r/ffxiv•
jmac01

Your opinion: Ninja or Dragoon?

[Question]

Greetings my friends, I am just coming off getting my BLM to 60, and was thinking about making a melee DPS. So, based on rotation (I play BLM, I'm not afraid of rotations), feel, and aesthetic, what would you guys prefer?

I collected a crap ton of Ninja gear while leveling, but the Dragoon feels real RP this xpac (plus they look pro af).

Opinions?

Posted Jul 28, 2015, 7:23 PM UTC

053
Goovodka[First] [Last] on [Server]•

Monk

10
MoogVoyagerBlue Venus on Leviathan•

I've maimed DRG since 2.4 and I haven't seen much love for Monks in the last few patches. Can someone tell me how their dps compares to DRG in say a raid setting? I have been pushing around 1200 on Faust. What are monks averaging for the most part?

1
bigblackcouch•

Main monk, 1180 was my last parse on Faust, so yap. We're fine. AND FUCKING FUN.

4
MoogVoyagerBlue Venus on Leviathan•

Yeah, I love Monk. If I wasn't so invested in DRG I'd be all over that shit. Good to hear they are pushing similar numbers :)

1
Goovodka[First] [Last] on [Server]•

It varies greatly between fights, faust is difficult to gauge dps with because of inflated numbers. I did 1.5k dps on faust just last night but obviously it's because my aoe hit some adds

2
kyrios91Dux Dragunity on Midgardsormr•

Monks are doing well. Though most fights in Heavensward has a shit-ton of downtimes RIP GL3 no wonder they have skills to spend those GLs before it drops lol.

1
AConcernedEorzean•

The obvious answer is Monk.

-1
legenwait•

Go Ninja, theres too many DRG right now

5
kcgreg77[First] [Last] on [Server]•

You'll want to level Lancer/Dragoon to lvl22 for "Invigorate" and lvl34 for "Blood For Blood" cross class skills useful on Rogue/Ninja. Good starting place! By then you'll know if you want to stick with Lancer/Dragoon or give Rogue/Ninja a try

I'm biased with DRG. One thing I really like about DRG is that I have no pre-pull bullshit to deal with, you just GO! With NIN's you gotta check your stance, precast Huiton and beg your tank to wait 10sec before pulling, change your rotation if there's a WAR in the party....nah :/

3
jmac01OP•

Yeah that's a good point.

1
Taranok•

Do note that the DRG rotation is kind of pants until level 50, when they get chaos thrust. The Ninja rotation is also relatively wrong until 46, where you get 3-length Mudras and Shadowfang. After level 46, your rotation really doesn't change much, you just get your Huton Extender that you swap out AE/DE with, and everything else is oGCD stuff or support stuff being tacked on.

I personally prefer Ninja over Dragoon because its rotation tends to be a bit more forgiving and is easier to recover from mistakes, but DRG is as far as I am aware the best melee DPS in the game, but it heavily depends on what style you want, what speed, and in the case of Ninja, how good your connection is without or with WTFast.

You'll know if Ninja are right for you due to bad connection issues, and 45 is when you're guaranteed to know if it will or will not be a problem. Aside from that, they're both fun for different reasons.

However, none of the DPS classes have a limit break as awesome as the Ninja's. Summoning a bunch of ghost swords while you're in a sphere weaving a ton of mudras one after another is pretty sublime in its elegance and power.

2
XakthulSyris D'katti (MOB) - Famfrit•

Wow, you actually do all that? I just cast Huiton right after the tank pulls.

Plus, I like my Mug-healing, so I never change outta Viper.

1
kcgreg77[First] [Last] on [Server]•

I've only gotten NIN to lvl44, I'm just recounting what I've seen in raid groups. And I don't know if it's been fixed in 3.0, but I remember my stance always dropping due to lvl synch and job changes, then forgetting to put it back up. I'm sure veteran NIN's are better at it. Point being...as DRG I don't have to check or precast anything.

