[COMC] 3 Years Stong. + Mini Reviews/Rants/General Stream of Conscience!
Hey, thanks for checking out my collection!
I’ve been deep in this hobby for the past three years, though I have always loved playing board games growing up. I decided to write my thoughts on each game in my collection since I always enjoy when other COMC’s share their thoughts. Little did I know that it would take forever to do - I had fun writing this though.
King of Tokyo
An early addition to my collection. I love this game: big chunky dice, easy to understand gameplay, and a fun theme with great artwork. This is usually the first game I play with people who are new to board games. It’s not very long and quickly shows you that board games have changed since you were a kid. I had someone tell me that King of New York was the much better version of this because it added more strategy, but I don’t really see how making this game more complex would make it better. Why fix what’s not broken? Granted, I have yet to play KoNY, so I could potentially eat these words.
I also have the expansion for this game, but rarely play with it. It’s good, but unnecessary in my opinion.
Ticket to Ride
I think I used to like this game, but that time has long passed. The last couple times I played have been dreadful for me. I feel like this should be renamed to “Stress: The Boardgame.” Here are my issues: 1) No one ever talks when playing this game. I have played with a variety of people and the only words ever uttered while staring at this geologically inept map are: “Hey, it’s your turn.” 2) You can just get so fucked in this game. Sometimes the person isn’t even trying to screw you but BAM! 17 point down the drain. I really hate the people who try to screw you while playing. Like somehow ruining my fun is making this a better game for you? I don’t get it. Was that really so strategic for you? Fucking me was your only option because you can’t seem to fulfill your own routes? 3) This game stresses me out. It has an actual adverse reaction to my blood pressure. Whenever I complete a route I feel like I just completed one overdue assignment, and now I have the opportunity to take another one. No thank you. This game will likely get donated the next chance I get.
On a side note: the 10th anniversary edition is freakin’ gorgeous. Too bad I hate you.
Cosmic Encounter
…Or as my group likes to call it “How aliens meet.” One of the first games I bought for my collection. This is a game I enjoy playing, but haven’t taken it off the shelf in a while. Nerd Poker is the best description I’ve heard for this, unfortunately I own a very readable face so I’m not very good at bluffing. I feel like with the right atmosphere this can be the star game of the night, but with certain people it falls really flat. It has a special place in my cardboard crusted heart, so I don’t think I’ll ever get rid of it – I just need to take it out more often.
Suburbia
Suburbia might be my favorite board game in the collection. I absolutely adore the theme (both my wife and I majored in Urban Planning). I think my favorite types of games are where you are building something in front of you. I’ve heard people complain about the “fiddliness” in the last third of the game, but I disagree, keeping up with all the functions of your burrow are what make this game great. It also makes you pay more attention to what your opponents are doing. I can’t wait for the next expansion to come out soon.
Isle of Trains
I got Isle of Trains in the Dice Hate Me Rabbits Kickstarter, and I think it’s my favorite game out of the 6 (and only 1 of 2 that survived the cut). It is a fun game for two players, but I think the art style is what really sells it. It’s also another game where you are building something in front of you, so yeah, I dig it.
Diner
The second of the Dice Hate Me Rabbits that stayed in my collection. This game creates an odd situation for me. I think the mechanics are fantastic: I love how the game is almost played in real time, but not quite. I also think the double-sided cards are very clever. In fact I love everything about this game on paper, until I start playing it. This game accurately mimics the chaos and stress of working in the food industry. By the end of the game everybody is yelling at each other and stressed out; and I’m about ready to spend all my tip money on whiskey shots at the bar next door. It kinda causes flashbacks of all the years I worked in the food industry. No Thank you. On the other hand I do love all of the mechanics, and if I ever get super frustrated at my current job I can just play this and remember that there are much worse places to work. I SAID ORDER UP!
Diamobds
I bought this because I love trick taking games… well I love A trick taking game (see Dominoes below) and I wanted a more accessible trick-taking game to play with my friends. Unfortunately I have only played this a handful of times, so I’m not really sure where I stand on it yet. It seems alright.
Patchwork
The first weekend I got this game it was played 8 times. Yeah, I really like this game. It hits almost everything I like in board games: it’s tactile, clever, and accessible. The first time I played I just liked the “tetris” aspect of the game, but then I started understanding the button economy. I’m afraid that I’m going to play this game too much and it will get stale, but currently it is in my top five.
Forbidden Desert
I’m a huge fan of “Desert Mythology.” Dune is one of my favorite books, and deserts were always my favorite biome to explore in video games. Because of this Forbidden Desert was very high on my To-Buy list. Maybe I put a little too much agency in theme. I don’t dislike this game, but I can only stand to play it maybe once a month. For some reason I get very stressed when I play this game. This could be because my group has only beaten the game once in the 15+ times we’ve played it. Damn sun keeps killing everybody.
Terra Mystica
I don’t really have much to say about Terra Mystica. I really like how all of the different systems work together, and how there are so many different races you can play as. I have fun playing it, I think. But boy is it a bitch to teach. I’m glad I bought it, but I don’t think I would miss it too much if something else took its place.
Roll for the Galaxy
This is one of the newer additions to my collection. The first couple times I played this game I wasn’t really sure what to think – the game ended before I really had an idea of what I was doing. 10+ plays later I still feel that I am playing this game inefficiently (I lose 80% of the time), but I’m still really enjoying it and I want to do better. So I guess that means it’s a good game in my book.
