r/Minecraft•
CakeX

[::] The confusing and painful behavior of the new end gateway block

CommandBlock

After seeing a recent post talking about how the end gateways can be customized with commands, I decided to try it out. However, after doing so, I discovered it has some extremely confusing behavior that I think I have figured out. This is likely an artifact of the original purpose of the gateway in the end.

First off, without considering the other factors I will mention, the coordinates set in the gateway's NBT data are different than the coordinates it teleports you to; the teleport-result coordinates are 5 blocks north and 5 west from the NBT ones.

This is where it gets confusing. As far as I can tell through my testing, if, in a 10 by 10 block range south-western from the teleport-result coordinates, there is a block higher than the highest block in the teleport-result coordinates, it will instead teleport you to that higher block.

If there are multiple blocks that 'tie' for the highest position, the game will try to teleport to the nearest one, prioritizing first south, east, and then south-east.

As a result, the gateway is probably much more difficult to use than you'd think.

Again, I think this is because in the end, with the original gateways, the game is trying to give the player the safest teleport location, which results in this weird behavior.

All of was tested in the latest snapshot, the 'c' subversion.

If you find something that seems to not suggest what I've written, please share.

Edit: it seems that the 10 by 10 block region may not always be south-western, it may be towards/away from (0,0) the coordinates. testing needed.

Edit 2: I think the 10 by 10 region extends the direction away from (0,0)

Posted Aug 1, 2015, 4:13 AM UTC · edited

74
aary33•

I was testing with this block and its teleportation, and indeed are the coordinates offset of what is actually written in NBT. It's very unfortunate, as I can see if this stays it won't really make a reliable method of teleportation. It's a bit disappointing how confusing it can be, we can only hope there's a way to differentiate naturally generated blocks VS exact coordinates. Teleporting without redstone clocks or pressure plates seemed too good to be true!

3
CakeXOP•

Yeah... for now they still can be used, the destination just needs to be built fairly particularly. Also, it's possible that its behavior will change as the snapshots go on. Hopefully they will.

2
walkersgaming•

Meri explains it here.

I hope they add an "exact" tag for minigame use

3
Plagiatus•

It is actually a 5 block offset in every direction around the target block and therefor a 11x11 Square ;)

It will start placing you on the highest block in this area. If there are multiple ones, you'll get set to the most negative one (with x being more important than z I believe).

And you will actually never be set to the target block, EXCEPT it being the only block left to spawn on.

You will be teleported exactly 1.5 blocks above the block.

2