Achievements causing gamethrowing

Mayor:Be acquitted without revealing to the Town.

Veteran:Win without going on alert all game.

Janitor:Win the game without cleaning any bodies.

Yeah I think we all know how counterintuitive some of the achievements can be, rewarding you for making bad plays, sometimes plays that go against your role's objective. However, even though there are achievements that should be changed, we should at least come up with ones to replace them. The ones I see as needing to be changed are ones that rely on any of the following:

A:Making bad plays (Such as, Be killed by the SerialKiller you jailed.)

B:A Witch or Transporter affecting your target that night (Role block yourself/the Godfather.)

So here's a few of my own suggestions

Mayor:Have 2 or more of your attackers die to bodyguards in a single night.

Jailor:Protect the Mayor from an attack.

Janitor:Clean an Investigator who found the Godfather.

Consort:Stop the Jailor from executing a Mafia buddy.

Survivor:Win the game after being doused by an Arsonist.

All of those suggestions are for replacing existing achievements, but here's a few other suggestions for adding new achievements to some roles that may need them.

Transporter:Transport the Mayor with an alerting Veteran.| Stop a Vigilante from shooting a Town member. (Could also be a Doctor achievement)

Bodyguard:Protect 2 or more people in one game.

Godfather:Prevent the Mafioso from visiting an alerting Veteran.

Witch:Force the Jailor to execute the mayor.| Control a Doctor to protect you from 2 or more attacks.

If anyone else has any suggestions to replace existing achievements or just wants to talk about the ones they thought up feel free to post them here.

Posted Jul 31, 2015, 11:43 PM UTC · edited

99
Loading comments…