I've been playing on Just the Story for so long.

So when the update came around, I must have missed that it reverted the settings down to their defaults. This also includes the difficulty setting, for those that are not aware.

I thought I was doing so well on Blood and Broken Bones for the past 100 hours of gameplay, when it turns out I'm just stupid and never bothered to check the difficulty. I guess it's a good thing I'll be doing a second play through to get all the achievements. Hopefully by then all the bugs will be sorted out.