Is this NM?

Got this card from overseas, and wanted to check to see if it's NM.

I've asked the sender if the card is NM and was confirmed that it is NM from the sender. I kind of doubt it.

Imgur1

Imgur2

I'm thinking of returning the card, and would ask the sender to cover the fees in returning. From US to Germany.

Edit: Front and Back Straight pics Imgur3 Imgur4 Imgur5

Edit2: Opened a case. Thanks for all the comments.

Posted Aug 29, 2015, 7:59 PM UTC · edited

042
SmallLion•

I consider that near mint.

2
Punkmaffles•

Pic 1 shows it covered in grime. Unsure though. Otherwise likes nm to me.

3
AnvilHands•

Yeah this is tough call. If it was a regular copy, I would accept it as NM without a problem. But people generally hold foils to a higher standard, and when you are picking one up at 5000+ points, you want the surface to be smooth and grime-free. I would be a little disappointed receiving this if OP didn't send me pictures ahead of time.

5
showstepsOP•

It is a foil Urborg :( 5000+ points as you mentioned and covered in grime and scratches.

2
Punkmaffles•

Then definitely Not near mint for a fifty thousand point card. Open a case and have it sent back.

1
MTGDrafts•

The grime is unpleasant but overall i still think it falls under NM. I would get the opinion of an admin though since their opinion is what matters.

2
showstepsOP•

Thanks. I guess i'll wait for an admin here, or open a case?

1
MTGDrafts•

might as well open a case. also now seeing the back id say that is SP

1
Wizard37administrator•

No.

2
showstepsOP•

Thanks,

1
Sparkisparki•

As a foil guy, I wouldn't call that NM. Scratches and grime like that do not make it NM, the same as if you got a non-foil cards like that.

1
showstepsOP•

Thank you.

1
Polythello•

Grime (which I know is much more visible and feel-able in real life than in this phone), plus bumped and wearing edges.

He should have checked with you first to see if you were OK with the condition, or just not sent it.

1
Umezete•

Bit late but grime and scratches kill foil value more than a few border nicks. Honestly knowing how hard it is for clouding to show on scans (It kinda looks like it might be clouded but can't tell) I doubt this is even sp.

1
KangaRod•

What is it exactly that you are taking issue with?

It looks pretty NM to me

0†
showstepsOP•

Foil card with scratches and grimy looking for a 5000 point + card.

4
KangaRod•

NM doesn't mean pack mint gem flawless 10/10/10/10/10 you know?

0
Puca_Noob•

I think OP might be a bit too picky on this one. He did capture a little dirt when he got the picture just right. What does the straight on front, and back of the card look like? Best to see those pictures, then ones of the flaws to get an overall view of the card.

1
showstepsOP•

Added more pics of front and back.

Thanks,

2
Mercury756•

I will say that the back looks pretty SP, but this whole business of complaining about stuff that can only be seen when a card is held in just the right way that a glare will show what cant be seen with the naked eye is some BS. If you can see it without doing all that, then fine, but otherwise wipe it down and get over it.

-2
Umezete•

Its clouding and grime, its very very visible to the naked eye but doesn't scan/photograph well.

I'm sure the card actually looks much worse in person, I've received foils like this and they're just atrocious.

1
showstepsOP•

Thanks,

Completely agree.

1
Mercury756•

Fair enough.

1
KangaRod•

Would you mind sharing your user name? If it's not too much trouble, I'd rather not trade with you in the future.

-3†
AnvilHands•

Show and I discussed this - it is the same German trader that sent me a grimey foil Damnation several months ago. I never made a stink about it, but apparently this trader has a habit of sending out SP foils without notice. You may be wise to block him if you are in the market for high-end foils.

5
KangaRod•

What do you guys mean grimy? Can you just wipe it off?

1
Umezete•

To be fair if you consider this nm I wouldn't want to trade with you either.

1
KangaRod•

So... Why exactly is this not NM? Because it has a bit of dust on it?

1
showstepsOP•

Thanks, i've already done it for you. Hope you find those duels you are looking for.

Cheers.

0†
KangaRod•

4 down, 2 to go

-4
Puca_Noob•

I agree. That card is a NM one.

0†