face tighten and I know it just has to be covered in flakes like I did a TCA peel. It makes me sad to say this, but I think part of the culprit could be my sunscreen. :( Both the Hada Labo UV and Biore watery essence have alcohol pretty high up in their ingredients list. This is most unfortunate because I love their texture, they don't cause be breakouts or clogged pores and they absolutely do leave a white cast. I have tried layering moisturizing products and I still get large flakes. :( I think it could be time to go back to the sunscreen drawing board. Can you folks give me some product recommendations?

Posted Jul 7, 2015, 11:56 AM UTC

2027
evil_doctorporkchop•

This is the same challenge I have, but I do better with mineral filters anyway, which will always leave my face a tad whitish, so it's unavoidable for me at the moment. And I'm also starting to see now that the alcohol is what gives the heavily favored sunscreens their light, serum-like, quick dry texture.

However, I have heard good things about Menturm Sun Bears and Shiseido Anessa Mild Sunscreen. Both are formulated sans alcohol and based on the reviews I've read, either no or minimal white cast either.

6
balancedbrunchOP•

Thank you! I'll check them out.

1
GiveMeABreak25•

You said you use a lot of actives (which can cause flaking) have you tried using a konjac sponge in the AM before applying your routine/make-up to deal with the flakes? Just an idea.

6
marswithghosts•

THIS. This is the main reason my chin, formerly known as Flake City, is under control. That, and I pulled back on the active train a bit. I was overexfoliating and my poor chin couldn't handle it.

4
GiveMeABreak25•

IMO, most people don't need to use a bha/aha daily. 3x's per week is sufficient and helps control uglies that can come like flaking or disrupting your moisture barrier. I know from experience! Of course, YMMV and different issues call for different measures. But in OP's case, she wants to blame the sunscreen when that is probably not the case (bonus, she doesn't have throw away/purchase sunscreen!)

4
balancedbrunchOP•

I'm blaming the sunscreen because when I don't leave my house, but do the rest of my routine sans sunscreen, I don't get flaking. So it seems the two are connected. I use some form of chemical exfoliation (tretinoin, BHA, mandelic acid, Vit C serum or another AHA combination daily). I do not plan on continuing this in the future once I reach my skin goal for fading PIH, but for now this is what it is.

2
GiveMeABreak25•

Do you wear makeup when you are not leaving the house? I just know my flakes don't show until I start rubbing around makeup on my face. Just a thought.

2
marswithghosts•

I've cut down to 1-2x a week AHA and maybe...5x a week BHA? (Was twice daily!!) I use the COSRX A-Sol twice a day for maintenance but it's not a Major Exfoliant, so I haven't seen any issues with it yet.

1
balancedbrunchOP•

I do have one and use it, a soft clean washcloth (my personal favorite), or my Clarisonic a couple of times a week to help out. It does improve the flaking. I'm just worried the alcohol is drying my skin out.

0
2catsinjapan•

What is your budget? It sounds like you need a sunscreen formulated for sensitive skin and with plenty of moisture. Anessa Mild does leave some white cast. If you are very pale, it will not be very noticeable. It seems that Dr Ci:Labo sunscreens might be what you are looking for. Nicely moisturizing, ethanol-free and very light, yet SPF50 PA++++. They are more expensive that the Sun Bears and Biore crowd, but... they come in huge (for Japan) tubes of 60 grams. They were recommended by my dermatologist when I was talking meds that made me very photo-sensitive. I bought two new tubes this summer and I'm rediscovering them all over again.

5
balancedbrunchOP•

This sounds really great. Thanks! Do you know the name of the product specifically? I am trying to search for it and I'm not sure which one.

2
christina-rae•

I love Missha All-Around Safe Block Essence Sun! My skin in the center of my face is dry and sometimes gets flaky. I find this sunscreen very moisturizing! It also doesn't leave a white cast and it works well under my makeup. I don't recall if the Essence Sun has alcohol at the top of my head, but I do remember reading somewhere that the Missha All-Around Safe Block Mild Essence Sun Milk is alcohol-free!

4
Rawjerseycream•

I like this one too, and it's what I rotate to from the Hada Labo. I notice a wee bit of a cast, but it's tinted slightly pink, and I suspect I'm the only one who even notices it. Helps that I'm quite fair. It doesn't dry me out and it's nice that it's not at all irritating on my Pocketderm sensitized face.

2
balancedbrunchOP•

Rut roh, I'm glad you mentioned this cause I'm dark skinned and any bit of cast on you is probably going to be awful on me.

3
cynixxiNC15|Redness|Dry/Combo|US•

As someone else mentioned Sunkiller Perfect Strong Moisture. Another is Mentholatum Skin Aqua UV Moisture Milk, it had no white cast and no alcohol. It unfortunately is only +++ though.

4
queenofanaviahttp://wingmeadream.com/•

^^^^^^^^^^Seconding this. Love that sunscreen. I'm trying the Sun Bears next, which apparently is similar?

1
dancingmochiNC25|Acne|Combo|US•

Sunkiller Perfect Strong Moisture is one. Feels like applying another layer of lotion.

Although I don't know how this would fare on someone with sensitive skin.

3
chicaem29•

I was just going to recommend this one. I love it. It feels so lovely on my skin and it's great when your skin is feeling even remotely dry. I've just started using AB sunscreens daily, and ever since I started with them it's been hot and humid here in the mid-Atlantic so the ones with alcohol work great... but I just went on a trip up north where the weather was much cooler, and many of my usual sunscreens made my (oily) skin feel a little tight and dry. The Sunkiller Perfect Strong Moisture was, well, perfect and I know it will be my mainstay when the weather turns cooler here at home.

1
port_of_indecision•

My skin is sensitive to pretty much everything (although I don't get flaking), and I love this. Only complaint is that I want it in a bigger package!

1
leherrNC20|Pigmentation/Redness|Dry|DE•

Hear hear!!

1
pomegranitaNC44|Acne/Pigmentation|Oily|NL•

It's really nice and moisturizing but I personally found it to be too much for my (very) oily skin :( I can totally see why this would work for other people though.

1
empti1NW15|Aging/Pigmentation|Combo|US•

I like Shiseido Senka Aging Care UV Sunscreen SPF50+ PA++++. It's a chemical sunscreen. Sharkus_Reincarnus did a thorough review of it here which I agrees with all of her points. There's alcohol in the ingredient, but the scent is not heavy like the Biore Perfect Face Milk. It provides some moisture and leave no white cast. Amazon prime has it for ~$11.

3
lil-bee•

Try the Rohto Menthalatum Skin Aqua range. I don't think it has any alcohol, I have dry skin and am an NC 25-30 and these feel great and leave no whitecast for me. Definitely worth a try!

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
vanityrexBlogger | vanityrex•

Mommy! Mild UV SPF 30 PA++++ is the only alcohol free sunscreen I've used. No white cast at all, but a pretty slow drying time.

1
anisopterasaurus•

Innisfree eco safety sunblock spf 35 pa ++. My HG. Missha all around safe block and biore broke me out :-(

1
evil_twink•

Not marketed as a sunscreen but Sunkiller super lasting base is SPF50 and p++++. It has almost no white cast because it is tinted. It doesn't have alcohol. The texture is similar to the Paula's Choice resist sunscreen. Dries down super matte but the initial application can be a bit sticky.

I just assume that if I use enough (1/4 tsp-ish) of this base, it's the same as using a sunscreen (?)

1