Satoshi - "We can phase in a change later if we get closer to needing it"
bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1347.0Posted Aug 17, 2015, 10:34 AM UTC
Posted Aug 17, 2015, 10:34 AM UTC
"It can be phased in, like:
if (blocknumber > 115000) maxblocksize = largerlimit
It can start being in versions way ahead, so by the time it reaches that block number and goes into effect, the older versions that don't have it are already obsolete.
When we're near the cutoff block number, I can put an alert to old versions to make sure they know they have to upgrade."
Satoshi
Let's not forget this key point:
I don't think another GUI that could pop up should be treated as some kind of "second-class" client - luke-jr
Not exactly in context, but I like Gavin's reply to him:
Perfect is the enemy of better
...and:
Now is a good time to change
[deleted]
I dont see anywhere where he suggests doubling every 2 years. Can you point me to that ?
When Satoshi introduced the backward-incompatible checksum change, he set it to activate after two years. That seems like a reasonable amount of time. -- Theymos
This one is fun. On one hand he is now saying we can wait. And here you see him say you need to plan TWO YEARS ahead.
Those two statements are not contradictory.
need to plan TWO YEARS ahead.
It's two years to achieve consensus...
Two years from rolling out code until code activates.
That means if the same logic were applied here we could have a change take place no sooner than August 2017, provided a solution was designed, built, tested, and rolled out today.
No no no, that's the old way. Where we set a specific block height and say something like "blockheight > 220,000"
The 'new' way is like BIP 66
But if we're having a discussion about block size then I doubt you are interested in any of the computer science behind Bitcoin
No no no, that's the old way.
I said, "if the same logic were applied." You probably just didn't read my post very carefully.
But if we're having a discussion about block size then I doubt you are interested in any of the computer science behind Bitcoin
I have an MS in the field and thirty years experience as a coder and architect in dozens of different languages and technologies so I think I'm good, thanks.
GOOD FIND.
It's literally is view on this change.
That was his view five years ago.
So was the whitepaper. And if you are implying that anything he said does not mean it is set in stone - why not change the block limit?
So you're sayng: If what he said is set in stone, then increase block size limit. If not, then increase block size limit.
It's fine that your mind is made up. Personally I don't think reading old Satoshi quotes is any replacement for proper analysis.
My mind is not made up. I'm not running XT because the consensus is not there. And XT is more than just changing the MAX_BLOCK_SIZE.
He supported a one off change apparently, not doubling every 2 years. So presumably he would advise against running XT.
That is not what I get out of it, it sounds to me like his change would up the size whenever it got too big
"It can be phased in, like:
if (blocknumber > 115000) maxblocksize = largerlimit
It can start being in versions way ahead, so by the time it reaches that block number and goes into effect, the older versions that don't have it are already obsolete.
When we're near the cutoff block number, I can put an alert to old versions to make sure they know they have to upgrade."
Satoshi
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1347.msg15366#msg15366
That is a one-off change, and it explains what he meant by "phased in". Curious how people here are trying to interprite "phased in" to mean a continually increasing limit. Almost as if they had some agenda to push.
static const unsigned int MAX_BLOCK_SIZE = TX_PER_MINUTE * TX_AVG_SIZE_GUESS * 10 * 2;
So also Garzik fall in this error a long time ago, and still more reasonable that 8MB in 2016 and then x2 every 2 years, ridiculous.
Satoshi is right. It is time to change now. We get too closer to needing it. If we wait more, our future will be a big mess.
The autonomous being we call Bitcoin should be self-adjusting when this ordeal is behind us, analog to the difficulty adjustments.
It is not autonomous. Human beings control it. Human beings who might be persuaded to game the system.
So Satoshi refused the change and preferred to kick the can down the road, and felt that when he needed it would be done.
Here is where I feel Gavin has mad a major mistake as the "Chief Scientist" he should of played an apolitical role and shelved his personal view of bitcoin in an effort to work on consensus. If consensus ends up being 2MB that that is what it is. Instead Gavin has decided to go for the big move because he feels that its only interesting if Bitcoin is a global payment network. Something that even raising the block limit to 10 MB will not make it.
Even Satoshi played it very conservative at a time where lifting the block limit could have been done with no issue at all. Kudos to Jeff who is always trying to fix things
Instead Gavin has decided to go for the big move because he feels that its only interesting if Bitcoin is a global payment network.
That is what it was created for..
"Abstract. A purely peer-to-peer version of electronic cash would allow online payments to be sent directly from one party to another without going through a financial institution. Digital signatures provide part of the solution, but the main benefits are lost if a trusted third party is still required to prevent double-spending. We propose a solution to the double-spending problem using a peer-to-peer network. The network timestamps transactions by hashing them into an ongoing chain of hash-based proof-of-work, forming a record that cannot be changed without redoing the proof-of-work. The longest chain not only serves as proof of the sequence of events witnessed, but proof that it came from the largest pool of CPU power. As long as a majority of CPU power is controlled by nodes that are not cooperating to attack the network, they'll generate the longest chain and outpace attackers. The network itself requires minimal structure. Messages are broadcast on a best effort basis, and nodes can leave and rejoin the network at will, accepting the longest proof-of-work chain as proof of what happened while they were gone"
Yes I understand that, I can't imagine anyone who supports bitcoin that doesn't want Bitcoin to be globally accepted, thats the end game. But if you can't get consensus to make that change because of technical reasons you work with what you got.
Satoshi himself didn't say even when presented with the limitations of a 1MB block. Hey your right we need to compete with VISA lets raise the block limit to 10MB and the make sure its goes every year.