2
Taranok•

Yeah. Monk and Ninja are pretty hosed as far as DPS in that they both have ideal pull times for a precast (the stance is whatever). I really wish the devs would fix that or, at the very least, give both classes a useable out-of-combat only button that instantly makes them ready for the fight. Would simplify matters a lot.

1
unbeaupetrin•

NIN main here, in Savage I have the pull countdown macro so I can lead with Suiton. Tank is displeased but I hit ~1180ish dps so can't be too mad :^)

1
XakthulSyris D'katti (MOB) - Famfrit•

Well, yeah. That first attack would be insane if you're using Sneak Attack.

Cool that there's actually a countdown macro, too.

1
unbeaupetrin•

Posted in another comment but this is my opener:

Jin > Chi > Ten > Ninjutsu > <wait.20> > Ten > Chi > Jin > Ninjutsu > Spinning Edge > Kassatsu > Gust Slash > Blood for Blood > Internal Release > Dancing Edge > Draconian Pot of Dexterity > Spinning Edge > Trick Attack > Shadow Fang > Ten > Chi > Ninjutsu > Mutilate > Dream Within a Dream > Mug > Spinning Edge > Jugulate > Gust Slash > Duality > Aeolian Edge

As for the macro it's just basically saying hey I'm counting down!, casts Huton(Jin Chi Ten Ninjutsu) and then calls out 20 15 10 and then 54321.

1
lukedogg[First] [Last] on [Server]•

Yep. I cast huton let my group know at ten seconds. Monk then starts chakras and scholar aldos.

1
tunoddenrubMeli Bajaa, Elandra Mistyvale, Setsuko Kaminagi on Excalibur•

I would actually say 34 is not soon enough to tell for sure if you'll like DRG. The rotation changes a fair bit by 50, and then again by 60. If you like DRG at 34, DRG50 might not be to your tastes, and if you find DRG boring at 34, DRG50 might actually remedy your problem.

1
conativejj[Cassius] [Longinus] on [Behemoth]•

Ninja

3
kazemakaseDiabolos•

Do you like Naruto or Skyrim better?

3
Evrae_Altana•

Skyrim has no polearms =[

2
kazemakaseDiabolos•

Just burly nord arms.

2
jmac01OP•

I literally thought the same thing lol. I do like me some Naruto I guess ...

1
kyrios91Dux Dragunity on Midgardsormr•

Do you like Naruto or DARK SOULS better?

Fixed

1
YuureiShinji•

Right, DRGs die almost as much as people in Souls. :v

1
tasjahTasjah Arkwright on Brynhildr•

DRG; not biased

2
kyrios91Dux Dragunity on Midgardsormr•

Keepo

1
Syntaire[First] [Last] on [Server]•

Dragoon. If they ever address the mudra lag, then give Ninja a shot. They're really fun, but also really frustrating.

2
jmac01OP•

Thanks for the prompt responses my dudes, I'm gonna start out with a goon to get bfb and whatnot and then roll a ninja to see what's up.

2
chili01Berserker Krusty on Leviathan•

Dragoon for the Eso Armor.

2
ChaosKe[Baal] [Mirtaq] on [Shiva]•

Got DRG and NIN at 60 and they are both very fun and satisfying to play. Both feel a bit boring when starting out but get a lot better at later levels. NIN starts to get fun when you unlock your ninjutsu especially huton and DRG changes quite drastically between lvl 50-60 so dont judge either of them too early.

DRGs dps potential is a bit higher but NINs training dummie dps translates a bit better into real fights, so they even out a bit in most fights.

Gameplaywise both have a lot of off GCDs to keep you busy. NIN has his mudras and higher speed through huton while DRG has a bit more positioning and its Botd needs balancing between accumulating and depleting time.

2
Soroth23•

I started in 2.0 as a Dragoon, and its been my go to DPS ever since. I love the feel, the history, the moves, the visuals, just everything about them.

If youre looking for an engaging rotation, a Dragoons opener (MAD BURST DEEPS BRUH) is about 20+ buttons long.

Cant say jack about Ninja, ive never played it past level 15.

