Vigilante king and his Uber-style law enforcement app
news.com.au/finance/economy/vigilante-king-an...Posted Aug 2, 2015, 12:20 AM UTC
177
Posted Aug 2, 2015, 12:20 AM UTC
He must have really liked that place. Seems like anyone else with that much money would just moved somewhere else.
"But other locals are concerned about the privatisation of policing, and fear that putting so much power in the hands of a man once known as “Trashanova” could stoke tensions."
Amazes me that even when people are providing solutions there are people who will still defend the government funded alternatives that caused the problem in the first place.
Particularly like this part
"The mayor has hailed the project as part of a wider success story in privatising areas including sewage and recreation programs — saying that the rest of the nation needs to follow suit."
This guy did it. Truly outstanding, Sydney Torres managed to police his neighborhood better than any government police. He did it with the right attitude and approach not to provoke local government and police. It grew up so fast and so efficient the government already signed up to capture the service.
This is all Anarcho-capitalists need to do, anywhere, everywhere, we need to open franchises of this guy. Service the population, middle-class and the poor, and show, not tell, that people don't need the State, they need entrepeneurs and private property.
And as its success grows you turn the growth into the demise of the service it made redundant much like Uber is doing with government taxi monopolies.
[deleted]
His "affluent" neighborhood. People who can afford to pay for both private security and taxes and all their other living expenses.
No, this is not "all" we need to do.
It's one thing to protect your neighborhood, it's another thing to actually threaten the monopoly one the initiation of force, particularly beyond a neighborhood. Note that everyone employed is an off duty New Orleans cop, and that they continue to enforce the same laws.
There are already private security companies in this country. People know about them. There is stil a national guard, there is still a police department, there is little to no competition in law enforcement, and there is still a state.
Most people who see this will still have no idea how arbitration works, or how multiple entities could coexist peacefully and provide better service than the government.
How do you think the police unions will respond in towns across the nation if their legitimacy is actually being undermined, and police are at risk of losing their jobs? Are you under the illusion that most departments want competition?
To be clear, what this guy did is great. I just don't see this as being the path to anarcho-capitalism.
[deleted]
Police cost $200/year. http://albany.edu/sourcebook/pdf/t1432003.pdf
On average, and for "all sizes".
A city with over 1 million people, presumably that includes New Orleans, has an average budget of $282 per resident. That is not what people are actually paying to the government in taxes, it is the cut the police take.
Furthermore, I doubt his services are 200 a year.
And, call me ignorant, but won't such an entity inevitably have a higher price when it is still growing? Example: Let's say I have a security force that polices a few high-crime neighborhoods with 500 clients, and you charge 200/year. That's 100k/year. Is that actually going to be enough for a year's salary for half a dozen officers?