This debate has been going on over 3 years, it is time to do something or else we will be looking for fire extinguisher while the house is already on fire
I feel that Gavin was between a rock and a hard place. If bitcoin is to succeed as a global currency, the block size needs to increase so that it can actually service the globe.
If the block size is kept below 1MB there won't even be potential for mass adoption, since the [admittedly small] Bitcoin community has proven itself able to fill up blocks, whether it's by gambling transactions, "stress tests", darknet transactions, or heck, even hypothetical real world transactions.
Bitcoin was seen as a potential global currency in 2013 but has since flatlined. More development needed to happen, Bitcoin wasn't perfect as-is then, and it isn't now.
So Gavin proposed raising the block limit to increase adoption and the actual value provided by Bitcoin (if all the blocks are always full you'll never be able to submit a transaction, making Bitcoin useless to you), however an amalgamation of interests are working against him.
Yeah there's the devs that are working on blockstream et al standing to make a profit off of small blocks, but there's also the simple technical limitations - large blocks create a need for more storage and processing power, further centralizing the already-centralized "p2p" currency.
So you either increase the block size and make "bitcoin" accessible to more people, or you keep the block size as is and make bitcoin (read: original Bitcoin) accessible to "people" (the pre-existing Bitcoin community).
Either way, it will change what "bitcoin" is, considering "bitcoin" is defined as the divine word of Satoshi, and any change to his codebase is simply heresy.
You can have global or decentralized, but you can't have both. Globalization requires efficiency, which is the exact opposite of what a decentralized network aims to create (redundancy > efficiency).
I used to be a "make blocks bigger to help the network grow" person, but after seeing the technical limitations, financial incentives in the discussion, and blatant inefficiency of the Bitcoin system either way, I've realized either route will still produce comedy gold, and that's all that really matters.
Without trying to start another blocksize debate.
If the block size is kept below 1MB
I think there is almost no one maybe 1 dev that I can think of that would categorically oppose a block increase of any kind.
Either way, it will change what "bitcoin" is, considering "bitcoin" is defined as the divine word of Satoshi, and any change to his codebase is simply heresy.
Codebase has changed a lot since Satoshi left, so again no serious dev believes in any divinity and no code is divine, maybe the hard cap. Everything else has been discussed.
I've realized either route will still produce comedy gold, and that's all that really matters.
Sometimes there are more honest discussions in Subs that shall not be named and sometimes they are funny
I find this part amusing.
[deleted]
they can't
Anyone, not just a handful of people, can change the way it works/operates/functions, as long as they can convince the rest of the network to run their software.
[deleted]
you could do it too - just try.
To roll out a change to the network you need to get most of the clients understanding both the old and the new protocol, and then when you have a majority you turn on the new protocol. (jgarzik)
[deleted]
That's... not true at all. The only people that can change it are the miners and network nodes. All the devs can do is develop software. If nobody uses the software, nothing changes.
[deleted]
[deleted]
IV. Satoshi himself envisioned much larger blocks.
This is called "arguing to authority", and it tries to give pecuniary value to that only truly worthless article of all times and places : the esteem of the mob.
When I was interested in Bitcoin, I subscribed to the idea to a network able, in the future to manage a large number of transactions (large like in VISA large). No one told me, or wrote or argued, we should stay to 1 MB so 2nf layers would be developed. Do you want develope a second layer? Do it. But do not stop the rest of the network from progressing and become better.
"Phasing in" does not necessarily equal "doubling every two years".
The change could just be to remove the limit. Not change it.
"It can be phased in, like:
if (blocknumber > 115000) maxblocksize = largerlimit
It can start being in versions way ahead, so by the time it reaches that block number and goes into effect, the older versions that don't have it are already obsolete.
When we're near the cutoff block number, I can put an alert to old versions to make sure they know they have to upgrade."
Satoshi
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1347.msg15366#msg15366
Presumably largerlimit is < infinity.
By that same logic, it "doesn't necessarily equal anything" specific.
Exactly, It is a very vague phrase which could mean pretty much anything.
Yes, no one think's it can't be changed. The thing being debated is whether it should be.
Actually the debate is more like when and by how much, not whether it should be.
Just someone think they can stall it forever or until it expedient for them.
No one is debateing if it should but, just how
[deleted]
The stress test and the chart hinting at the end of 2016 to get only and always full blocks.
Also interesting, the responses, also from 2010:
kiba
caveden:
If only we did one of the two suggestions from back then, we wouldn't be in this mess.
Where oh where is Captain Hindsight when you need him?
If anything, this should give u/caveden a ton of credibility as he exactly foresaw this mess.
I can't even imagine what it is going to be like when bitcoin is even bigger than it is now. Its part of the reason I think having a scheduled increase like x2 every 2-4 years with a cap is a good idea. Its not like we can't fork it in the future, if we do it now it will show people that the protocol of an economy (based on a protocol) can be changed successfully, without as much fear.
Yes, this has been the danger.....Bitcoin stagnant already and unable to grow.
People could stop and think and alot of the drama would be avoided. In reality there is no crisis in bitcoin because the block size limit is not in urgent need of being raised. People absolutely hate when you say that. But its the truth none the less.
It is not in an urgent need now, but it might be next year or a little later.
Do we want to act only when it is urgent and do a rush job, or prepare?
[deleted]
By the time it's in urgent need of being raised, the inertia necessary to do so will take too long and users will suffer to the point of abandoning the system. If it's a massive wave of adoption and it gets stopped by the protocol's inefficiencies, Bitcoin will be screwed.
Relevant
I'm honestly starting to wonder if such exodus from Bitcoin wouldn't be a good thing long term after all. Some of the altcoins are already significantly better than Bitcoin feature-wise, particularly the CryptoNote group. They obviously lack the network effects, the ecosystem etc.