1
unbeaupetrin•

Jin > Chi > Ten > Ninjutsu > <wait.20> > Ten > Chi > Jin > Ninjutsu > Spinning Edge > Kassatsu > Gust Slash > Blood for Blood > Internal Release > Dancing Edge > Draconian Pot of Dexterity > Spinning Edge > Trick Attack > Shadow Fang > Ten > Chi > Ninjutsu > Mutilate > Dream Within a Dream > Mug > Spinning Edge > Jugulate > Gust Slash > Duality > Aeolian Edge

NIN opener is so many buttons I miss MNK ;_______;

1
Soroth23•

holy crap. Even if you count all the signs and the ninjutsus as one, pretty sure that still beats out Dragoon by just a little bit.

1
CaptainShadowcatCaptain Kage on Brynhildr•

I think Ninja has always had the most ridiculous opener of any job. the posted rotation also ignores shadewalker and smoke screen.

1
kyrios91Dux Dragunity on Midgardsormr•

a Dragoons opener (MAD BURST DEEPS BRUH)

Dem 5k crit Jumps / Full Thrusts are too sexy to not notice

1
bonafideone•

TBH they're both good, but i think DRG pulls out more dmg. Play what you like man.

1
KhadrothKara Ragna on Brynhildr•

Dragoon will feel a bit like your BLM at later levels with how similar Blood of the Dragon and Enochian are.

1
nomiras•

DRG, easily. They get the sweetest armor, they are currently top tier in melee DPS (not that it matters for people that are not going for world firsts). DRG's rotation flows super easy. It feels natural.

Once you get mudra with NIN, it just starts feeling super clunky IMO. If you have any lag whatsoever, your Mudra will be screwed and you will lose damage. I don't even normally have lag, however, when it comes to Mudra, I can watch a friend almost instantly cast a level 3 mudra, however, when I cast it, it seems to take much longer. If this was gone, I'd go with whichever class, however, Mudra lag makes me not want to play NIN at all.

1
Admiral_Burrito[Balmung]•

Level DRG at least until you get that vital Blood for Blood cross skill. If you don't like the gameplay, at least you got the cross skill that many other jobs use.

1
Artanyas[First] [Last] on [Server]•

They're both very solid melee DPS. I suggest you try the two of them for a few levels and just go with whichever you like best.

I personally prefer DRG, though.

1
therandinator211•

Personally, I've never liked DRG.

My main DPS jobs were BRD primary and BLM as my "have fun blowing shit up" job. I picked up NIN when it came out and after the usual grind to to 30, loved NIN when I got it and since then I've mained NIN (and BRD) all through FCoB. Now in Heavensward I'm a full time NIN pretty much and like it even more despite the minor changes we got. There are ways to get around the mudra lag issue by substituting one mudra for another that outputs almost the same damage. That all depends on your latency though. Now as far as DRG goes, I have never once been able to like it, i leveled it to to get Blood for Blood and hated every step of the way. But that's just me. I'm in no way saying the job is bad, sucks, or anything negative about it. One of my best friends and Savage static member plays DRG and he's a beast at it, easily one of the best I know.

At the end of the day, only way you'll really know which one you like better is to level both of them a little and see which one starts grabbing your attention more. Sadly, NIN won't shine though till you start getting mudras. As a Rogue it's pretty dull honestly.

1
XakthulSyris D'katti (MOB) - Famfrit•

They play and damage similarly, but I think DRG has more powerful AOEs and AOE combos, while NIN just has straight-up damage and a bit higher attack speed going for them.

I've played both to 50, and I have nothing really bad to say about either.

1
YuureiShinji•

NIN's massive selling point is their extremely versatile offensive raid utility, to be honest.

2
XakthulSyris D'katti (MOB) - Famfrit•

Yeah. Fun for leveling first, too, though.

1
hhreilly•

I have NIN at 50 and DRG at 56 and I prefer the DRG right now.

1
Darkseth88•

Doesn't matter if there's too many drg. There's too many bad players in every job. Bring all 3 melees to 50 and make your decision. Play what's more fun, not what's more fun to 40 other random people. Or... At least play the job you're good at.

1