Why are many costs inflated when you have insurance?

I have a question about the costs that the Doctors and medical providers charge to the Insurance companies.

My wife has a High Deductible Health plan through her employer for her and my child (I think the deductible is $3000 and max out of pocket is $6000 on a plan with Aetna).

Anyway, we looked at the numbers and thought it was a good value because we estimated that even if there were 10 to 15 office visits for colds, etc over the year we'd still only be paying $1800 or so, and her employer funds the first $1500 of the HSA each year.

My assumption was that a typical Dr's visit was $100 to $150 and that the insurance companies would typically negotiate a discount on that rate. We checked with the medical group that she goes to and their uninsured price was listed as $125.

Anyway, she got an infection that required antibiotics and went in for a office visit so she could get a prescription. They also had her follow up the next day as well.

The bill we got from them was close to $900 for the two visits (the lab costs were billed separately at a reasonable cost). Apparently, the negotiated rates are almost 4X what they charge an uninsured patient.

According to our insurance company, not only is this legal, but this is common. They said there was no limit to what they could "negotiate" as a rate. It seems like something the medical provider is doing to avoid billing insurance.

Even if this is legal, this seems like a scam. They didn't warn us in advance when she gave her insurance information and when we asked what the cost will be in advance, they told us that they couldn't determine it until the service is delivered since the insurance company negotiates the rate. (Which we assumed would be a discount off the posted prices)

So my question is this actually legal? and if it is, why are the insurance companies agreeing to these large negotiated rates?

Are the insurance companies actually paying those rates once you hit the deductible? Or do they actually have a lower "secret" negotiated rate that they actually pay the providers. (And is that legal)

Keep in mind, all of these providers are "in-network".

If this is indeed legal and common, it seems like the whole advantage to choosing a High Deductible health plan was just eliminated.

What is the best type of plan to avoid this headache? An HMO?

Posted Jul 17, 2015, 11:23 PM UTC

11
Civisisus•

Yes, it's legal. It's not at all 'consumer-friendly', especially in the context of high deductible health plans, but it is legal.

The rates insurers negotiate with network providers can exceed what those MDs charge other patients - whether they're uninsured, or whether they are insured with other insurers. It's...odd, but not really a scam, because MDs don't customarily have one 'set' rate.

What IS scammy is, as you've alluded to ("they didn't warn us in advance..."), the extent to which insurers hide settled rate information from people who are covered- but that's another story....

Insurers negotiate rates with clinicians and facilities for a variety of reasons, mostly to 'aggregate' access for health plan members. As someone covered by your plan, you have access to network docs who are accepting patients, and probably stand in line ahead of off-the-street 'retail payers'. So, while your MD might accept a lower payment from an uninsured patient, they might NOT accept the patient in the first place.

While we're talking about odd though, a couple of things in your post seem odd to me:

a) retail clinics post their charges - and that's a big deal in the world of health care. Few, if any, "normal" physician practices post charges of any kind (yet; more will do so, soon) - but you reference your medical group's "uninsured price was listed at $125", and elsewhere, that they "post prices". That doesn' t sound right.

b) $100 would be a very low charge for a routine visit to a primary care doctor. Double that is more like it. Where in the US are you?

1