r/whitesox•
aviddemon

Should we have drafted Schwarber instead of Rodon?

Schwarber is beasting for the Cubs right now. I think Rodon is going to be a really good pitcher, but Schwarber plays a position of need for us right now. He'll probably slow down and he probably wouldn't develop for us or something anyways.

Posted Jul 22, 2015, 3:55 AM UTC

035
JROremussale 49•

Part of this is seeing Rodon struggle, which really is the fault of the White Sox. He should be in AAA right now, not burning MLB time. He has spotty control and only two pitches. Honestly, they should not have called him up this year. He should have spent 2015 developing the changeup in the minors and made the team next season. A lot of his struggles have to do with the fact that when he gets into hitters counts everybody knows a fastball is coming.

8
america_rex•

Rookie starting pitchers constantly have rough first seasons. It not every day someone like Sale begins starting and looks like Cy Young

1
JROremussale 49•

I'm aware of this, but it wasn't helping that he was brought up with only 2 pitches. He could have used time in the minors developing a third pitch.

1
america_rex•

i agree having a good changeup would be huge. I would advise everyone to not be worried about him unless this is continuing next season.

1
JROremussale 49•

I don't think anybody is worried, but just that when you are in AAA and the games don't matter on the MLB level you can spend entire games throwing primarily changeups to help get the feel of it. Obviously he can't do that pitching in the bigs. He'll be fine and I'm sure he'll be working on that all offseason, but to me it would have been very beneficial to spend at least half a year in AAA working mostly on getting a good feel for that change, which will help his K numbers and also decrease his BB numbers.

2
jackarroo1980•

I don't think you can assume that he'd be hitting the same way with us.

Cubs are hitting like crazy this year, White Sox are the opposite of that. I know it's not sabermetrics but I have to believe bringing a rookie up in a good situation vs a bad one helps.

5
JROremussale 49•

I wouldn't say they are hitting like crazy. 23rd in runs, 27th in hits, 26th in average, 27th in total bases. Not saying the Cubs suck, but it isn't like their hitting is lighting the world on fire.

6
HelloNeumann29•

You're totally right, Cubs are not hitting like crazy... In fact, we're hitting pretty terribly. Rizzo is the only true consistant one, Bryant has been good but I wouldn't say great. Behind them, its not good. Schwarber is a beast, but its still a small sample size. Rodon looks to be a future #2. Call it a wash? The Sox just happen to need the hitting more than the pitching, at this point. It sounds like the pitching staff likes Flowers, but I don't know much about his defense... obviously the offense is bad and has been bad for the Sox behind the plate for a while, so this is a very interesting question.

5
JROremussale 49•

I think a lot of answering the question of "Should they have taken Schwarber" depends on if he sticks defensively as a catcher. He'll always have hitting value, but his "position of need" value really takes a hit if he becomes a DH or 1B.

A lot of it also depends on Rodon. If he develops a changeup and cleans up his control he could be a #2 or even a #1 caliber pitcher. If that happens and he's dominating guys alongside Sale than it will look like the Sox made a good call. If he ends up as a #3 or #4 it will look like the Sox made a bad call.

It's way too early to tell what will end up happening, so I agree with you that it is really a wash right now. I don't think the "should we have drafted 'X' player" can be answered immediately, especially with pitchers. Personally I don't think either choice would have been a wrong choice, but when you get the best pitcher in the draft at #3 I don't think it is a bad call to choose him.

1
HelloNeumann29•

I... completely agree....with a sox fan.... at least you're not a Cardinals fan!

1
Mrslinger85sale 49•

I like Rodon. I think he should still be playing AAA ball right now. He's shown that if he can keep the walk rate down, and pitch more consistently, that he has what it takes. I'm not going to worry about him this season yet.

5
The1andonlyZackbighurt 35•

Sample size is VERY small right now...let's calm down on second-guessing draft picks this soon.

3
MustacheMarkbighurt 35•

Flash in the pan. Look where Bryant is. "Future hall of famer" the day he came up. Now? Not so much. Give it time. No worries.

3
miket23•

Kris Bryant is having a spectacular year? He would have the highest on base % on the Sox by almost 40 points. Struggling lately, true, but dude is still doing great.

5†
MustacheMarkbighurt 35•

Hes doing great, for sure. But the day he came up, even before that he was talked about by everyone as being the next superstar and I don't really see it yet. Maybe eventually.

1
miket23•

I mean he's getting on base at .370 clip as rookie and it was a lot closer to .400 all season before his recent slump . He's on pace to have a 5 point WAR season. That is extremely good

1
TheManInsideMesale 49•

If Theo got drunk and offered Bryant for Abreu straight up, Hahn would take it running away. Bryant is the best hitter on either team by a wide margin.

1
[deleted]•

Rizzo is a better hitter than Bryant in almost every way right now.

1
HelloNeumann29•

He would have the highest on base % on the Sox by almost 40 points.

Stop.

-5
miket23•

Ok, well maybe I should say starters who play regularly? Abreu leads the sox at .335 and Bryant has .369 on base.

1
HelloNeumann29•

Sorry fellow Cubs bro. Your comment made me think you were trolling more than anything.

1
TheManInsideMesale 49•

Kris Bryant is a bonafide superstar right now. Imagine where he'll be in 3 years, barring injury. Dude is as advertised.

1
mattfromchicagoGo Sox!•

When it comes to the MLB Draft, I'm a big proponent of just taking BPA. Baseball prospects are too finicky and the development process is too long to start trying to pick for MLB need. You grab the best player available and fill in the holes as you go.

Rodon was clearly the best prosect available in the 2014 Draft. Realistically, he probably should have gone #1 (I'm sure the Astros would have preferred to take him in hindsight). So, no, I agree with the pick.

2
ggslovin•

Agreed, you go BPA. I also agree it looks like Rodon could have used another season in the minors, but I still like what I have seen so far. He still shows the #1 potential.

1
sycked•

He'd have turned into Ron Karkovice 2.0 with this franchise's track record of developing major league caliber bats.

1
ACSimeon•

No. Rodon is an Ace in the making. Schwarber is going to be decent. If we demoted Rodon, he would just destroy everyone in the minors.

1†
mattfromchicagoGo Sox!•

Why would we DFA Rodon

1
ACSimeon•

People are saying he needs to go back to the minors for more seasoning. I disagree, obviously so do you.

1
mattfromchicagoGo Sox!•

DFA is a specific, contractual transaction. The Sox would not need to DFA Rodon to move him back to AAA, they just need to use one of his options.

5
ACSimeon•

Corrected for accuracy. Thank you.

3
waff1ez•

I'll take pitching over hitting anyday. Everyone needs starting pitching, most teams can get by with whoever they have playing left field/catcher/first base/ whatever Schwarber is playing.

1
TripleCrown90•

Schwarber is going to be a good player but I still am not convinced he is going to be catcher at the MLB level. I think he will be playing at a different position.

1
TheManInsideMesale 49•

Yes...

We also should have tried to trade Shark for Schwarber a month ago, before he hit the majors. Decision making is not this teams strong suit. Neither is baseball I supposed.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1