Top Four The Rivals - Transfer Window Special
Ok guys I put together some thoughts on other club's transfer windows so far.
#Chelsea
Ins Falcao, Nathan, Begovic
Main Outs Cech, Drogba
Falcao A strange choice, agent conspiracy theories notwithstanding, by Chelsea. I always thought Falcao looked a second behind the pace with us – his touch, finishing, ability to hold up the ball all looked poor. Still he’s likely to be Chelsea’s backup to a backup striker. If they let Remy go then things get a bit more interesting because, with Costa’s glass hamstrings, Falcao could have the goal scoring expectations of a title challenger hoisted on him. There is no denying Falcao’s pedigree though and if he gets back to half of his original level, he’ll provide more than adequate backup.
Begovic A great backup goalkeeper for Chelsea. They will be losing Cech who is both a winner and still one of the best goalkeepers in the Premier League which will have an impact upon their team I’m sure, however Begovic will provide excellent backup
Nathan I was going to look into him more because I don’t know much about him but I actually already have a prediction; he won’t get a visa for a few seasons before moving on to the newest £bnaires on the scene, West Ham, for £20m without ever playing a match for Chelsea
Overall it has been a fairly quiet transfer window so far for Chelsea – Of course we have plenty of time left until the transfer window shuts at 18:00 on September 1st but I always got the impression that there'd be no radical movements at Chelsea. Possibly Cuadrado could leave with someone like Pedro coming in but other than that I really don’t expect huge things from them.
#Manchester City
Ins Sterling, Unal
Main Outs Milner
Sterling A strange one because I think he’s a great buy for them but at a ludicrous price. I know we shouldn’t, and can’t really, mock other clubs’ overspending but £44m + £5m seems a little high. A highly talented youngster, one of the most promising in England, he will bring speed, dribbling and directness to the City front line. A Front 3 of Silva, Aguero, Sterling looks a bit frightening if it clicks. He’ll definitely go into next season with something to prove, after Liverpool constantly leaked little details about how moronic his behaviour has been, so expect him to hit the ground running. Short-term and long-term I personally think he’ll be a great buy (if a little expensive)
Unal Erm. So, Enes Unal is here everyone. 18 years old and Turkish are some of the things I can gather from Wikipedia. Everyone says he’s a promising youngster so we’ll see if he gets included in the City team. Like Nathan though, if anyone actually knows anything about him feel free to write it below.
Until this weekend City had done nothing so far – Sterling will, regardless of how the press have turned against him, be a good player for them but I imagine we’ll see a few more players coming in yet. Personally I think they need another midfielder, new left backs, a backup right back and a new centre-back, maybe even a new striker if they keep selling everyone. Will they manage to get all this business done in the window? I don’t know, I’m just a guy on the internet.
#Arsenal
Ins Cech
Main Outs Podolski
Cech Well this won’t take long. Chelsea have once again done their recent thing of moving on great players to their closest rivals and I personally think Cech is a signing that can’t be under-estimated. Whilst he won’t single-handedly drag them to a PL title, he will bring a winning mentality and confidence to a team that looks like they might genuinely hit the peak they’ve been promising to hit for about 10 years.
Now is the interesting part of the window – if Arsenal build on signing Cech and go on to plug their other gaps (such as a ball-playing defensive midfielder and a consistently good striker) then they could genuinely be a threat next season to the title. However, if they decide that Coquelin’s first decent half of a season in his career is enough that they will continue to play him, with Cazorla being wasted alongside him to make up for his poor ball distribution, and not buy a new midfielder then fantastic. Similarly if they decide that Giroud and Welbeck are consistent enough strikers not to require investment then we can all breathe a little easier. The worst part is recently with Arsene Wenger you never know – this is a manager who signed Sanchez & Ozil for fairly big money. Then again this is also the manager who doesn’t seem to like spending money, even now the purse strings are a little looser. All of this means Arsenal will likely be interesting to watch this window.
#Liverpool
Ins Bogdan, Milner, Ings, Origi, Firmino, Gomez, Clyne
Main Outs Glen Johnson, Steven Gerrard, Raheem Sterling (I can't believe I forgot!)
Bogdan Backup for a goalkeeper (Mignolet) who should himself be a backup for a title challenging/top 4 challenging team.
Milner A good signing for them – versatile and hard working. He has a decent free-kick on him too. I have noticed him, during this move, changing from being a “decent” player when he was a backup at City to becoming a “great” player now he’s moved to Liverpool. In all seriousness, I don’t think there’s much to say. Although, he is only 1.5 years younger than Bastian Schweinsteiger and is being paid £150K/week (which is more than Schweinsteiger) – so make of that what you will.
Ings Another striker for Liverpool. This lad, who’s lived in Burnley for long enough to age 25 years, could go either way. He is hard working, seemed quite skilful on the ball against us and can finish sometimes. He has missed some absolute sitters though for Burnley and for England U-21s recently and still has a long way to go. If he starts up front for them I wouldn’t be too worried.
