Calls with the BM

I've held the firm belief that when it comes to children and visitation, you enforce the court order. Kids might resist, but they're fine once they're with the other parent.

But what about communication with the other parent? Partner makes sure there is a daily phone call with their mom. Is that common?

Also, what do you do when the kids don't want to talk to the other parent? I've been kind of pushing the older kids to talk to their mom, even when it's obvious they don't want to. I've literally told the oldest, Your dad is calling your mom, go talk to her. No, really, I mean it. Obviously, this is more their dad's issue, but there was one time where it would have just been silly to go get her dad and make her go. Easier for me to just tell her myself.

Advice, please. I'll be with them, and their dad, soon, and am dreading the painfully awkward phone conversations with their mom...

Posted Jul 7, 2015, 6:59 PM UTC

433
missy070203•

When my daughter is with her father I send her a goodnight text "good night I love you!" and a good morning text "Good morning have fun today!" and then I let her time with him be with him. Sometimes she texts me first. I think a forced phone call would take time away from what ever it is she does with her dad. That is their time together I just let them have it.

She just turned 12 last week.

She is with me 90% of the time. There is no court order (Because he never showed up at the hospital or signed the papers for her birth certificate and doesn't have custodial rights and because he doesn't want to be a dad most of the time. He is "too busy".(His words- not mine) ). They have a relationship and it's not my place to interfere with that. He is welcome to see her when he wants so long as she is willing, it doesn't conflict with planned events (vacation etc.) and he gives at least 24 hours notice.

We had a verbal agreement of every other weekend and one weekday in the begining but he constantly blew her off for fishing trips and then demanded to see her with sometimes only an hour's notice. It's been strained at times.

Sometimes I'll urge her to call her dad if she hasn't spoken to him in a while and I always remind her of his birthday and father's day and make sure to take her shopping for him.

The older she gets the more resistance there is to my occasional "Why don't you call your dad". They have a weird relationship that is completely different from her relationship with me, I don't understand their dynamic together.

It seems that letting them have contact on their terms fits them. I care more about a balance between what she wants and what is best for her over all.

6
derb8412•

" I think a forced phone call would take time away from what ever it is she does with her dad. That is their time together I just let them have it." I agree so much with this.

3
joyb27•

Ours text their mom and stepdad goodnight every day (and the sane to us) and it's really helped them. They can also text during the day if the my want to. Unfortunately yours don't seem to have that relationship - I think if they actively DON'T want to talk to her, you guys should stop forcing the issue because it's not going to magically improve their relationship with their mom. The calling itself isn't necessarily a problem, but maybe dad could say he's going to see if they WANT to talk. Those that do, can. Those that don't, aren't forced to. She might bitch that you're poisoning them against her, but you've been forcing them to talk for a while now, and perhaps they need some autonomy over this.

4
FakeBabyAlpaca•

This whole thread is confusing me. Everyone seems to be anti-calling when the kid is with the other parent. My fiancé - who has every other weekend and half the summer - has always called every afternoon to see how SD's day went and say I love you. She might miss some phone calls, and if it goes for 3 or 4 days then he will ask the mom to have SD call her. They divorced when she was 3 (she's 12 now), and I always thought it was a nice way to maintain the relationship during the two week stretches that she was with BM.

But everyone here seems to be saying that it's intrusive and disruptive.

I always thought it would be nice for SD to look back one day and know that her dad called every day. Are you all saying it's not?

4
curious4sq•

It's really about personality, relationships, and more. Some parents and kids are fine with not checking in every day. The irony of a lot of step parents talking about "if BM was secure in her relationship" isn't lost either when its very clear there are quite a few step parents here who have insecurities of their own. I can't imagine why a phone call is a big deal either. Sure some have pointed out some extreme examples but most seem to be talking about a 5-10 minute phone call being "disruptive"? I guess I encourage communication because being away from a parent is hard, for both sides.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
derb8412•

ss is 11. We remind them to call her and then tell them to. We don't however, follow them around and dial the phone for them. If they miss a call BM gets livid and makes them feel like shit later, so they usually do call her once we remind them. We try our best to "enforce" it simply bc BM makes such a huge deal about it if they miss a call. When they visit her, we rarely talk to them. It is their time with her, and we are secure enough to not need to talk to them daily (but they do live here most of the time). If the kids want to talk to us then they call or text.