It also really annoys me when I hear people complain that this game is too “luck-based.” Have you played the game? There are sooo many ways to mitigate the randomness that is caused by the dice. I think some people just want to have each gaming experience be a completely fair randomness free playing field – ‘cause that’s how life works.
Pandemic: The Cure
This might be the first co-op game that I have really enjoyed. Co-op games usually frustrate me because I feel like I’m just doing a group puzzle, and when the group loses I’m just frustrated at the puzzle. For some reason adding dice alleviated that issue for me. I think it’s because the puzzle is a little more unpredictable, or maybe I just really love chucking dice. Either way I feel like the wins are more nail-biting, and the losses can be hilarious: like when the Generalist somehow rolls 5 hazards in one go and the game that was a sure win turns into an insta-loss.
Imperial Assault
I fell for the hype of this game. I watched all of the ecstatic reviews, saw that awesome AT-ST, and thought to myself: hey you liked star wars when you were a kid, you don’t have any miniatures adventuring games, why not this? So I bit. Here’s my main issue with this game: I play tabletop rpg’s with some of the same people I play boardgames with. I feel like this game is just a tabletop rpg with its training wheels still attached. It’s neat and very pretty, but for someone who plays D&D semi-regularly it just doesn’t quite do it. It has a lot of the same elements, but it feels like a role playing game without the role playing. Every time I busted this game out I felt like I’d rather be throwing some d20’s. Also, it takes forever to find the correct tiles to build the map. Sorry Imperial Assault – I think your time sitting on this shelf is at an end. It’s not you, it’s me.
Settlers of Catan
My then-girlfriend-now-wife bought me this game back in 2012 as a college graduation gift. We had played it a couple times before, so we already knew what we were getting into. The weekend she got me this we both became ill and ended up playing the game some 10+ times using the 2-player variant (which I still think is fantastic). The game was just so pretty, I loved seeing all of my settlements and roads stretch out across the island. I was addicted. I had played board games before (owned a couple munchkin & risk variants before this), but this was definitely the catalyst that started me on this hobby. I don’t play this game very often anymore (I think I burnt my wife out on it) but I still love this game.
Telestrations
This is the game I feel every household should own. It’s a box of instant laughter. Every time I explain the game and somebody tells me that they don’t want to play because they’re a horrible artist, I assure them that their contribution will only make the game better.
Dixit
I like this game enough. Really fun with the right crowd, horrible with the wrong crowd. I freakin’ love the picture that has the backpack smiling with all the stuff on the floor - I would buy a print of it if it was possible. Fantastic.
Snake Oil
Another party game. I think this is the best version of the Apples to Apples/Cards Against Humanity variety, because this game lets you sell your card choice. Even if you have horrible card choices a little bit of creativity will go a long way. Ton’s of fun. It’s great seeing someone who’s mostly quite kill a sales pitch. Perfect beer and pretzels game.
Monikers
So I realize that I basically spent money on a game that can be played with scraps of paper, but I’m glad I have this. Another party game that always has tons of laughs. My favorite exchange playing was:
Me: “umm… I’m blind and deaf”
A Friend: “Anne Frank!”
Me: “You got it!”
Everyone else: “What?! No, that’s not right”
Me: “No, he’s right” shows card.
Not until after the game did I realize that I had switched Anne Frank and Helen Keller in my head, and somehow my friend was on the same level. Thanks Clerks II.
Citadels
This game is okay. I feel like it would have been a fantastic game if I got it when it first came out. I think coup does better role selection, and the city building isn’t very exciting. I do really like the plastic gold bits though.
Coup + Reformation
I’m a super fan of this game. It’s super quick and most everybody enjoys it after their second game. It’s a perfect end to a game night.
Hanabi
Pretty fun with the right crowed. I feel like there is a lesson here somewhere… something about communication… or team building. Yeah, this game is pretty much a team building exercise.
Rhino Hero
Love this game! Everybody I have played this with loves this game! Do you love this game?
One Night Ultimate Werewolf + Daybreak
When I first got this game I think it was the only game my group played for a month. Tons and tons of fun. It’s interesting how a meta game will start to form around the people you play this a lot with. My only real issue with this game is if one person isn’t “in” to it, the whole game can suffer.
Bang! The Dice Game
Bought this when my weekly game night grew suddenly in people. Its pretty fun: real easy to teach with some interesting social deduction. Haven’t played it in a while - less people show up to game nights when the weather is nice….and I stop holding games nights. Anybody else notice that more people want to play games when it’s cold outside?
Standard Deck of Cards
I have a plethora of card decks, but this one is on my shelf for easy access. It get played often enough, but the only games my group plays is Egyptian Rat Screw and Scat. I feel like both of these games are fun in the right situation.
Dominoes
So really my favorite game isn’t a board game but a dominoes game: 42. As far as I know 42 is the only game dominoes should ever be used for (maybe moon if you only have three people and you’re waiting on a fourth, or stacking into small domino structures). I’m pretty sure when I was in college I played 5 hours of 42 a day. For those who don’t know, 42 is a four player trick taking game you play with partners. It’s kinda like Spades but a lot better ‘cause the elements will never ruin a game of 42. It’s best played outside with a steady supply of beer. Unfortunately post college I moved to a location where people don’t play this game, so I have to make pilgrimages south periodically to get my fix.
Oh no, I wrote too damn much. I'll have to continue this below.
Posted Aug 13, 2015, 11:50 AM UTC