Thieving Vs. Raiding
I'll preface this by saying I love the game and I know people have brought this up before, but (nullifying my into) I can't help but feel I've never once been raided. Just stolen from. Don't get me wrong I LOVE pvp aspect of this game. Pvp is one of my favorite things in many games, but (there it is again) I can't help but feel most "raiders" are just keeping up a racketeering scheme. "Pay tribute by leaving stuff unlocked or we will destroy everything and be on our way." It just feels pointless to do anything if all my progress will be gone when I come back. There just is no way to defend yourself when you go offline, it feels like I'm getting punished for not playing the game and that is just obnoxious.
I don't mind shit going down while I'm in game, but I gotta sleep, I have to work, I have to eat dammit. Let me have some viable way to protect my stuff. :(
This is seriously the only thing that is keeping me from being absolutely 'fan-boy' about this game. I just don't really have as much fun on a private server, but that seems to be the only way to be sure I don't have to start from scratch every single time I long back on. Hiding my boxes and materials doesn't help either because of how small the map is and how big servers are.
It is alpha, I know, and the idea of building a camp that can be raided while you are gone is awesome. There just aren't anything at all that can even remotely withstand the most mediocre of competent human attacks. I would like to be surprised when I log on. Not just ready to wake up in a ruin and a pet cemetery every single time. It takes too long to establish yourself for it to be taken so easily, especially in the early game.
EDIT: added tl;dr
TL;DR: It feels like the game is punishing you for logging off.
Posted Jul 7, 2015, 11:23 PM UTC
i agree with everything you said, its completely true. It is a problem with all survival games but it seems you hit the nail on the head when you say " It takes too long to establish yourself for it to be taken so easily, especially in the early game." this is what can solve the problem. Reduce the time to establish yourself, dramatically in the early game especially. Or increase dinos/bases hp/armor dramatically when the owner is offline. At the moment the best way to enjoy is the game is to find a good private server with increased harvest and reduces taming times, so that when you get raided and ruined its X times shorter to set up again.
This very thing is what forced me into a pve private server just so i could get an idea of the game and how i should go about setting up.
That's my beef. It just takes too long to do anything. Picking an official server was my biggest regret simply because whoever picks the official time lengths is insane.
That's why I'm playing on a server I found here on reddit with 5x exp/taming speed/harvesting. My first day on the server I joined a tribe (I was playing solo, met some randoms), built a fort, found another tribes base and we raided it.
I play on a very good, yet still pvp, private server. Even with 2x taming and harvest, it's a lot of work. And it still takes 10% of the time to ruin, that it takes to build.
I think they should beef up the walls, thatch is weak, no prob. But beef up wood, make stone even better, and so on. It's super demoralizing to put 200+hrs into your fort and dinos just to logo and have them be gone.
Getting robbed is one thing, but utter destruction while offline is another. I got a baby and a job (the wife plays too) you just can't log in enough. There are some decent weekend raids only serves around though.
If you really think about trying to destroy a log cabin, it'd not be easy by any means.
It is otherwise an excellent survival game that does so much right. It's just a little unforgiving for those of us who can't play it as a career.