2
polyspiceOP•

Maybe I should just assume BM is secure in her relationship and doesn't need to talk to them when they're away. The youngest still really wants her daily call, though, when her father asks.

1
derb8412•

It def isnt a bad thing if kid wants to call. We just know that in the eyes of the kids/BM they dont get as much time with her as they do us (although in a calendar year it is the same). It is often hard to stop a whole family to ensure a 10 min call takes place, IMO, so we just leave it alone. They are most likely spending time together in some form or fashion

1
her_nibs•

How old are the kids? There are all sorts of technological solutions available for this sort of thing nowadays, all sorts of ways they can quickly communicate that aren't talking on the phone...

I would not force a child onto the phone. I would definitely stay far away from that whole thing if I was not one of the parents.

2
polyspiceOP•

I try to stay away, but sometimes I find myself a bit caught in the middle...

1
esk_209•

Depends on the kiddos' ages. My SS is 10; on regular visit times (our 2 nights per week or every-other-weekend) we don't call mom, but she often calls him. When he's with mom, DH calls usually once per weekend and then once on one of the weeknights. DH tries not to call every night, although BM will usually call on every one of our nights (which, frankly, I have an issue with, but that's a different rant).

The only time we have him call her is when he's missed her call (like if he's in the shower or in the middle of finishing homework). So, we don't have him call her, but he'll call her back (if that makes sense).

My biokids are older, and they were older (6th and 9th grades) when we separated then divorced (9th and 12th grades when their dad moved out of the country). I've rarely (if ever) "forced" them to call their dad. I've reminded my daughter a time or two, but at their ages it's between them and their dad.

2
tiredchick•

It's pretty common when the kids are young, from what I understand. As they get older, it generally will transition to more of a responsibility for the kid and the other parent to work out.

The BM in my case is hostile toward my existence, so I have nothing to do with the phone calls. It got under my skin, but I took a tactic of 'this is free time for me to do what I want for 10 minutes' and began just doing my own thing during phone call times. It's not your job to make the kids talk to their mom, even if it is more convenient. Is she making it easier for the kids to talk to you (not DH, but you) when they're gone? If no, then avoid the awkward for everyone and take 10 minutes daily to enjoy some alone time.

One thing you could do is maybe agree on a time that dad will call mom for the kids to talk to her. They know they're supposed to talk to her at X time, you know when you can dip to do your own thing, and rather than it be a 10 minute halt to your day, it's a scheduled break for you.

1
polyspiceOP•

That's a very good idea, thanks.

1
toritxtornado•

Our BM and her boyfriend now have the kids' emails (ages 10 and 7), and that has made it so much easier. There's no awkward phone call where the kids don't know what to say. There's not interruption in our time. The kids can respond and email them first if they want to, but it's up to them. They each have a chromebook which makes it easier too.

1
wimwood•

My SS9 is allowed to text or call, but never asks to. I'm sure he would talk to his mom if she called, but really why would she? He's with his Dad, he's safe, he's busy, he's 9. If he wants to talk to his mom, he can. Seems like a lot of the phone calls I see are parent-generated, not kid-generated.

I could understand if this was a 2-4yo, but older kids should be pretty able to go 24 hours to a week without a daily call to the other parent. Only other time I could see a daily or even twice-daily check-in being appropriate, is if the child goes a very long time without seeing the other parent and is unsure, or if you know the child is placed under a lot of stress at the other home and you are sure that a daily call or text is not going to be intercepted by the other parent and further add to the child's stress.

1
polyspiceOP•

Seems like a lot of the phone calls I see are parent-generated, not kid-generated

Appears that way. I dunno, I'm not a COD, so I don't really know how the kids feel. I also think, in some ways, I'm trying to overcompensate for the divorce. However, as much resistance as we're getting from the kids, I think maybe people are right and over 4 (or so) is old enough to go without daily contact with parents.

Their mom is not going to be happy; she wants to talk to them every day. But I think she and their dad need a talk about how much is really necessary. Because it appears to be doing nothing but straining their relationship with their mom, at least, if not their dad, too.

