r/Naruto•
Sarahmint

Does this bother anyone about Sakura's light novel?

Homura and Koharu keep their power and play a respected role in the book. What kind of Hokage is Kakashi and what kind of human being is Naruto for not doing something about it? They should have been hanged, publicly shamed and humiliated, or worse. At the very least, they should have been permanently banished from Konoha.

Posted Aug 18, 2015, 4:50 AM UTC

033

i mean, they didn't technically do anything wrong.... the only thing i could consider them guilty of is aiding and abetting the uchiha massacre, and i think most of us would cut them some slack given that the uchiha were actually planning a coup.

I mean, they even called out Danzo on his afk during Pain's assault.

Idk dude, they just seem more like those bystanders who really went no harm no foul on the entire village.

6
SarahmintOP•

Homura was pretty adamant for it in Itachi's flashback with screaming "We can't allow it anymore. They call it revolution, but if their plan is to take back political power, we'll have to treat them as traitors". She was all for keeping Uchiha under the foot of the Senju.

0
flingerdinger•

If Naruto and Kakashi can forgive Sasuke for leaving and Oorchimaru for everything that fucker has done they can forgive two old people

5
SarahmintOP•

what if I told you

Sasuke was in the right

because Kakashi could not protect him

and insisted he "give up on revenge" despite everything that happened to Sasuke, including not pursuing the most dangerous Akatsuki member who was a hairline away from snatching and killing Naruto, the Konoha jinchuriki (or so they thought) - meanwhile Shikamaru who has a lot more to loose, gets Kakashi to get his whole team to support him when he really didn't loose that much but was allowed to "let it all out" since he has family to pick up the pieces.

Sasuke's actions did more good then harm when you look at the full picture. Without Sasuke, Danzo would be the 6th Hokage. He runs things for himself under the delusion that it's "for the village and the ninja world" when all he does is use bodies to hide behind. It's the way he lived and died.

-2
flingerdinger•

See with Sasuke I'm not nearly as pissed, still dislike him as a character, but I am not as pissed as I was when I was younger. But explain Oorchimaru.

3
SarahmintOP•

edited my response

0
SarahmintOP•

I loved Sasuke to death until chapter 699. Gaiden 5 made me hate him and what he has become - a failure at everything

After Kakashi's Susano'o, I should have seen this disappointment coming.

Orochimaru was revived for the Hokages to join the (unnecessary) war. After that, nothing was explained. Not his answer to Sasuke's "What is the real reason?" I have no comment on Oro because retcons are coming too fast for even the "real reason" retcon to be explained.

Naruto as a series should have ended with the Pain fight and Naruto becoming the village hero.

-4
Danbito•

I mean, they're not exactly evil. They're more annoying than evil, really. They're just sticklers for traditional values. But very big sticklers.

3
SarahmintOP•

You nailed it.

They still succeeded in genocide against Konoha's own Uchiha population, leading to Itachi aiding Akatsuki, leading to obtaining the Bijuu, leading to a bunch of other things that snowballed into the "4th Great Ninja War" that could have been prevented had they worked with the Uchiha, had Itachi capture Tobi, and protected their own villagers over their own selfish aristocracy.

0
mike1883•

Not like they knew what their actions would lead to. They were looking out for the village. They made a decision based on the information they had. Every village was responsible for the war. The blame can't be given to a few. What if Jiraiya not left to look for Orochimaru or Tsunade become a drunk gambler. Sarutobi chose to punish no one. There is plenty of blame to go around in Konoha as well as the other villages.

4
SarahmintOP•

They were looking out for the village.

By killing the villagers!

Or do they not count? I guess they don't. They never did. Only Uchiha that matter are the servants of the Senju

-1
Jimm607•

The Uchiha were killed when the coup was deemed unavoidable. The uchiha weren't planning on using happiness and friendship to gain the power they wanted.

5
mike1883•

They were traitors to the village no they didn't count. Boohoo they felt disraspected.

1
kidyeezy75•
2
Darkbalmunk•

Who was gonna go after him considering the fights at the end of the remember the number of people and where they were focused.

3
Raidoton•

Punishing Kabuto after he went through Itachis Izanami would be stupid. He is not a threat anymore and in prison he can not atone for his crimes.

2
HokageEzio•

Izanami basically is punishment, it's like an internal correction center.

1
HokageEzio•

Yes, embrace the Curse of Hatred after everything in the war. Absolute genius. The Curse of Hatred has never lead anybody wrong before.

1
SarahmintOP•

Yes. Make the same mistakes done prior to Naruto's beginning. It has never harmed any of the characters before.

1
HokageEzio•

Yep, let's just go kill them for revenge. That plan worked great the first time...

For such a Sasuke fan, you aren't getting how he developed at the end. Sasuke isn't trying to go for revenge anymore, and he's the only person who wanted them dead. Naruto didn't kill the person who killed his master because he listened to what Jiraiya taught him, and that's what the new Ninja World runs on. They don't roll like that, because all it does is end people up dead over and over on both sides. Sasuke was the guy trapped in a cycle of revenge, but he's moved past that.

1
SarahmintOP•

You are not getting it either. Sasuke was not going for revenge by the end. He was going to change the world (in a self-destructive way). So instead of working together with Naruto in the end, he just apologized and took a long walk alone, lolz. If you pay attention to how he shocking jumped into the war and announced he was going to become Hokage, he responded to the outcry "the Hokages are the reason we are in this situation, I'm going to make sure this never happens again".

His plan was self-sacrifice, not revenge. Ironically, his ultimate outcome was self-sacrifice by doing nothing to fix the "antiquated/twisted system".

In a way he abandoned everything to chase after Kaguya or inter-dimensional beings. Forgets about his old and new families in the process because Piccolo-Gohan team is cool

1
HokageEzio•

I know his plan was self sacrifice, that's not what I'm talking about. I'm talking about your original point of killing the two elders. That is solely based on revenge. Notice how they weren't a factor when he started his revolution. He didn't care about them. He's over that, which means there's no point in hanging them in the center of the city or exiling them or anything.

1
SarahmintOP•

The elders have never been wrong before, oh wait. Tsunade had to put them in their place when they wanted Naruro basically hostage! They venemently opposed the Uchiha (and anyone else as far as we know) from having more political power then being anything more then at the mercy of the government. Seriously, don't forget the first half of the story.

You are the kind of reader who interprets everything Naruto says and does as the only absolute good outcome?

1
HokageEzio•

I told you months ago that part where Tsunade choked them out was one of my favorites, I don't like either of them cause they're just bystanders. And I've told you that I didn't think Sasuke's path was entirely wrong or entirely right in the end, so no to your second question. You're forgetting all that stuff I said directly to you. But that doesn't mean I think they should be publicly executed either.

2
erockarmy1•

The only character that was truly evil and got punished for it was Hidan.

1
SarahmintOP•

Danzo and Orochimaru were pretty evil. Even Zabuza was heartless. Kabuto was downright sadistic during the war, laughing at the thought of people being killed by their deceased loved ones.

1