Gomez Youngster – backup, promising. Don’t know much more than this so if you do, feel free to expand below.
Origi Yet another striker! They’ve become a striker hoarder, scouring the footballing world’s equivalent of ebay looking for deals on up and coming strikers or established strikers or over-the-hill strikers. Then they buy them and lock them in their room of strikers and try to keep them forever. Occasionally they get out and flee to Barcelona but most are still there. Anyway, Origi looked good in the World Cup I thought. Looked fast and direct and kept Lukaku out of the team too. Then he played for a poor Lille team for another season and wasn’t very good so now I have no idea what to expect if he does make it out of the striker room and onto the pitch.
Clyne A good RB. I was disappointed that we missed out on him (well until we did our own business). Was one of the best in the league last year until January and then seemed to switch off and stopped being fantastic. Offensively is limited, has a poor cross on him, but defensively is fantastic, especially at one on one defending. Will be a decent upgrade for them on Johnson and means they might stop playing players like Markovic at RB which could free him and others (Ibe) up to play in their actual positions.
Firmino A promising, young, tricky Brazilian player who misses open nets for Brazil but scores lovely volleys from outside of the area for Hoffenheim. He’s another player that, like Milner, has turned over the space of a day from a promising youngster into a good player and then into a world class player. I honestly didn’t know so many Liverpool fans watched Bundesliga (especially teams like Hoffenheim) but we all live and learn. Anyway, he’s a genuine talent and, I think, will do well for them with Coutinho next season until he gets moved by Rodgers to play as a Sweeper in a back 3
Overall I think Liverpool have done the transfer business of a 5th place football club. They’ve brought in some promising youth, they’ve brought in some players from other clubs in the league by promising them first team football instead of rotation and they’ve brought in some top of their range players (Firmino). They’ve lost one of their winners though (Gerrard) and whether anyone can provide that kind of mentality around the club remains to be seen. As pointed out below I've forgotten about Sterling! This kid (20 years old) was one of the only good performer's from Liverpool's first half of 14/15 - without him they would have probably been much lower than they were before they started their run of form. He also picked up the slack massively when Suarez and Sturridge dropped off during their title challenge. they will miss him!
#Tottenham Hotspur
Ins Alderweireld, Trippier, Wimmer
Main Outs Paulinho, Capoue, Assou-Ekotto
Alderweireld A talented CB who, after having a great initial loan with Southampton, has no joined Spurs from Atletico Madrid in a fairly acrimonious transfer that ended with threats of legal action and a senior member of a club being sacked. Anyway, he seems really good. Confident on the ball and can play alongside Vertonghen and maybe form a solid partnership with him. Wouldn't be a Spurs team without calamitous defending though.
Trippier A little like Liverpool, except with RBs, Spurs have popped Trippier into their room full of right backs. However, he did seem talented when playing for Burnley and has a pretty wicked cross - Kane is most likely looking forward to this. Defensively though, I don't know enough about his game to say this with any real confidence, he seemed a bit suspect whenever I watched him. Time will tell.
Wimmer Another defender from Spurs. I don't personally know anything about him so I'll just leave this to the people below to mention.
A good of business for Spurs so far in that they've signed the 2 defenders that will most likely make up their XI's back four's right hand side. They've also managed to move on some players who looked destined to wallow as dead-weight (Paulinho, Capoue) and are looking likely to move on Stambouli too. Anyway, Spurs are basically only looking to signing Belgian players from here on
Ok guys, I’m done here. Add your own opinions below on the other team’s transfer windows and who you think will be challenging for the Title and T4 next year.
Posted Jul 14, 2015, 9:18 AM UTC · edited
I was expecting some silly question like, "DAE think we are doing better than them in the transfer window?"
I'm pleasantly surprised to find a really nice overview. Keep up the good work mate, it's posts like this that keep the standard of this sub high.
Thanks man!
I just wanted to get a decent discussion going. I like to think I was quite impartial in my write ups.
I think it's just a bit early to say at this stage.
City, Chelsea and Arsenal will all do loads of business before the window closes so we can't really judge properly yet.
Think Liverpool will be done once they get a striker, probably Benteke in which case I don't see them getting top 4.
Yup i agree, just an early bit of looking at their windows so far.
Would you say Arsenal would be title contenders like us if they picked up a striker?
I think that depends what you call contending.
Personally I think Chelsea will win by 5-9 points.
It's quite arrogant to just assume we're contenders and Arsenal won't be given they just finished above us by five points imo.
You can say we made signings but we made signings last season and almost all of them contributed very little. Signings aren't a guarantee of improvement.
Yea, this is fantastic. I do a decent job of keeping up with players coming and going at the top clubs, but this provides context for those moves and a United perspective on each. I also like the banter sprinkled in it.