1
polyspiceOP•

Why the downvote? Should I NOT be listening to the advice of the community? I call troll...

1
LaTuFu•

Communication between co-parents should only be as needed. With younger kids, it'll be more frequent, often daily or every other day.

Forcing/coercing older kids to communicate with a non-custodial is not a great idea, imo. Nothing wrong with asking them if there is an issue and do they want to talk about it. But not a good idea to push them in a particular direction. It'll just drive them away from you, potentially, believe it or not.

1
polyspiceOP•

Suggestions on how to persuade the mom that this needs to come from the kids? I'm guessing she won't respond well to, please don't call.

1
LaTuFu•

The only thing I can think of is "this is something you need to work out with the kids."

1
polyspiceOP•

Historically, that has not worked out so well :)

1
Autumn_xx•

Our custody agreement states that when the boys are with one parent, the other parent has the opportunity to call or Skype the boys daily. When my husband is at work or in class and I'm with the boys, I have to provide the communication with BM (aka she calls me on Skype). The twins will be 3 in August. I fully support seeing the other parent while with one due to alienation issues and maintaining a bond with both parents. When they get older they'll be able to initiate the calls themselves. Until then, we have to. Sometimes she's civil and nice. Other times she's a raging bitch (I usually hang up on her when this happens).

1
anytimeyoulike•

I'm a biomom with a new SO. My ex is single. I have my son call his daddy all the time. It's not at set times- just whenever it's convenient and he seems like he could use a chat with Daddy. He outright requests calls pretty often, like if we're on a long drive somewhere or if he's having trouble getting to sleep. I think it helps our son feel like he has a coherent family and all three of his parents- Mommy, Daddy, and step-dad- are available for him whenever he needs us. It makes him feel more stable and secure, and it helps to ensure that all of his parents know what's going on with him. My ex does the same with calls to me. It's sometimes awkward for my SO, but our little boy's mental and emotional health trump that.

My son is only 4 and the split is relatively recent, but I hope this sort of thing will continue well into the future. I'm his mother whether I'm physically present or not. My ex is his father whether he's physically present or not. He needs us both, and more contact is better than less contact.

So, yes, I think it's probably common, and it's a good thing. Good communication is key to every kind of relationship.

1
polyspiceOP•

Would you make your son talk to his dad, even if he didn't want to? That's where I'm at with my oldest SD. I think, until they're 12 or so, they shouldn't really have a choice.

1
anytimeyoulike•

Maybe. That depends on the circumstances. Parenting is about doing what's best for your kids, not whatever they want. Sometimes that means pushing them into things they don't like- including frequent communication with their parents. A generation ago that might have meant nightly dinners as a family; maybe for some of us today, it means daily phone calls.

If I had any reason to believe my son had good reasons to avoid talking to his dad, I would reconsider.

1
polyspiceOP•

If I had any reason to believe my son had good reasons to avoid talking to his dad, I would reconsider.

The reason is she's mad that her mom left her for a new guy that she's forcing her to accept as her new dad. As in, less than a year after separation, with no talk about what that meant, bringing her to her boyfriend's family on vacation.

1
anytimeyoulike•

She might be right to avoid her, then- I don't know. Do you think so? Is your SD trying to give her BM the silent treatment as some sort of punishment? That would be childish and counterproductive. The silent treatment is rarely a good way to handle an interpersonal problem.

Or maybe your SD is avoiding her BM because her mom really has been impossible to deal with. Sometimes people in exciting new relationships get caught up in the rush, make rash decisions, and won't listen to reason about anything. Does your SD have a problem with her BM's new boyfriend? Does she think the new family won't last and she's just trying to keep her head down until the storm passes?

Maybe the best course of action would be to talk to your SD about what her reasons are. It sounds like things are pretty confusing with her BM right now- maybe she could use some support through it all.

1
frenchpressgirl•

Sounds like insane overkill to me. We're on a week-on, week-off schedule for the summer and there are zero phone calls in either direction, by parents or kid.

The only time phone calls happen -- apart from, like, his birthday -- is when his mom is lonely and mopey, and she calls him to try and make herself feel better. (Gross.) He loathes being on the phone and goes right into monosyllabic dead-voice.

0