Myths Comedians Believe
harryjriley.wordpress.com/2015/07/13/myths-co...Posted Jul 13, 2015, 8:56 PM UTC
Posted Jul 13, 2015, 8:56 PM UTC
Oh look another blog about comedy.
There are bad crowds and going up first does take more skill
No such thing: apparently you've never been to a show after midnight on a Friday where 3/4 of the crowd is drunken 20-30 somethings who don't want jokes. LOL I have and it's a disaster. Our club used to do 3 shows on Friday and the 3rd show was roulette. I mean these people could be rowdy as hell! Sometimes it was fun, most of the time it was a test of patients and how many good dick jokes you had in your set list.
One myth that drives me crazy is that being funny comes from going up all the time. It doesn't. You're either naturally funny or you're not. You and plug away at it, constantly writing new bits and throwing out the parts that don't work and keeping the parts that do, but you're always going to get stomped by someone who is naturally funny and knows how to write a joke.
Yea, natural ability is huge. But, hard work can make up for much of the deficiency is you have an ounce of talent. The number of people who aren't the most talented but work like mother fuckers is not insignificant. Conversely, the number of those with talent who don't work is significant (so many funny, lazy comics who will quit eventually)
I agree with what you said. But hard work can't teach you to write a joke. You can read a book on it, you can learn a formula, and you can even use that to stumble upon a bit that works every once in awhile, but you can't learn to be funny.
The whole "go up as often as you can" mantra fails to mention that you have to have a shred of talent for it to make a difference. The vast majority of the people doing stand-up have no business on a stage. Encouraging them to go up as often as possible does nothing but turn crowds off to live comedy.
I kind of agree with you, going up is important but there's more to it than that.
There are some people who go up a lot but don't seem to realise that there's more to it than that, as if going up and doing the same non-joke will make it good. You have to be self critical and think what does and doesn't work.
I'd also say there's a point where you're comfortable on stage and depending where in your comedy career you are, you can't get anymore comfortable.
Speaking of comfort though, there's a school of thought out there that discomfort heightens the comedy. Louis CK is in that school. And I've experienced it too, to an extent, I tend to do better with fresh new material that I'm unsure of, because my nervous energy gets laughs, and then when I break out old material that I know better, I lose a little something. Not to say that it's all bad, because there are pluses to using familiar material, but there are also minuses.
I've seen fuckers go up who are entirely not funny. I write them off, ignore their sets at mics. Then, like a year later, I'll catch a set and there'll be a real difference. Fuckers can learn how to be funny.
It might not make you funny. But for the guys who are funny? It separates the good from the great. A lot of guys are naturally funny, and they are comedians. You gotta just work harder than the.
Going up all the time makes you more comfortable on stage. So yeah it does help. If you keep doing something and don't get better than you obviously aren't trying or your definition of trying needs an adjustment.
Going up all the time makes you more comfortable on stage. So yeah it does help.
I didn't say it doesn't help. But going up all the time isn't going to take someone with no talent and make them talented.
Yeah I guess, but I think what people try to suggest with that comment is that work ethic is more important then talent.
Well then, they're wrong.
I believe in bad crowds, and I've seen them. There is absolutely such thing as a GOOD crowd, so there has to be bad too.
"Bad crowd" isn't really an excuse, but it's def an impediment. You just have to work a lot harder to make them laugh. I hate when people say "there's no such thing as one," it's such a corny, false affirmation to me.