TakeMyUsernameAgainMarxist-Leninist (Maoist)|SDS•

Althusser truly does not get enough credit as the titanic figure that he is

3†
Per_Levya winner is you!•

you mean the guy who murdered his wife and got away with it. who hardly read anything by marx(only his early works, never capital) is a titanic figure? how so?

1
closovsky•

Actually I was just about to read his 'Reading Capital' ...

2
Per_Levya winner is you!•

In one astonishing passage, which is likely to have destroyed his reputation for ever, Althusser reveals how ill-read he really was: the possessor of thousands of books of which he now claims to have opened only a few hundred. His expertise in philosophy, in the history of ideas, was sketchy at best: 'I knew the work of Descartes and Malebranche well, Spinoza a little, Aristotle not at all; Plato and Pascal quite well, Kant not at all, Hegel a little.' He was not even particularly conversant with Marx, having read only his early works when he came to write his own seminal Marxist texts.

Althusser appears to have lived out his whole adult life in the terror that his inadequacy as a thinker, his fraudulence (the word he himself uses), would sooner or later be exposed to his colleagues, his disciples and his enemies. It has happened later rather than sooner and only because, for whatever reason, he chose to bring it on himself.

review of althussers selfwritten biography, worth the read:

http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/getting-away-with-murder-its-the-talk-of-paris--how-louis-althusser-killed-his-wife-how-he-was-an-intellectual-fraud-its-all-in-his-posthumous-autobiographical-memoir-gilbert-adair-turns-the-pages-1530755.html

3
closovsky•

Sounds good, I think I'll read it ...

1
TakeMyUsernameAgainMarxist-Leninist (Maoist)|SDS•

So your blaming him for having mental illness and flat out lying about him not reading Capital? Cool story.

0†
noname888•

Interesting passage re: Gramsci and Poulantazas

I was living in Ann Arbor at the time, attending graduate school at the University of Michigan. Together with some other folks who would later go on to create the TR editorial board in Boston (but at the time also living in Ann Arbor), we pulled together a collective and issued a pamphlet, “Against Dogmatism and Revisionism: Toward a Genuine Communist Party.” The pamphlet called attention to the crisis in the NCM, suggested that a principal source of the crisis was the theoretical poverty of the movement, and argued that the work of Gramsci, Althusser, Poulantzas, and others offered us the possibility of rebuilding the movement on new foundations. The pamphlet met with a favorable response; several thousand copies were sold around the country.

Given that Podemos and Syriza (yeah, yeah, I know...) also turned to Gramscian/Poulantzas (and Laclau, I think?) I'm intrigued by this discussion happening in the early '80s through the NCM.

2